| T O P I C R E V I E W |
| Dubber |
Posted - 10/29/2003 : 1:25:22 PM I had to run before the CEA (well, Brian and Arnold) got to present their testimony. My impressions of today's hearing are as follows: - Betty Nixon of Vanderbilt gave a nice overview of what she and her group discovered/discussed this summer - no specific points leap to mind and no glaring errors iirc.
- Jonathan Band attempted the unenviable, he tried to tie everything
(Copyright and it's specific carve-outs, technologies' impacts on the exceptions, and the broadness of the language coupled together with the big stick of the statutory damages in the May 27th version of the ammendment) together and relate all of it to the current discussion. The difficulty encountered was mainly that "people in the know" about some subjects/topics approach ideas with certain pre-suppositions or pre-determined definitions of those ideas. I think I understood where he was coming from and where he wanted to go, but, then again, I'm a librarian in my day job. :-)' I think the presentatino was fine for some audiences, but a bit beyond the experience of the Committee members - Scott Lyon (Yay! one of 'ours' finally got to speak for more than 5 rushed minutes in a hearing!) Started out and made excellent points (excellent in my mind because I/we have been pushing for just this sort of thing for a while, now) which seemed to resonate well. But later in the discussion he seemed to be trapped by a couple questions/questinoers. Which I'll elaborate in a separate reply to this topic after I've cogitated on them awhile.
- As I said, I regretfully missed hearing Brian and Arnold. Hopefully another attendee will flesh out their messages.
We, and I think the Committee to a large extent, cannot come to an agreement on what 'thing' (access, content, or service) is actually being stolen. -Aaron W. Dobbs |
| 15 L A T E S T R E P L I E S (Newest First) |
| SKozicki |
Posted - 11/10/2003 : 10:03:38 AM Of interest:
http://www.efga.org/archives/00000019.html
This is a link to the CEA and CERC proposed legislation. |
| kelargo |
Posted - 11/08/2003 : 2:46:19 PM quote: It may not be unlawful to own a gun, but it may be unlawful to own a bazooka or vehicle-mounted machine gun. One of the things I think we tried to accomplish in our bill is to make this distinction. We can punish people for committing acts against the public (or against the service provider) without necessarily outlawing the object that was used in the crime or offense (the gun in the above example). But at the same time, there are some items (such as the bazooka) which have very little legitimate use but pose a greater risk of harm, and these items it may be reasonable to prohibit (i.e. devices with no substantial use other than committing a theft of service).
This is a very good point and you it exactly what I am saying.
Bazookas and such are regulated devices, at the federal level (ATF), not at the State level.
As such, if a device should be unlawful, it should be regulated at the Federal level, not the State level. quote:
quote: What can the owner of this unlawful device do regarding the depreciation of their unlawful device, if it was used for commercial reasons, such as Network Management and Troublshooting services.
- Not sure how this fits into the bill. Could you clarify the question please?
A person owns a device lawfully. All of a sudden, the device is unlawful. The person who owned the device is now breaking the law and must dispose of the property.
How is the owner going to get reimbursed for the lost value of the property?
The owner was able to depreciate the property on their Federal income tax as a business expense. That is not longer possible.
quote: - This gets tricky, because it's mixing state and federal issues. The federal government (a la Congress) has power over "interstate commerce", which they don't share readily with states. Basically, states can't pass laws which would unduly hinder interstate commerce. In order to avoid coming into federal conflict, the bill would have to be read as evaluating the device at point of origin and point of destination, and purely transporting the device across the state as freight would be excluded (Courts try to construe laws in a way to keep them constitutional, so I think this is how a Tennessee court would read the law, but it's anyone's guess if this is what actually happened).
Creating a law as nebulous as this reads, without any certifying process to guarantee indiviudal freedoms, is wrought with conflicts of Interstate Conflicts. |
| Scott Lyon |
Posted - 11/03/2003 : 10:26:00 PM quote: Originally posted by kelargoWho certifies a device as being Unlawful? What does it cost a manufacturer to certify their device is Lawful?
- There isn't a certification process under their proposed bill. The decision of whether or not a device is "unlawful" depends on the outcome of litigation started by someone challenging the possession, sale, use, etc. of a particular device. So, I suppose the best way to answer this question is: the manufacturer would pay its own attorneys fees defending its device in court.quote: Can a TN Manufacturer export their certified TN Unlawful device into another State where the device is Lawful?
