Tennessee Digital Freedom Forum
Tennessee Digital Freedom Forum
Home | Profile | Register | Active Topics | Members | Search | FAQ
Username:
Password:
Save Password
Forgot your Password?

 All Forums
 Tennessee Technology Legislation
 Legislation
 Proposed replacement to SB3101

Note: You must be registered in order to post a reply.
To register, click here. Registration is FREE!

Screensize:
UserName:
Password:
Format Mode:
Format: BoldItalicizedUnderlineStrikethrough Align LeftCenteredAlign Right Horizontal Rule Insert HyperlinkInsert Email Insert CodeInsert QuoteInsert List
   
Message:

* HTML is OFF
* Forum Code is ON
Smilies
Smile [:)] Big Smile [:D] Cool [8D] Blush [:I]
Tongue [:P] Evil [):] Wink [;)] Clown [:o)]
Black Eye [B)] Eight Ball [8] Frown [:(] Shy [8)]
Shocked [:0] Angry [:(!] Dead [xx(] Sleepy [|)]
Kisses [:X] Approve [^] Disapprove [V] Question [?]

  Check here to include your profile signature.
Check here to subscribe to this topic.
    

T O P I C    R E V I E W
Tony Posted - 03/02/2004 : 06:12:04 AM
Scott Lyon's proposed version of the "cable theft" bill is now online. Please review this document and give your feedback here. Thanks!
15   L A T E S T    R E P L I E S    (Newest First)
Scott Lyon Posted - 03/12/2004 : 2:52:37 PM
quote:
Originally posted by critch

What is the benefit to having a state level law that is essentially the same or similar to a federal level law?


To some degree, this is something we haven't discussed a lot throughout this process, but it's something implicit in the background. Basically, the state will pass legislation the same as or similar to federal legislation for several reasons.

One reason is state's rights. Throughout the lifetime of our nation, there has always been a conflict between an overarching federal government and local state governments. This tension was drawn into the Constitution and as the nation has grown, the power of the federal government has grown as well. However, states still feel that they should be allowed to legislate within their borders to protect their citizens (or in this case, their CSP's).

Sometimes, you'll also see states pass versions of federal statutes, but with small amendments tailored to the states. The theory behind this is that the federal law sometimes allows states to adopt MORE restrictive versions of the federal statute, to borrow the federal statutory framework but add on their own restrictions and penalties (ex: the state version of the CAN SPAM Act may include provisions that the Attorney General for the state can pursue a civil action against a violator to recover "damages", which gives the state a chance to raise revenues when the feds corner a spammer).

There's also an honor and dignity issue at play here. These are state legislators and they are charged with serving the interests of their constituents. To tell them "don't worry guys, we don't need you; the feds will take care of the whole problem for us" is a demeaning way to look at state legislatures. The Constitution envisioned Congress resolving disputes relating to "interstate commerce" (which has been expanded to include almost EVERYTHING) or certain other specific issues, while states had the power to legislate on the matters not explicitly granted to Congress. In the case of copyrights, that IS necessarily one of the issues granted to Congress and which Congress pre-empted the states on. However, communications law is something of a mixed bag (i.e with components in interstate commerce, but also purely local in some respects). State legislatures have been able to legislate on certain issues relating to communications services as utilities, without crossing into the signal/telecomm/interstate commerce issues Congress directed to the FCC.

All in all, it would serve us best to remind the legislators that some parts of the bill extend into pre-emptive federal territory, that Congress has already provided extensive protection to CSP's, but also indicating that Tennessee has laws on the books which need updating anyway, so we should use this as an opportunity to clean up the old laws, clear away any potential conflicts, and make a statement about Tennessee's commitment to innovation and technology (my $0.02).
critch Posted - 03/03/2004 : 12:52:59 PM
What is the benefit to having a state level law that is essentially the same or similar to a federal level law? So far Rick and myself can only come up with the idea of venue shopping. If so, couldn't the issue be raised that we need to remove the current theft law and defer to the federal law as final say. It would also allow that whole content issue to solve itself away by being at the federal level where copyright can be dealt with.
Scott Lyon Posted - 03/02/2004 : 10:08:50 PM
quote:
Originally posted by utman

