Tennessee Digital Freedom Forum
Tennessee Digital Freedom Forum
Home | Profile | Register | Active Topics | Members | Search | FAQ
Username:
Password:
Save Password
Forgot your Password?

 All Forums
 Tennessee Technology Legislation
 Legislation
 House Bill Exclusions

Note: You must be registered in order to post a reply.
To register, click here. Registration is FREE!

Screensize:
UserName:
Password:
Format Mode:
Format: BoldItalicizedUnderlineStrikethrough Align LeftCenteredAlign Right Horizontal Rule Insert HyperlinkInsert Email Insert CodeInsert QuoteInsert List
   
Message:

* HTML is OFF
* Forum Code is ON
Smilies
Smile [:)] Big Smile [:D] Cool [8D] Blush [:I]
Tongue [:P] Evil [):] Wink [;)] Clown [:o)]
Black Eye [B)] Eight Ball [8] Frown [:(] Shy [8)]
Shocked [:0] Angry [:(!] Dead [xx(] Sleepy [|)]
Kisses [:X] Approve [^] Disapprove [V] Question [?]

  Check here to include your profile signature.
Check here to subscribe to this topic.
    

T O P I C    R E V I E W
stickman Posted - 05/09/2003 : 08:23:37 AM
The amendment to the original house bill now contains several exclusions for government agencies and financial institutions. The bill is being pushed as a "cable theft" law, but why would these organizations need exclusions from stealing? You'll notice that there is a clause qualifying when a financial instition is allow to intercept, decrypt, and retransmit your communications. Unfortunately there is no clause stating the law enforcement and government agencies are restricted to acting under existing federal, state, or local laws. Under this bill, the TBI can intercept your email and other communications without cause.
15   L A T E S T    R E P L I E S    (Newest First)
Dubber Posted - 05/14/2003 : 4:18:47 PM
quote:
Originally posted by Rick
Um... draft it?

Mod previous post: Funny
<gah, still can't type>
Rick Posted - 05/14/2003 : 3:45:52 PM
quote:
Originally posted by bucket


I wonder what the cable industry & the MPAA had to do to get legislation that allowed them to use both the civil and the criminal part at the same time ?



Um... draft it?
bucket Posted - 05/14/2003 : 2:54:31 PM
bobaloo mentioned that, in this bill, "you can be hit with both criminal and civil action".

Tennessee's bad check law has a criminal part and a civil portion. You have to choose which one to want to use. One or the other. Not both.

I wonder what the cable industry & the MPAA had to do to get legislation that allowed them to use both the civil and the criminal part at the same time ?
bobaloo Posted - 05/14/2003 : 09:21:51 AM
You can be hit with both criminal and civil action. Usually criminal is first. After that, civil. It is considered bad form for criminal to follow civil.
The prosecutors would decide whether to use the criminal statutes and arrest you. The "offended" business would decide whether to sue.
And to make the point again, as others here have made, this strange law is on a twenty four hour clock. (Does it start over at 00:00 everyday?) Every 24 hour period is a new crime.
So, if little Johnny starts his homework* late and crosses from midnight to 12:01 am the next day using his wi-fi notebook, he has commited two crimes. Not one. Even though it is clearly one event. And remember, two felony convictions look worse on little Johnny's record, than one.
Moral... don't burn the midnight oil.
(*this assumes little Johnny is not immune from prosection via the education cut-out.)

bobaloo!

ps
The ishmanlaw.com site, bucket posted, is a disturbing read.
SKozicki Posted - 05/14/2003 : 12:23:47 AM
It is both a criminal statute AND a civil statute. You can be charged not only with a violation of the criminal code under this bill, but according to section (e)(1), also existing laws such as a theft of service (39-14-104) or a theft of cable television (7-59-109) IN ADDITION to the civil penalties that are itemized in the bill. The court would basically decide which book to throw at you, but potentially, they could throw them all.
Dubber Posted - 05/13/2003 : 10:52:30 PM
Respondeat Superior sounds pretty cruel. Of course, fantasy football isn't "really" gambling. It's just another game. Like chess. Chess isn't gambling either. Of course, no one wants to admit they put their "token" on the loser in the Big Blue vs Kasparov match, either.
Of course, breaking the law isn't really gambling either.
What am I saying? Getting up in the morning isn't gambling either; nor is driving to work.
But wait, all of the above in this post *is* a form of gambling.
  • Fantasy Football: you bet you can build a better team
  • Chess: you bet you (or 'your' designee) can beat your opponent
  • Breaking the law: you bet you won't get caught
  • Getting up: you bet you will survive the day
  • Driving: you bet your life that no one will take your life through negligence / road rage