- Under their proposed bill: no. The bill does not respect state borders, so long as some part of the offense is committed in Tennessee. Thus, it is illegal to import or export a device into or out of Tennessee, even if it is legal in other states.quote: If a Manufacturer in another state sends their product to TN resident, who is liable for this TN Law? The Manufacuter in another state or the resident in TN?
- Under their proposed bill: both (depending on who had an "intent to defraud" (an undefined term, which nobody knows how to apply right now)). The unlawful device is illegal to make, illegal to possess, and illegal to use, if you have an intent to defraud (or presumably, enable another to defraud).quote: What if a person in another state where the device is lawful moves to TN- What procedure must this new resident perform to avoid breaking the Law for owning a suddenly new Unlawful Device? What does this cost?
- The person must avoid transporting the device into the state. The cost: ?quote: What if a Manufacture in another State, where the device is lawful, ships the device overnight to another state where it is also lawful, but the shipment travels across TN state line. Who is breaking the Law? Manufacuter in other state, Resident in other state or shipping company in TN? (located in Memphis, perhaps?)
- This gets tricky, because it's mixing state and federal issues. The federal government (a la Congress) has power over "interstate commerce", which they don't share readily with states. Basically, states can't pass laws which would unduly hinder interstate commerce. In order to avoid coming into federal conflict, the bill would have to be read as evaluating the device at point of origin and point of destination, and purely transporting the device across the state as freight would be excluded (Courts try to construe laws in a way to keep them constitutional, so I think this is how a Tennessee court would read the law, but it's anyone's guess if this is what actually happened).quote: Who pays for the ceritification?
- There is no certification process under their bill.quote: How does a manufacture provide updates to their product and avoid accidently creating an Unlawful device?
- Under their proposed bill, I don't know if this can happen. If the analysis depends on a state of action (possessing, selling, assembling) and a mental state (intent to defraud), I'm not sure that modifying the device without changing these other two conditions will affect the legal status of the device.quote: How expensive is this certification to perform for "time to market" value add to the cost of creating a new product?How can the certifying agency ensure the new product will not be exposed to other manufacturers who are also having their product certified? Who could possibly loose market competitive edge from a spy at the certify agency?
- There is no certification process.quote: What happens when a product is Lawful with one TN Service Provider and Unlawful with a different Service Provider?
- The device isn't really "lawful" to anyone at any time. It's just a question of whether someone wants to claim that a device is unlawful. Every provider can at any time claim that a device is unlawful and that you have an intent to defraud. Even if you succeed, the issue is not res judicata for the next provider, who can also sue you.quote: What happens to a resident who has a Lawful device with one Service Provider and switches to a different Service Provider who declares the device as being Unlawful?
- See the response above.quote: Who is responsible for informing the new user their device is unlawful?
- Under their proposed bill: no one. They don't have to give any notice at all, of anything.quote: How is the new user informed that their device is unlawful?
- Under their proposed bill: they are served with a summons, or the police seize their equipment.quote: What can the owner of this unlawful device do regarding the depreciation of their unlawful device, if it was used for commercial reasons, such as Network Management and Troublshooting services.
- Not sure how this fits into the bill. Could you clarify the question please?quote: Can a manufacturer of a Unlawful device export their product to another Country, where the device is Lawful?
- Under their proposed bill: no. As long as the device has some connection to Tennessee, this Tennessee law would apply.quote: Again, What exactly is an Unlawful Device?
- It could be anything under their proposed bill. The bill does not limit the definition (to avoid excluding devices the service providers may want to outlaw).quote: Can devices really be unlawful? or just the ACTIVITY and USE of the device be considered unlawful?
- We have some good discussion in this forum about the risks of confronting exclusively conduct, and why this may be one of the problems with their bill.quote: Is it unlawful to own a gun? Or is it Unlawful to shoot and kill someone with a gun?
- It may not be unlawful to own a gun, but it may be unlawful to own a bazooka or vehicle-mounted machine gun. One of the things I think we tried to accomplish in our bill is to make this distinction. We can punish people for committing acts against the public (or against the service provider) without necessarily outlawing the object that was used in the crime or offense (the gun in the above example). But at the same time, there are some items (such as the bazooka) which have very little legitimate use but pose a greater risk of harm, and these items it may be reasonable to prohibit (i.e. devices with no substantial use other than committing a theft of service). |
| kelargo |
Posted - 11/03/2003 : 9:53:36 PM > If you can prove this, even in a preliminary hearing or motion > to dismiss, you can get yourself out of litigation.