I haven't had time to study it intently, but I would like to see the aggravating factors inserted in order to give the opposition less to complain about.
We could also use this as a "bargaining chip", along with the "plaintiff pays" provisions (which a defendant can assert anyway, based on frivolous lawsuit caselaw).
utman Posted - 03/02/2004 : 5:13:33 PM
I haven't had time to study it intently, but I would like to see the aggravating factors inserted in order to give the opposition less to complain about.
critch Posted - 03/02/2004 : 4:28:22 PM
I'm really not trying to spam the list with a lot of little changes, but here is some great food for thought. I have complained that I don't like the definitions section. I think we may have a way of effectively getting the definition of service provider changed. We could reference 47 U.S.C Chapter 5 Subchapter 1 Section 153, definitions. Specifically definitions 43-46 which falls in line with our agreed opinions here.
quote:
(43) Telecommunications

The term ''telecommunications'' means the transmission, between or among points specified by the user, of information of the user's choosing, without change in the form or content of the information as sent and received.

(44) Telecommunications carrier

The term ''telecommunications carrier'' means any provider of telecommunications services, except that such term does not include aggregators of telecommunications services (as defined in section 226 of this title). A telecommunications carrier shall be treated as a common carrier under this chapter only to the extent that it is engaged in providing telecommunications services, except that the Commission shall determine whether the provision of fixed and mobile satellite service shall be treated as common carriage.

(45) Telecommunications equipment

The term ''telecommunications equipment'' means equipment, other than customer premises equipment, used by a carrier to provide telecommunications services, and includes software integral to such equipment (including upgrades).

(46) Telecommunications service

The term ''telecommunications service'' means the offering of telecommunications for a fee directly to the public, or to such classes of users as to be effectively available directly to the public, regardless of the facilities used.

Also, 47 U.S.C. 207 may give us the right to damages if we prevail in a defense of theft.

Also upon further research I see that cable theft is already addressed here, TITLE 47 > CHAPTER 5 > SUBCHAPTER V-A > Part IV > Sec. 553. Unauthorized reception of cable service.

Can we argue for no need for replication I understand (3)(d) here allows the state to also enact, but shouldn't it be argued that why make a legal mine field of what is allowed in each state where the federal law looks fine. Maybe we need to repeal state law and allow federal law be final.

Interesting, This same section also allows for fees to prevailing party.
critch Posted - 03/02/2004 : 3:33:13 PM
Scott: I think you might want to look over this Q&A on the FCC site with regards to question 2. I've been throwing out a hypothetical of using a descrambler to avoid the additional decoder boxes from Comcast and the extra $4.95 per month they incur. Looks like there might be support in Federal law from 1934 to say that would be legal. Also I wonder if it could also be applied to the extra IP charge by ISP's such as Comcast.

Anyways, part of the reason for looking that up is that I remember when our cable bill was reduced due to the removal of the per outlet charge, and was wondering where that originated. I'll also have to go read the Communications act of 1934 to bone up on what may be relavent here to this bill, but it looks like this is where we need to go searching for where this bill further oversteps jurisdiction, or maybe a better definition of theft that could be used.
Tony Posted - 03/02/2004 : 2:35:45 PM
quote:
Originally posted by Scott Lyon

I know we can't get all our internal feedback together in time to sent a revised copy to the CEA and CERC, but if no one has any objections, I'd like to send them a copy of our bill for review and commentary...
Not an objection, just a caveat: Until more of us have had an opportunity to read and comment on your bill, it would be best to identify it as a draft document pending approval by TNDF. Once we get the redlined version and you've made changes to meet the yet-to-be-formed consensus, we'll call it the TNDF proposed bill and mean it.

