| Author |
Topic  |
|
|
jody
395 Posts |
Posted - 06/03/2003 : 2:58:21 PM
|
From Scott's link about Lessig in 2 part interview I came across the web site for Mr. Coase, a recent Nobel prize winner in economics. On his site is a lecture he gave calling on the field of economics to change. I find his work and calling to be very useful when discussing the economics of the old Copyright/IP cartels. On another site I got into some heated exchange with some individuals who didn't like that I wouldn't argue their way when it came to analyzing the Copyright/IP debate. One of them went so far as to say I obviously had never studied economics and didn't care to understand it. That was patently false, but I had to refuse the bait. Anyway, the gist of my jest at their economic fallacies centered around their over reliance on the work of Adam Smith and the mythical "invisible hand."
The link: http://coase.org/coaseremarks2002.htm
Remember his work and the subject of transaction costs when you discuss the need to change the old guard of copyright and intellectual property. The economic arguments made for and against the S-DMCA laws in summer study, should any study occur, will most likely leave out his concepts of externalities and transaction cost, but the brightest and highest paid thinkers on both sides of the issue won't. Be prepared when faced with the eventual economic arguments, I say. |
|
|
Dubber
441 Posts |
Posted - 06/03/2003 : 4:45:54 PM
|
quote: Originally posted by jody ...Adam Smith and the mythical magic hand.
I think you meant mythical invisible hand... <political tangent>The "invisible hand" is currently being wielded by "The Plunge Protection Team" which has been in place for a decade or so. Google it for more info.</political tangent> |
 |
|
|
jody
395 Posts |
Posted - 06/03/2003 : 5:28:29 PM
|
Return volley o< (don't you love badminton?)
I am currently reviewing some of the PPT links google unearthed. I imagine you were inserting the debate of whether any form of organized human control could substitute for the guiding principles Adam Smith espoused naturally arose within a free market system. I don't think you were taking sides on it necessarily just throwing it in.
When I challenge the simplistic economic arguments some might offer when defending their viewpoint on some debate I often look out for the over reliance many place on Adam Smith's "invisible hand". As great as Adam Smith was he is not the last prophet on economics; his invisible hand was a technique used to explain an emerging quality in the market systems he studied or theorized might exist. For anyone who followed in his tradition it became a point of belief rather than a fact, though they often forget the subtle difference. Much has been added to the body of economic knowledge since then and it is clear that the "invisible hand" is a bogey man. What most economic thinkers now realize is that there are verifiable processes which can be discovered to predict market effects; or conversely there are effects which cannot be accounted for with any known processes. But never the invisible hand! The end result is that one should never rely on old economic methods to explain or rationalize a system without first disproving the invisible hand. All inputs and outputs to an economic system must be established to verify with certainty that the processes will hold true; something Coase argues is a large, complex system we have never before tried studying. Ergo most simplistic economic arguments are probably wrong.
Now, if you have actually bothered to read all this you should know I enjoy wasting time rattling off on something I really don't know that much about, but sometimes it's just fun to make noise! :) |
 |
|
|
Tony
401 Posts |
Posted - 06/03/2003 : 5:53:48 PM
|
| Hmmm, the post-elves have struck again! Also, we may need to create a separate group for topics at this advanced reading level. :) |
 |
|
|
jody
395 Posts |
Posted - 06/03/2003 : 5:55:27 PM
|
| What would I do without them? ;) |
 |
|
|
Dubber
441 Posts |
Posted - 06/03/2003 : 8:11:44 PM
|
quote: Originally posted by Tony Hmmm, the post-elves have struck again!
Luckily, I could mostly remember what I had written to go back and correct the elves' mischevious behaviour in my post. :-)'
|
 |
|
|
jody
395 Posts |
Posted - 06/03/2003 : 10:37:47 PM
|
So it is late but something has really been bugging me about my earlier posts and the title of this thread. What the he!! was I thinking when I used/coined the term "tyranist". Okay, on the surface I was trying to play off the anarchist theme; you know, they call us IP anarchist so I call them IP Tyranist. Bad choice. Maybe it has some poetic justification but it just stuck in my craw the wrong way. So I am officially changing my terminology here. Those who seek more control over intellectual property than is reasonbly due, and who seek to cast all doubters of their claims as anarchist, are now officially known as "IP Tyrants". Damn the poet in me.
This from the Merriam-Webster OnLine Dictionary:
Ty-rant: Function: noun Etymology: Middle English tirant, from Old French tyran, tyrant, from Latin tyrannus, from Greek tyrannos Date: 14th century 1 a : an absolute ruler unrestrained by law or constitution b : a usurper of sovereignty 2 a : a ruler who exercises absolute power oppressively or brutally b : one resembling an oppressive ruler in the harsh use of authority or power |
 |
|
|
Dubber
441 Posts |
Posted - 06/03/2003 : 11:57:31 PM
|
quote: Originally posted by jody What the he!! was I thinking when I used/coined the term "tyranist". ... Those who seek more control over intellectual property than is reasonbly due, and who seek to cast all doubters of their claims as anarchist, are now officially known as "IP Tyrants".
Jody, just to assuage your sensibilities, I changed Tyranists to Tyrants in the Topic Subject line. I left 'tyranist' in all your previous posts so the post above makes sense overall. -Aaron :-)' |
 |
|
|
Tony
401 Posts |
Posted - 06/04/2003 : 12:57:26 AM
|
The post-elves asked me to pass along their apologies:quote: Our Dear Mister Dubber: We didn't mean to hurt your feelings when we corrected the three misspellings in your post, and deleted the part that made no sense once we had corrected the topic post. We thought it was what you would have done yourself, had you used your admin powers to correct jody's quote rather than write about its incorrectness.
As for his use of "Tyranist," we left it alone since the word actually exists, though not in the abridged dictionary, and seemed to fit jody's use. If you wish to correct it to what you believe that he meant, please do so, but please don't bad-mouth the post-elves for doing our jobs the best we can, or we'll come after your posts while you sleep!
Thanks,
The Post-Elves
|
 |
|
|
Dubber
441 Posts |
Posted - 06/04/2003 : 11:10:15 AM
|
quote: Originally posted by Tony The post-elves...
While I occasionally correct egregious fat finger errors (I'm neither a good grammarian nor a gud speler) in other folks posts with administrator power, I would rather not change the content of their posts. What people say is what they say, and I feel it is not my place to alter it (beyond fat-finger errors) but rather to respond for clarification. Should the person posting a comment want to go back and change their post due to my response, great, they have that ability. I'm merely uncomfortable with editing the contents of 'OPP' (other people's posts) |
 |
|
|
Tony
401 Posts |
Posted - 06/04/2003 : 1:11:02 PM
|
Dubber, this is where we differ. If someone in the group that I know pretty well types an obviously wrong word or uses a malformed url, I try to correct it if I see it. The "Magical Hand Scandal," as I'm sure it will be titled in any future tomes about the early history of TNDF, is probably the second most extreme example of this, the most extreme being when I recently deleted two duplicated topics as well as the apology of the poster to preserve consistency.
The fix in this current debacle involved correcting a single word which the poster had already stated was incorrect, as well as only that portion of your response which quoted and pointed out the incorrect reference. This fix, it seemed, restored Jody's post to its intended meaning, which was my sole purpose in doing the edit in the first place. The word "Tyranist," however, is used elsewhere, seemed applicable, and so I did not touch it for fear of modifying jody's meaning.
I've more to say on this, but as this is hopelessly off topic already, I'm moving that discussion here.
|
 |
|
| |
Topic  |
|
|
|