Nothing like being intimidated with litigation...
>and btw: it's better to have a law on the books which specifically > describes a standard for evaluating devices, than to try to have to > guess whether other, more ambiguous laws, apply
I still dont understand the criteria for evaluating what is unlawful. In my previous post a listed around 16 issues that are not addressed in this law and have dire consequences.
Ken |
| kelargo |
Posted - 11/03/2003 : 9:40:28 PM Regarding competition with cable Service Providers...
Cable Service Providers can open up their systems in several ways to promote competition.
1. They can permit co-location of IP Intenet based services and let subscribers choose a different ISP to deliver Internet access. They have fought hard against this and it appears not to be recognized or appreciated as an option.
For example, If you buy DSL services, you can buy it from Bellsouth, Earthlink, AOL, etc... the physical plant is still owned by Bellsouth. These other providers are co-locating and renting time from Bellsouth's capital infrastructure to provider their own branded DSL service. I understand the established players are fighting hard to make next generation equipment exempt from this requirement.
2. This same process can be provided by cable companies to provide a more diverse channel selection and promote video signal transmmission diversity. The video can be delivered as streaming RTP video signal and locally distributed to a specific analog/digital channel.
3. In Fairfax, VA the local government now permits Cable competition. The cable provider must demostrate the ability to provide cable service to 80% of the population in three years. I believe in this situation, the new competing cable company must lay down their own plant, but I am not sure. The companies up there are Comcast and Cox with Starpower providing new services.
In the first two cases, the Cable Service Provider is a Transport Service of digital information. The higher value added layer can be provided by the Content Provider, such as a competing ISP or Video Content Provider.
I dont think the industry is not looked at in this manner, but it should be.
Why?
To promote diversity and separation of power and authority. You do not want to have one overlapping law that transcends several different Industries promoting conflicts of interest and overzealous restrictions without any options for the consumer.
Ken
|
| kelargo |
Posted - 11/03/2003 : 9:21:07 PM >It is Diebold. I would have ignored it as a typo, >but you did it twice.
You're right, its not a typo, just a brain fart. :-)
Ken |
| Scott Lyon |
Posted - 11/03/2003 : 2:55:14 PM quote: Originally posted by kelargo
>We just want to prohibit devices which have no legitimate purpose, >which will only be used to commit a theft of service. We want to make >it illegal to traffick in these devices or use them to commit theft >of service.
I dont like this idea...who is going to certify the device as being unlawful? What happens if a device is certified unlawful but it really is not? Who is liable for loss of income for being blacklisted. Or is used lawfully somewhere else? Why should this law restrict another industry?
Activities should be unlawful, not devices.
There isn't a list of "unlawful devices". Nobody certifies them, there's no "stamp of disapproval"....they're just devices, until somebody tries to claim that they're "unlawful devices" under our bill. To qualify under our bill, they would have to prove that the device has no substantial alternative use other than the theft of a communication service.
Language like this is what made the RIAA stop chasing the P2P networks, because that software had (in copyright law) substantial non-infringing uses. Similar thought, applied to devices now: in order to defend the device, you only have to demonstrate that the device is capable of a substantial use other than the theft of communication services. If you can prove this, even in a preliminary hearing or motion to dismiss, you can get yourself out of litigation. However, this might only turn you loose from the "unlawful device" claim. If you actually used the device to steal service, you'll have to answer for theft of service.
On top of all this, just because a Shelby County Circuit Court judge decides a device falls into this category doesn't mean that another judge has to follow suit.
All in all, this is a good thing for device makers and users. Unless a device is just a pure communications theft device, you have nothing to worry about (and btw: it's better to have a law on the books which specifically describes a standard for evaluating devices, than to try to have to guess whether other, more ambiguous laws, apply). The types of devices included will be outlawed in Tennessee anyway, so we might as well keep the restrictions as narrow as possible to avoid unintentional consequences. |
| SKozicki |
Posted - 11/03/2003 : 2:17:05 PM quote: Cable companies compete against over the air transmissions, and they compete with satelite companies. They only have a natural monopoly over wire based delivery as the cost of competeing buildouts would be insane. In the end whether or not they are a monopoly and required to follow the same type of rules that telcos have had to for a while is whether or not the alternatives are considered viable or not. In this case, anyone outside of a major city probably wouldn't have one problem with setting up a satelite dish. In the city might be a little different, but then over the air transmission is better. In the end, there is competition, and it keeps cable prices at least some what in check.
