| T O P I C R E V I E W |
| Dubber |
Posted - 05/02/2003 : 2:58:23 PM EFF / ACLU / PublicKnowledge ? have put together a mailing list: [email protected] to discuss nationwide SDMCA stuff. Florida is in the hot seat today but there has also been relevant discussions for TN I'll quote them here below as I get them... |
| 6 L A T E S T R E P L I E S (Newest First) |
| Dubber |
Posted - 05/02/2003 : 3:22:48 PM quote: From: "Nathan T. Mitchler" <nmitchler publicknowledge.org> Subject: RE: [sdmca] Fwd: FW: URGENT: HB 457 & SB 213 - OPPOSE Date: Fri, 2 May 2003 12:09:19 -0400 To: "'Fred von Lohmann EFF'" <fred eff.org>, "'Robert A. Costner'" <rcostner rboc.net> Cc: "'Alex Curtis'" <acurtis publicknowledge.org>, "'Gigi Sohn'" <gbsohn publicknowledge.org>, "'Mike Godwin'" <mnemonic well.com>, <[email protected]>
Fred's point is particulary strong in regards to TN. Their current laws on the topic are already quite strong and encompassing.
See TN STATS 39-14-149, 39-14-104 and 39-14-601 Nathan
[empahsis added by me...] |
| Dubber |
Posted - 05/02/2003 : 3:20:42 PM quote: From: "Gigi B. Sohn" <gbsohn publicknowledge.org> Subject: RE: [sdmca] Fwd: FW: URGENT: HB 457 & SB 213 - OPPOSE Date: Fri, 2 May 2003 11:50:47 -0400 To: "'Fred von Lohmann EFF'" <fred eff.org>, "'Robert A. Costner'" <rcostner rboc.net> Cc: "'Alex Curtis'" <acurtis publicknowledge.org>, "'Mike Godwin'" <mnemonic well.com>, "'Nathan Mitchler'" <nmitchler publicknowledge.org>, <[email protected]> I couldn't agree more. The foci should be on the necessity of the law and the language that makes it illegal for consumers to attach legal devices to their cable and internet services.
-----Original Message----- From: Fred von Lohmann EFF [mailto:[email protected]] Sent: Friday, May 02, 2003 11:49 AM To: Robert A. Costner Cc: 'Alex Curtis'; 'Gigi Sohn'; 'Mike Godwin'; 'Nathan Mitchler'; [email protected] Subject: Re: [sdmca] Fwd: FW: URGENT: HB 457 & SB 213 - OPPOSE
Robert,
While I agree with much of what you've said, I think it's a very bad idea to let this become a debate about the losses that arise from theft -- that's getting on their turf. The reality is that all the "theft" that he is talking about is already illegal under existing law. That's where I would start -- ask him what kinds of "theft" that he's talking about aren't already illegal.
Fred
|
| Dubber |
Posted - 05/02/2003 : 3:19:14 PM quote: From: Fred von Lohmann EFF <[email protected]> Subject: Re: [sdmca] Fwd: FW: URGENT: HB 457 & SB 213 - OPPOSE Date: Fri, 2 May 2003 08:48:31 -0700 To: "Robert A. Costner" <rcostner rboc.net> Cc: "'Alex Curtis'" <acurtis publicknowledge.org>, "'Gigi Sohn'" <gbsohn publicknowledge.org>, "'Mike Godwin'" <mnemonic well.com>, "'Nathan Mitchler'" <nmitchler publicknowledge.org>, <[email protected]> Robert, While I agree with much of what you've said, I think it's a very bad idea to let this become a debate about the losses that arise from theft -- that's getting on their turf. The reality is that all the "theft" that he is talking about is already illegal under existing law. That's where I would start -- ask him what kinds of "theft" that he's talking about aren't already illegal.
Fred
On Friday, May 2, 2003, at 07:15 AM, Robert A. Costner wrote:
Rep. Rob Briley (sponsor of the TN bill) said
... real problem regarding theft of voice, video, and data communications ... I know that none of the interested parties, including yourself, would condone that behavior as that cost is passed on to legitimate purchasers of these communications services.
While not today, I would be more than happy to produce a reasoned argument against this. First of all, there is no "real" cost in theft of services that is passed on to the consumer. This is a myth which has been perpetuated by the MPAA, RIAA, and SPA over the years. There is no increase in cost to the fixed infrastructure. What is actually being expressed in Rep. Briley's $130 million theft figure is the maximum amount of unrealized income for services that often likely would not be purchased anyway. Had this figure been for vandalism to the existing infrastructure, then yes, it would be a cost to pass on to the consumer. But it is not.
Secondly the problem is in the definition of theft. In the past special interest groups have tried to define theft in interesting ways. At one time the use of a VCR was purported to be theft. Not watching commercials on TV has been called theft. MP3 players when first introduced were said to be theft.
Countering this statement is not in fact our strongest argument. However, I cannot sit still easily while someone perpetuates such a logical fallacy upon the public.