bucket's link has an excellent example of how this could snowball to affect business. Sorry for the extneded babble to get to the point. G'night.
Dubber Posted - 05/13/2003 : 10:37:45 PM
Actually, the way I read it (bill + amendment) the cable co basically gets to pick the way they want to go, Criminal Case or Civil Suit.
I'd expect them to go Civil Suit against consumers like me, and reserve the Criminal Case for those 'infringers' whose 'offenses' are particularly egregious (from the cable cos' p.o.v.) such as a recalcitrant active TiVo user, a wireless networked home user, or heaven forbid a family of four with more than one computer.
bucket Posted - 05/13/2003 : 2:04:42 PM
If you peeps want learn more about the doctrine of respondeat superior and the Internet, here is a good place to start:

http://www.ishmanlaw.com/resources/Respondeat_Superior.pdf

Another thing- bobaloo's article dealt with civil law. Briley's amended bill, a proposed substitution for TCA § 39-14-149, is a criminal statute. That do make a difference.
bobaloo Posted - 05/13/2003 : 11:41:49 AM
Test Case? Me?

....run, run, run.

That is precisely what is so disturbing about such unbalanced legislation as this. Defense is unaffordable to almost all mortals. And the law affords no punishment to corporations who may act in error.
SKozicki Posted - 05/13/2003 : 10:44:31 AM
This is a tactic that I'm pursuing with regards to private schools being exempt. That is, if you have a home school, you are exempt from this statute.

Unfortunetly, the language specifically excluding private schools still hasn't made it into the amendment floating around.

Even still, do you want to be the test case for this?
bobaloo Posted - 05/13/2003 : 08:56:40 AM
I found this at http://injury-law.freeadvice.com/property_damage/exempt_property_damage.htm

"There are numerous laws which make public entities - such as federal, state, and local governments, immune from tort liability. Employees who are acting within the scope of his/her authority while working for an employer can be relieved of liability by the employer under the doctrine of "respondeat superior" (let the master answer). Under this doctrine, the employer is responsible for the acts or omissions of its employees when the loss or harm occurs while the employee "is on the job" and is performing work that s/he is supposed to be doing. If the employee is acting outside the scope of his/her employment at the time the damage to property occurs, the doctrine of respondeat superior will not insulate him/her from liability to the injured party."

So it would seem that it is unnecessary for the law to mention employees for them to have immunity. Apparently students (the component required to make a school a school) would also have this immunity while acting within the school framework.
So taken to the logical extreme...
Little Johnny, while doing school homework, can "attach" any device to his isp he pleases. Anything forbidden to us is not forbidden to the special class.
Good for Johnny.


bobaloo!
bucket Posted - 05/13/2003 : 04:03:24 AM
§(d)(2) of the amended bill, which exempts from liability "State or local government agency, municipality,or authority...", probably covers state schools. That clause may be construed as covering employees, but I kinda doubt it. I wouldn't think that that it covered students at all unless they were, say, teaching assistants. A TA, an employee of the school, might be exempted.

I wish that Glenn were on board to comment on this.
SKozicki Posted - 05/12/2003 : 2:00:16 PM
It is unclear whether the language could be applied to a student or employee. You'll just have to get sued to find out basically.

As for why these exclusions are there (and why they will remain there despite the 'adequate intent to defraud language') is because they make rich and powerful interests complacent about the bill.
bobaloo Posted - 05/12/2003 : 12:40:12 PM
Tony, I thought that might be it.
As I understand from reports on this forum, Betty Nixon made the case for Vanderbilt, and I assume, other private institutions to be excluded.
Questions I have for our representatives...
Do these exclusions apply only to the institutions themselves or do they include employees, students and guests? Shielding them from civil and criminal liability?
Would this also exclude these same people (if covered) from communications they do from their homes? Many login from work we know. And if they were accused could claim they were doing "homework."
And of course it must said again, why are carve-outs needed at all if this is a just bill? These exclusions appear to place 100's of thousands of Tennesseans above the law.

bobaloo!
Tony Posted - 05/12/2003 : 11:17:55 AM
bobaloo, §(d)(2) exempts any "State or local government agency, municipality, or authority," which would include public schools, colleges and universities.

In nathan's excellent report on the 5/7 House Judiciary Committee hearing, he noted:

"Rep. Cochran asked why there were exemptions, to which Beauchamp replied that no 'real exemptions' were required due to the 'intent to defaut' clause. The exemptions were added just to make certain. Rep. Cochran further questioned why public colleges were exempt but not private institutions. Mr. Beauchamp admitted that this was an oversight and that it would be corrected in the amendment."

No such correction made it into HA395, apparently.

Tennessee Digital Freedom Forum © 2003 TNDF.net Go To Top Of Page
Snitz Forums 2000