Be careful here. While you can say that each of these methods of transmission compete with each other, they are not by any means on a level playing field. Your analogy is like comparing automobiles, motorcycles, and scooters as 'methods of transportation'. Sure, they all get you to where you want to go, but no marketing muscle is ever applied in the automotive field to compete with motorcycles or scooters. They are competeing against like-kind. So it's more accurate to say that they are virtual monopolies. They are governed and restricted in different degrees and even by different organizations. Technically, they are all the same. But that's not the way our world looks at them.
We are on the cusp of something. That being that convergence has effectively 'happened' and we are still wrestling with the vestages of an old paradigm of looking at things. Yes, content providers provide content and access providers provide access, but the two are so intertwined - not just in implementation, but in business model and investment - that it's difficult to make the distinction. I think if you sat down with most access CEO's, you'd get them to quickly admit that they have no competencey in providing content other than to procure access channels to it. BUT, they would never admit on the record that they are not pursuing those business models as well. It is their only hope for continued growth for and from the investment community.
A fundemental principal that gets forgetten here is that content drives access. You want more access to get to more and better content. The more services are offered (ie reasons) then the more access you'll want. This has already happened with the Internet. It was nifty when you could read a static page that someone threw up in England from your modem in TN back in the day. As services got more elaborate and comprehensive, our demand for better and faster access grew - quickly! What has lagged is TRADITIONAL content (ie TV!). We are moving there. Things like TiVo and VoD and HDTV and other interactive scenarios will push the industry there. But the pace is glacial compared to the Internet (which had no real precedence and certainly a much smaller audience to migrate).
In the end, it will be a windfall for all involved. Just as video tape sales were to the industry in the 80s. Why can't I watch the local Detroit feed for a Red Wings game because my cable co won't carry it? There's no reason to today. It's not only possible, but ridiculously practical. It could be revenue generating if done right.
So I think that splitting content and access would be the logical thing to do. However, the forces that be will resist this probably more vehemently than what you're seeing with these proposed laws. There's no future in access. There's no incentive to spend another few billion to upgrade to Fiber To The Home if you cannot get a return on that investment without sharing the services and content revenue streams. This is the pearl that the telcos and cablecos are using in the shell game with the FCC. Give us control over content and we'll build the network of the future. Don't give us control, and we will sit on our hands and do nothing while the world passes you by. This is why the cable SPs are paying the lobbying muscle to enact the MPAA's model bills. |
| critch |
Posted - 11/03/2003 : 1:42:17 PM quote: Originally posted by kelargo
>We just want to prohibit devices which have no legitimate purpose, >which will only be used to commit a theft of service. We want to make >it illegal to traffick in these devices or use them to commit theft >of service.
I dont like this idea...who is going to certify the device as being unlawful? What happens if a device is certified unlawful but it really is not? Who is liable for loss of income for being blacklisted. Or is used lawfully somewhere else? Why should this law restrict another industry?
Activities hsould be unlawful, not devices.
and in another post... >If you plan on harping on this point, you will probably get shut down >by having the legislaters tell us that a judge is unlikely to allow a >charge continue for sharing that occured 100% inside your home. They >will point out the intent will mean the sharing to your neighbors in >their homes.
Fair enough. But the Service Providers sell Bandwidth. Content Providers sell Content. The two industries should be separated- similar to local and long distance telephone service. Content is Transported over Service Providers network.
One law should not address both industries since the lines blur and cause this reaction. BTW: How many counties in TN have more than one cable company? Are they not a monopoly for the most part in TN?
Cable companies compete against over the air transmissions, and they compete with satelite companies. They only have a natural monopoly over wire based delivery as the cost of competeing buildouts would be insane. In the end whether or not they are a monopoly and required to follow the same type of rules that telcos have had to for a while is whether or not the alternatives are considered viable or not. In this case, anyone outside of a major city probably wouldn't have one problem with setting up a satelite dish. In the city might be a little different, but then over the air transmission is better. In the end, there is competition, and it keeps cable prices at least some what in check.quote: Anyone following that Seibold Voting both story...? Its free speech vs copyright issue? Seibold's attempt to stifle information concerning the defects of their product with a law like this would be horendous.
it is Diebold. I would have ignored it as a typo, but you did it twice. |
| kelargo |
Posted - 11/03/2003 : 1:24:38 PM >We just want to prohibit devices which have no legitimate purpose, >which will only be used to commit a theft of service. We want to make >it illegal to traffick in these devices or use them to commit theft >of service.
