| T O P I C R E V I E W |
| SKozicki |
Posted - 05/20/2003 : 7:27:30 PM Well well well. It's been a whirlwind day today. Forgive me for blogging. Let me see if I can shake some of the marbles out and recap:
+ I met with the House Republican Caucus this morning @ 9am to discuss HB457. This was in response to the proponents of the bill presenting to the caucus the week before. We presented a pretty short set of 2 examples of how this bill would have unintended consequences and could arbitrarily sweep up folks acting legally. We also articulated how even with amendments and langauge mechanic work, the bill is fundementally flawed from the standpoint of reducing (eliminating?) cable service theft. Some great questions were posed, and I felt like the meeting went well, with several attendees offering to support our cause, and making recommendations on potential sponsors for our amendment. A BIG thanks to Matthew White, the Republican Research Analyst, for coordinating this and giving us the opportunity to be heard.
+ The House Budget sub com met briefly, but quickly rolled our bill to tomorrow (Wednesday) @ 9am. We expect to have heated debate at that meeting, and hopefully (as promised) will have a chance to speak and articulate our opposition. Please come if you can!
+ Shortly thereafter, I was invited by Sen Person to sit down and meet with him and Ann Carr to talk about the current status of the bill. We talked briefly about our amendment, and Ann rebutted a few issues that we still have concerns about in their language. I reiterated that we felt like the legislation was fundamentally flawed. I asked Sen Person what his intentions were for this afternoon's Judiciary Hearing meeting. He stated that his intention was to pass it, as is. I asked him if he felt like this was an issue that was worthy of more time to allow everyone the ability to further refine the language. His reply was that he was committed to trying to work out compromises, but that they were dealing with time constraints within the process. It was suggested that Beauchamp and I meet at 1:30 to further discuss specific concerns. I asked him specifically if summer study was an option, and was told no. I told him that I would gladly attend the meeting, but that it was likely to not be productive, since both sides have fundamental differences in how they want to approach the problem.
+ I arrived for 1:30's meeting in Sen Person's office to be greeted by two gentlemen representing Sharp and Phillips, along with Beauchamp, Stacy Briggs, David Wilson, and Sen Person. Immediately we were surprised by Sen Person's temper as he related a story of how he was being contacted by the Chattanooga Times, who questioned him about his son being a member of the TCTA and on Charter Communication's board. He made it clear that in no uncertain terms, he was handling this situation with absolute integrity. I asked him if he was directing his anger at anyone specifically, to which he replied 'to whoever suggests that this is improper.' I stated that I was not aware of anyone associated with TNDF which was stating that he was acting improperly. I did not get a chance to reference the fact that we had discussed it. But I plan to address it f2f tomorrow with him so there is no misunderstanding.
Thereafter we were handed some amendatory language which was drafted 'to address our concerns.' Aaron will post the amendments later on the site. The shocking surprise was the removal of all of section (f). This was a pretty gleeful moment for me, since (f) is the ratchet from which most evil in the bill springs. The other amendments are summarized as follows:
- a clause that formally excludes private educational institutions. We were expecting this, but it is not clear if home schools would fall under this definition. - a clause that states that breeches of contract with the SP are not a violation of the statute, but then obliterates its usefullness with a qualifying statement that reads 'unless the device is being used to obtain a communications service for compensation without payment by that person.' This is a step in the right direction, but perhaps the worst worded amendment I've seen yet. We've already said that if the SP is not collecting revenue from a service that it provides, but you are partaking of that service through lawfull means (by let's say, using an alternative device), then you are guilty. This does nothing to change that. - a clause that essentially reduces the 'device' count for infractions by not counting devices that are required by the SP in order to receive service. This was meant as a carve out for people to procure their own equipment, but it's also useless in this regard because the SP still maintains control over what that device is, and says nothing about future devices or using devices in ways in which they were not intended. It does, however, reduce the device count for infractions, and so raises the .00001% possibility that someone might be guilty of the misdemeanor offense instead of the felony offense to .001%. Close, but no cigar. - A few mechanical changes that help to clean up section (d) and (d)(3). As if cleaning up was even possible at this point.
The meeting quickly spiraled into Heated Discussion(tm) as the retail guys (Bruce and Adam) and Beauchamp squared off on language. I interjected at specific points, usually to clarify examples of unintended consequences and potential abuses. For the most part, I studied the language. My first reads were that these might actually defang the bill altogether. If I could suggest getting rid of any occurance of the word 'possess' and all of section (g), we'd go home happy. But I couldn't even get to that point.
I spent some time with Stacy discussing whether their proposed amendments satisfied our concerns. It was at this point that I had studied it enough to say unequivicably, 'no.' The language submitted, as I indicated above, is definitely a nod (hint of a nod?) in the right direction, but it misses the boat completely by rendering itself useless in the same sentence with 'unless' and 'except' type language. I let her know that I was appreciative that they were still trying to address our concerns, but that this was unsatisfactory and that we were still opposed to the bill as a whole.