-- Robert
|
| Dubber |
Posted - 05/02/2003 : 3:17:13 PM quote: From: Dan Barrett <[email protected]> Subject: Re: [sdmca] Fwd: FW: URGENT: HB 457 & SB 213 - OPPOSE Date: Fri, 2 May 2003 11:10:11 -0400 To: "Robert A. Costner" <rcostnerd rboc.net>, "'Alex Curtis'" <acurtis q publicknowledge.org>, "'Gigi Sohn'" <gbsohn ww publicknowledge.org>, "'Mike Godwin'" <mnemonic ta well.com>, "'Nathan Mitchler'" <nmitchler ta publicknowledge.org>, <[email protected]> On Friday 02 May 2003 10:15, Robert A. Costner wrote: > Countering this statement is not in fact our strongest argument. However, I > cannot sit still easily while someone perpetuates such a logical fallacy > upon the public.
Quick off-topic: My big question is, if the rep in question has never been in contact with the MPAA, how did he happen to get a copy of the MPAA's model legislation? Dumb luck? Just out surfing one day?
Back to the argument: TN folks, I think you'd do well to challenge the rep to identify the statutory purpose of the bill via the following questions:
- what evil does the bill seek to remedy? - what is the remedy? - what current statutes cover the offense in question? - when has the current law been insufficient to prosecute an offender?
Then ask the lawmaker to identify the _exact words_ within the bill which restricts it only to online theft of movies.
Best, d.
|
| Dubber |
Posted - 05/02/2003 : 3:02:41 PM quote: From: "Robert A. Costner" <[email protected]> Subject: RE: [sdmca] Fwd: FW: URGENT: HB 457 & SB 213 - OPPOSE Date: Fri, 2 May 2003 10:15:48 -0400 To: "'Alex Curtis'" <acurtis b publicknowledge.org>, "'Gigi Sohn'" <gbsohn c publicknowledge.org>, "'Mike Godwin'" <mnemonic d well.com>, "'Nathan Mitchler'" <nmitchler e publicknowledge.org>, <[email protected]> Rep. Rob Briley (sponsor of the TN bill) said
... real problem regarding theft of voice, video, and data communications ... I know that none of the interested parties, including yourself, would condone that behavior as that cost is passed on to legitimate purchasers of these communications services.
While not today, I would be more than happy to produce a reasoned argument against this. First of all, there is no "real" cost in theft of services that is passed on to the consumer. This is a myth which has been perpetuated by the MPAA, RIAA, and SPA over the years. There is no increase in cost to the fixed infrastructure. What is actually being expressed in Rep. Briley's $130 million theft figure is the maximum amount of unrealized income for services that often likely would not be purchased anyway. Had this figure been for vandalism to the existing infrastructure, then yes, it would be a cost to pass on to the consumer. But it is not.
Secondly the problem is in the definition of theft. In the past special interest groups have tried to define theft in interesting ways. At one time the use of a VCR was purported to be theft. Not watching commercials on TV has been called theft. MP3 players when first introduced were said to be theft.
Countering this statement is not in fact our strongest argument. However, I cannot sit still easily while someone perpetuates such a logical fallacy upon the public.
-- Robert
-----Original Message----- <snipped>see 3:00 post
|
| Dubber |
Posted - 05/02/2003 : 3:00:29 PM quote: From: Alex Curtis <acurtis at publicknowledge.org> Subject: [sdmca] Fwd: FW: URGENT: HB 457 & SB 213 - OPPOSE Date: Fri, 2 May 2003 09:15:34 -0400 To: Gigi Sohn <gbsohn ayt publicknowledge.org>, Mike Godwin <mnemonic aty well.com>, Nathan Mitchler <nmitchler a publicknowledge.org>, [email protected]
this is the reply letter from TN sent by rep. rob briley--who claims to never have been approached by the mpaa on this bill. for those rallying the troops in TN, apparently, he's having a meeting in his office on may 6, 10:00am. we need some folks in attendance for this one.
thanks, alex
-----Original Message----- From: Rob Briley [mailto:[email protected]] Sent: Friday, May 02, 2003 8:25 AM To: 'Ann DeVille' Subject: RE: URGENT: HB 457 & SB 213 - OPPOSE
There has been much misinformation spread about this bill, my intent in sponsoring it (contrary to popular belief, I have never been contacted by anyone from the Motion Picture Association of America regarding this legislation, ever), what it accomplishes, and what it prohibits. I introduced this legislation because of a real problem regarding theft of voice, video, and data communications. The value of that theft last year is estimated to be between $100-130 million. I know that none of the interested parties, including yourself, would condone that behavior as that cost is passed on to legitimate purchasers of these communications services. Once the bill was introduced, parties from all sides began meeting to work out an amendment to clarify that to violate the provisions of this proposed law, one must have the intent to defraud or steal something that would otherwise have to be purchased. These parties have included consumer electronic manufacturers, computer software designers, computer network professionals, and librarians. It does not at all relate to copyrighted material, as those issues are pre-empted by federal law. The amendment also makes it abundantly clear that legislation would not make illegal legitimate computer designs or applications relating to networks and firewalls, nor the encrypting of data associated with those applications. I am continuing to work on the amendment to address any specific concerns. However, the vast majority of those who have contacted me have not seen and/or read the amendment to the bill. To help people understand what the legislation will look like as amended, I have scheduled a meeting in my office, 17 Legislative Plaza, on Tuesday, May, 6, at 10:00am. Please feel free to attend this meeting. I look forward to working with you to develop a piece of legislation that accomplishes my intent without compromising your legitimate activities.
Representative Robert W. Briley 17 Legislative Plaza Nashville, Tennessee 37243-0152 (615)741-2184 - phone (615)741-1041 - fax [email protected] <mailto:[email protected]>
|
|
|