I dont like this idea...who is going to certify the device as being unlawful? What happens if a device is certified unlawful but it really is not? Who is liable for loss of income for being blacklisted. Or is used lawfully somewhere else? Why should this law restrict another industry?
Activities hsould be unlawful, not devices.
and in another post... >If you plan on harping on this point, you will probably get shut down >by having the legislaters tell us that a judge is unlikely to allow a >charge continue for sharing that occured 100% inside your home. They >will point out the intent will mean the sharing to your neighbors in >their homes.
Fair enough. But the Service Providers sell Bandwidth. Content Providers sell Content. The two industries should be separated- similar to local and long distance telephone service. Content is Transported over Service Providers network.
One law should not address both industries since the lines blur and cause this reaction. BTW: How many counties in TN have more than one cable company? Are they not a monopoly for the most part in TN?
Also, I like the Network Interface Device demarcation concept for cable, similar to the Telephone Service's NID. The inside wiring is your responsibility.
Anyone following that Seibold Voting both story...? Its free speech vs copyright issue? Seibold's attempt to stifle information concerning the defects of their product with a law like this would be horendous. |
| Scott Lyon |
Posted - 11/03/2003 : 11:50:44 AM quote: Originally posted by SKozicki I do think that the law should focus on the act and not the device, but then we're back trying to determine people's motives and grade them on a scale of severity. That can be very difficult, even in a criminal court. But I think that's where it needs to be determined instead of all this civil suit crap.
I think Scott hit on the fundamental problem with approaching this as a pure "punish actions" or "punish devices" approach. If we make the analysis about "punishing actions", we'll have to turn the analysis at some point to the intentions of the person making the action. To draw on the example from my speech, I can teach everyone how to use a splitter to get a second television connection in their home, even if the cable company wants to charge them for that second set. How do we distinguish between the midnight infomercial for "Scott's School of Home Cable Theft" and MTSU's course in basic engineering? Both circumstances could involve my illustration of how a splitter works and ways you can apply it. The fundamental distinction would hopefully be: did I tell you what I told you because I wanted to help you steal cable? If enforcement was in the hands of the prosecutor, I'd feel pretty unrestricted teaching the MTSU course and I'd sweat bullets over my midnight infomercial. But there's still room for the "close-call", like my e-mail to you describing how to install the splitter (not a public education forum, but not a private for-profit activity). I would hope that prosecutorial discretion would kick in and the college professors could sleep soundly at night. But depending on how a prosecutor wants to read that e-mail, I could still be in for some real trouble.
But the civil cases are where we see the real threats. Private civil actions don't have "prosecutorial discretion." At the end of the day, a private company does not have to answer to the public good; they have to answer to the bottom line. So even if a lawsuit is not in the public interest, but may prove profitable by restricting unfavorable technology, a private company has every reason to bring even a baseless lawsuit to prohibit my speech or keep me from the market, and make me go through the entire litigation process to trial in order to prove my innocence. The coercive penalties in a civil lawsuit don't come in the end-judgement; they don't need to. The coercive penalties are the litigation process itself!!!
Now, what about restricting devices? The approach we've taken is that we don't want to outlaw any technology which is already currently legal and can be used for legitimate purposes now. We just want to prohibit devices which have no legitimate purpose, which will only be used to commit a theft of service. We want to make it illegal to traffick in these devices or use them to commit theft of service. Admittedly, there are a lot of devices which would not fall within this category which may still be abused, BUT we should not prohibit legitimate devices simply because irresponsible people CAN use them for illegitimate purposes. Computers, telephones, crowbars, and hammers can all be used for illegitimate purposes, but the solution is not to take away all tools to stop the behavior. The solution is to punish the behavior and those who would abuse tools to break the law. |
| SKozicki |
Posted - 11/03/2003 : 10:21:17 AM oh by no means am I advocating the language I suggested. I was simply stating that if you wanted to counter that issue, you could draft language to address it rather than pronouncing that everything was illegal until you said it wasn't.
If anything, I believe that cable TV (to wit any) SP's should be forced to utilize the demarcation rule that telephony SP's use today. That is to say that once that signal enters my home, I may do whatever I wish with it, with whatever equipment I wish, so long as it doesn't interfere with the transmission or plant outside my home.
But we've gotta take this one step at a time. To suggest that cable be forced to uphold the demarcation rule is an FCC issue, not a state issue.