All discussion of section (g) was pretty much tabled because Sen Person emphatically stated that his intent was to catch people who were stealing and punish them. When I suggested that the punishment spelled out in this bill is not consistant with other crimes, I was rebuked. Beauchamp's argument about the severity needed by multiplying per device and per day was because someone who is stealing service can potentially partake in hundreds of dollars in services per day. This assumes that if you have a pirated cable signal, you're going to order every pay per view, watch every premium channel simultaneously, and record it all without their consent. I can't argue with that, but I think it's definitely not within the realm of possibility.
I left the meeting so that I could prepare for the Senate Judiciary Hearing, and to make sure that we didn't go so far as to infer Sen Person's involvement was improper.
The Senate Judiciary com meeting went as expected. Since our issue is a hot potato, and it's unclear to the proponents whether they have the votes or not, our issue gets pushed to the back of the bus. At 4:50, with an impending Democratic Caucus meeting @ 5pm, it was announced that we would roll the bill to next week's meeting. The committee spent a good amount of time articulating that they were appreciative of the people in the gallery who were interested in the bill. Many people had traveled to hear testimony, and none had occured.
It was at this moment that Sen Person stated that he was incensed that anyone would suggest any impropriety on his part in this matter, and that he would invoke "rule 13". It was not clear to me what this was until after the hearing was adjorned. He essentially recused himself from the bill's vote from here forward. This was a huge disappointment for me, despite him being a proponent of the bill. I am concerned that his cooperation and ability to create consensus will greatly diminish. I am concerned that this could slow or even stop progress that we've had with the bill. I hope to address this personally with him. Sen Person thanked our group for participating and reiterated that he's spent a great deal of time (an exagerated number of weeks. he said 6, when in actuality it's been less than 3) working with us to address our concerns. All I could do was nod in approval. I wanted to make an official statement for the record that showcased our approval, but I didn't want to violate protocol.
With that, we continue on.
I should have some more detailed analysis and talking points based upon the amendments that have been flung out today. Hopefully by late this evening. |
| 5 L A T E S T R E P L I E S (Newest First) |
| SKozicki |
Posted - 05/21/2003 : 12:11:16 AM quote:
I agree with Scott. Removing Section (f) is a big deal, but just puts us back into the same boat with all the other states (i.e. we're not ending up with something WORSE than what they got). But this statute is still a mess, and their communication service device and terms of service carveouts don't actually accomplish anything (i.e. they're exempted, unless they violate section (a)? What kind of exemption is that? In a sense, everything's exempted until it violates!!)
Agreed. In fact, the more time I've spent with the language tonight, the more I realize that it's crap.
quote:
It's unfortunate that Person recused himself like that, because he was honestly very reasonable to deal with (though was it Beauchamp or Person who said summer study was not an option?).
It was Person. I'm not sure why he took such a hard line on this. He's got a 37 year career though, so I'm sure he has a good reason.
quote:
I wonder who's doing the piece for the Chattanooga Times. Has anybody been contacted (I guess Tony is our media-figurehead, with a television and radio interview under his belt)? If it's just a "scandal" piece, I think we'd do best to stay out of it, but if it's a piece on the legislation overall, we might want to throw in our two cents.
His name is Chris. I have spoken with him off and on this week. I talked to him tonight and made our position clear about this issue. He was unaware of Person recusing himself. From our discussion, I think they are pursuing it as purely a reporting of events. |
| Scott Lyon |
Posted - 05/20/2003 : 10:45:39 PM I agree with Scott. Removing Section (f) is a big deal, but just puts us back into the same boat with all the other states (i.e. we're not ending up with something WORSE than what they got). But this statute is still a mess, and their communication service device and terms of service carveouts don't actually accomplish anything (i.e. they're exempted, unless they violate section (a)? What kind of exemption is that? In a sense, everything's exempted until it violates!!)
It's unfortunate that Person recused himself like that, because he was honestly very reasonable to deal with (though was it Beauchamp or Person who said summer study was not an option?). I wonder who's doing the piece for the Chattanooga Times. Has anybody been contacted (I guess Tony is our media-figurehead, with a television and radio interview under his belt)? If it's just a "scandal" piece, I think we'd do best to stay out of it, but if it's a piece on the legislation overall, we might want to throw in our two cents.
Have we distributed copies of our bill to the other Senators on the Judiciary Committee? I'm beginning to believe the only reason we got the concessions in the new amendment is that they are encountering heavier resistance than expected. Let's keep ratcheting up the pressure and keep Tennessee from getting rolled into the SDMCA snowball! |
| SKozicki |
Posted - 05/20/2003 : 8:15:11 PM Nathan,
It's unknown how they will proceed. I would expect them to have enough time to roll it together, but they could potentially retract language. And as we've seen, I'm sure language will be inserted at the last second. |
| Dubber |
Posted - 05/20/2003 : 8:11:18 PM Here's the link to the three amendments (all in one .txt file separated by "---'s") http://dubber.org/tndf/030520amendments.txt (or in one .pdf file to doublecheck) http://dubber.org/tndf/030520amendments.pdf -Aaron W. Dobbs :-)' |
| nathan |
Posted - 05/20/2003 : 8:09:38 PM Question on the amendment process.
When the Senate Judiciary Committee meets to discuss SB213, will they first patch SB213 with HA395, and then ammend today's changes, or will today's ammendments only be applied to SB213?
Quite frankly, I suppose anything is possible at this point. |
|
|