Tennessee Digital Freedom Forum
Tennessee Digital Freedom Forum
Home | Profile | Register | Active Topics | Members | Search | FAQ
Username:
Password:
Save Password
Forgot your Password?

 All Forums
 Organization
 Meetings
 Wrap up of 5/13 meeting with Sen Person

Note: You must be registered in order to post a reply.
To register, click here. Registration is FREE!

Screensize:
UserName:
Password:
Format Mode:
Format: BoldItalicizedUnderlineStrikethrough Align LeftCenteredAlign Right Horizontal Rule Insert HyperlinkInsert Email Insert CodeInsert QuoteInsert List
   
Message:

* HTML is OFF
* Forum Code is ON
Smilies
Smile [:)] Big Smile [:D] Cool [8D] Blush [:I]
Tongue [:P] Evil [):] Wink [;)] Clown [:o)]
Black Eye [B)] Eight Ball [8] Frown [:(] Shy [8)]
Shocked [:0] Angry [:(!] Dead [xx(] Sleepy [|)]
Kisses [:X] Approve [^] Disapprove [V] Question [?]

  Check here to include your profile signature.
Check here to subscribe to this topic.
    

T O P I C    R E V I E W
SKozicki Posted - 05/13/2003 : 11:23:57 AM
Attendees (from our group):

Scott Lyon
Theo Morrison
Scott Kozicki

Senator Person was in attendance, along with Ann Carr, Stacy Briggs, Holly Salmons (from Johnson & Carr), as well as two other individuals whose names I didn't get (one of which was a member of the Republican Party research group).

Stacy initiated the meeting by presenting some language that they wish to amend the bill with. Specifically:

--quote--
to the end of the definition of "communication service":

A "communications service" does not include any communication device which a communication service provider may require its customers to use in order to lawfully receive any communication service.
--unquote--

Stacy informed us that this was at the request of more retail associations, and that they felt this language should appease our concerns about legal devices being declared illegal under this statute.

Our response was that we didn't feel this was adequate for two reasons. One, being that it is circular language with the rest of the bill (vaguely carving out something that is vaguely defined elsewhere). Two, that this doesn't prevent the CSP from declaring that a device is being used as an intent to defraud them, still allowing them to declare it illegal.

The conversation quickly moved from fine points about language to the larger issue at hand, namely that the cable co's are trying to legislate what you can and can't do with signal that you've lawfully procured. This resonated with Sen. Person, and he took control of the conversation, stating that he has 3 digital cable boxes, multiple devices that fit the definitions of 'multi-purpose devices', and plant to make it all work. He pays $152/mo for all of this. We said that he could save money by purchasing some of those devices outright instead of 'leasing' them from the cable co today, but this bill would eliminate that option. This got him excited.

He went on to say that he wants to be able to use wireless, so that he can surf around the house. We said that under this legislation, he could not lawfully do that unless he procured the equipment from the CSP and paid whatever fees the cable co assessed to him per month. Doing otherwise, intentionally or not, made him a felon through the inference in section (f). This did not make him happy.

We talked about the broader issues of how other utilities are sold and utilized, and he noted that cable is not packaged in the same way. Then we started to get into specific language, namely section (f)'s inference of guilt. When it became obvious that neither Ann nor Stacy could adequately argue for the provision, Sen. Person made the suggestion that we strike subsection (2) under (f). Ann said that they could look at it, but didn't commit to it.

It quickly became obvious that we were not going to get to all 9 of my 'Christmas list' of changes I'd like to see in the bill in an hour. So Sen. Person asked "can't we make this simpler? Does it need to be 14 pages to make theft illegal?" We used that as an entre to suggest that we believe that this bill is flawed from the beginning, and that its intent and spirit have completely been lost within ambiguity. He agreed, and suggested that we come back with 'our version.' We never specifically stated that we have a complete amendment, but we hinted that we would follow up with him later today with more language.

He asked if we got all of our changes incorporated into the bill, would we be satisfied, to which we replied 'no'. We characterized the bill initially being terrifying, and the amendments have simply dressed up the terror, but not eliminated it. Scott suggested that they were swelling the problem instead of fixing it. We said that if ALL of the changes were incorporated, we could _live_ with the bill, but not be comfortable with it. Sen. Person reiterated that we should come back with 'our version', in essence, what we would be comfortable with. Our reply was that we would follow up later today.

Sen. Person wrapped up the meeting stating that he wants legislation that he can understand, and that doesn't cause any unwanted side effects. His specific quote was 'we want to stop cable theft, but protect my son's freedom to use technology'. (after a detailed description of his son's setup, which made me drool) Our response was that *this* was the sole reason why we were present and we would follow up.

Theo is going to make the rounds today to build support for our amendment, including Sen Person. I will follow up with a more presentable list of specific language changes, but I already cautioned them that I would not be suggesting language as much as I was requesting to strike things. I will post this document as soon as I complete it.

I consider this morning's meeting a tremendous win. Sen. Person understands the consequences far too well, and appears genuinely interested in doing The Right Thing™. He essentially tee-d up every argument we had, and I believe that our response will fit with his expectations.

Of note, after the meeting, my conversation with Ann Carr centered around their desire to utilize the Senate version of the bill (i.e., the bill that we amend together) as the one to drive the resynchronization process. She stated that they wished to have everything ironed out by next week's Senate Judiciary Hearing, at which point, they'd use that document to replace the House document.
3   L A T E S T    R E P L I E S    (Newest First)
Dubber Posted - 05/13/2003 : 11:06:06 PM
Dam*! I wish I'd been able to juggle work stuff out of the way to attend that one. Even as merely a silent presence. I am not really surprised that Senator Person had more going on than he let on. And I am especially glad that he apparently spoke with, and listened to, the son for whom he has purchased all that nice sounding stuff.
Bravo, gentlemen!
-Aaron W. Dobbs
:-)'
I think that letting Anne & Stacey know ahead of time that you'd more want to strike language than offer it was entirely appropriate, and forward thinking as well. There's more to strike from this bad boy than adding will fix.
jody Posted - 05/13/2003 : 12:19:10 PM
On the face of it it sounds like quite a bit was accomplished. Of course this is the same senator capable of whispering sweet nothings while... This is certainly more than I imagined would be done. Now it's Theo's turn. How will today's events shape tomorrow's hearing?
loosifer Posted - 05/13/2003 : 11:31:31 AM
Wow, that sounds great!

Definitely interesting, and definitely motivation to get our amendment in good shape.

--
If a `religion' is defined to be a system of ideas that contains unprovable statements, then Godel taught us that mathematics is not only a religion, it is the only religion that can prove itself to be one. -- John Barrow

Tennessee Digital Freedom Forum © 2003 TNDF.net Go To Top Of Page
Snitz Forums 2000