But certainly the example of people coming over to visit is a good one and has been used several times by us to illustrate the folly of this proposed law. Inviting someone over to watch a hockey game would be illegal explicitly under the proposed law. And that just goes to illustrate how this is really about content and not about access. Because the act of partaking in the content would trigger the law over access.
Regarding unlawful devices, there can be such a thing. Scott Lyon presented the example of the "Cable Stealer 2000" - a device whose sole purpose is to pirate cable. There is the possibility of such a device, and those devices should be rendered illegal. But what is 90% more common is the digital filter, which has a lawful purpose, but is being used to commit an illegal act. I do think that the law should focus on the act and not the device, but then we're back trying to determine people's motives and grade them on a scale of severity. That can be very difficult, even in a criminal court. But I think that's where it needs to be determined instead of all this civil suit crap. |
| critch |
Posted - 11/03/2003 : 07:35:12 AM quote: Originally posted by kelargo
>You could close this hole a little tighter though. I think you could >easily draft legislation that specifically says that only people who >are within a registered name/address domicile may utilize a service >AND that you are not profitting or selling those services to any >other party. You still might have some guy who thinks it's okay to >share his wifi cloud with any person who might wander by. I don't >think it's worth going after such a miniscule population.
This is a bad idea.
Service Providers Sell Bandwidth. Nothing else.
They dont even guarantee they sell bandwidth... its just "best effort". Unless you are a business and you might get some SLA... and perhaps two circuits from two different Service Providers utilizing different egress points... anyway...
But consider this ramification:
1. If someone is visiting me. I live alone. I have a heart attack. They call 911. Is that unlawful?
This is good, but isn't likely to be taken seriously.quote: 2. If someone is visiting me. and they ask if they can check their email I let them log in and surf to my.yahoo.com. Is that unlawful?
3. I have a wifi network in my home. The signal leaks out and someone gets in. Who cares?
In each case, a third person is utilizing my subscribed service.
Again, Service Providers only sell bandwidth. If they do not like how the bandwidth is being used, then they should find a different occupation.
Good examples, and good point here. As you show here, this isn't just about internet access. To the extreme is when your neighbors come over to watch a pay-per-view show, say a UT or 'Bama football game.quote: I fill a 5 gallon can with water. I am driving down the road. Someone is pulled over. They are thirsty. I sell them a gallon. Am I breaking the law? I'm just reselling my extra capacity. What if I give the water away? Am I breaking the Law?
The problem with this example is the fact that you purchased something that is finite and rarely comes with a contract when you purchase it. The bill is dealing with services. Some of the services are rate limited to the point of considering them finite, but it is still a service.
If you plan on harping on this point, you will probably get shut down by having the legislators tell us that a judge is unlikely to allow a charge continue for sharing that occured 100% inside your home. They will point out the intent will mean the sharing to your neighbors in their homes. |
| nathan |
Posted - 11/03/2003 : 07:00:32 AM Along the lines of your first group of questions...
Considering all the "unlawful devices" currently in TN, if this bill passes, who is going to inform all these owners/possessors that they are suddenly felons? What will thy do with the devices at that point? |
| kelargo |
Posted - 11/03/2003 : 06:01:42 AM >You could close this hole a little tighter though. I think you could >easily draft legislation that specifically says that only people who >are within a registered name/address domicile may utilize a service >AND that you are not profitting or selling those services to any >other party. You still might have some guy who thinks it's okay to >share his wifi cloud with any person who might wander by. I don't >think it's worth going after such a miniscule population.
This is a bad idea.
Service Providers Sell Bandwidth. Nothing else.
They dont even guarantee they sell bandwidth... its just "best effort". Unless you are a business and you might get some SLA... and perhaps two circuits from two different Service Providers utilizing different egress points... anyway...
But consider this ramification:
1. If someone is visiting me. I live alone. I have a heart attack. They call 911. Is that unlawful?
2. If someone is visiting me. and they ask if they can check their email I let them log in and surf to my.yahoo.com. Is that unlawful?
3. I have a wifi network in my home. The signal leaks out and someone gets in. Who cares?
In each case, a third person is utilizing my subscribed service.
Again, Service Providers only sell bandwidth. If they do not like how the bandwidth is being used, then they should find a different occupation.
I fill a 5 gallon can with water. I am driving down the road. Someone is pulled over. They are thirsty. I sell them a gallon. Am I breaking the law? I'm just reselling my extra capacity. What if I give the water away? Am I breaking the Law?
Ken
|
|
|