TNDF'ers, please take the time to study Scott's bill and the comments that have been posted, and let us know what you think about it, and suggestions that will make it meet with your approval. Take what time you need but remember, sooner is better.
Dubber Posted - 03/02/2004 : 12:47:44 PM
Marc Pearl, the person sent by/for CERC, is head of "IT Policy Solutions" www.itpolicysolutions.com
We ought to bring him into the loop as well.
-Aaron
:-)'
Scott Lyon Posted - 03/02/2004 : 11:46:56 AM
I know we can't get all our internal feedback together in time to sent a revised copy to the CEA and CERC, but if no one has any objections, I'd like to send them a copy of our bill for review and commentary sometime tomorrow, so that hopefully we can discuss it with them before the week is out (and definitely before next Tuesday).
Scott Lyon Posted - 03/02/2004 : 11:10:52 AM
quote:
Originally posted by critch

I think your opinion of intent to defraud is flawed. Where is the trickery, deceit, or misrepresentation in using a cable descrambler on the end of a line that I have paid for service? If I tune into a channel that I do not pay for, it would be considered theft of service. Trickery, deceit, or misrepresentation all seem to require an interaction with another party.
And this may stem from my relative ignorance of the technology used, but let's say we're talking about a digital filter where the box DOES communicate back to the headend, but the filter blocks the signal. The interception of that signal may constitute "deceit" or "subterfuge" under the statute. But this is a problem in the existing law as well, with regard to cable descramblers. (BTW, "subterfuge" in Black's Law Dictionary, Seventh Edition, is defined as "a clever plan or idea used to escape, avoid, or conceal something"). Maybe we need to change the definition of "intent to defraud" to include language to tackle the use of decryption technologies (though I'm REALLY uncomfortable walking down this road even a little way, because we may not like where we end up).
quote:
For (a)(2), being a programmer, I would say that it is trying to do too much and needs to be broken apart. It explicitely covers a couple of tecnologies that shouldn't be dealt with together. It deals with credit card information, telephone numbers, and access codes. I'll think some more on how it is best broken down later.
I agree and think we might want to set the access code issue aside (and maybe borrow some language from the federal Computer Fraud and Abuse Act, but directed toward networks and services).
quote:
For (b), If you are receiving the content from a Internet source, how do you break down the service? This one is sticky due to the fact that the service is riding on top of another service. Of course it would probably just anooy Flourney to no end if we could explicitly write them out of this bill stating that the sale/rental of a copyrighted work is not a service and explicitely not covered under this law. In tailor making the definitions section to be tighter and possibly limited to some form of utility, we could eliminate the whole argument over what is content and what is a service.
And maybe I wasn't clear about this. I want to make this statute just about the signal, what the communications (by whatever technology) between the headend and your house/business/etc. That signal, whether it's a digital packet or whatnot, is just like the radio signal in the air: it carries information and content inside of it, but it is not content itself. Only when it is received and the signal is "translated" (trying to make this the type of explanation we can put in front of Briley) by a communications access device (like your radio, your television, your cable box, your cable modem) do you get access to the "content". Once the signal hits your house, it stops being a "signal/service" and becomes a content issue, which is a federal copyright issue.

Now, in the cable context, each channel could be read as a separate service, and if you decide to descramble HBO without having a subscription, your conversion of the signal into content is the violation. But the copyright parts of that (if you then sent the HBO signal to your TiVo and recorded all the content for a couple days) would be a federal copyright "fair use" issue (interesting question: can you have fair use of content, if you stole the service? My initial answer: yes, because the method of acquiring the signal is not related to the rights reserved to the copyright holder (unless you publicly rebroadcast the content, make copies of it, make derivative works, etc.)). In the case of On-demand or pay-per-view, these would just be separate services on the same line.

What about streaming over the Internet? Arguably, they'd like to make this a service wrapped within a service. But it's not a service directly from the CSP. It goes past the CSP and then to the streamer, and back to you. It's the communication of content over a line, shaped in the form of a service, like calling a pay-per-minute service. If you called on the telephone to a company that agreed, for a fee charged to your credit card, to read you poetry over your phone line, does it matter to them whose phone you're calling from? Streamers are a supplemental SOURCE of content and they communicate on the CSP's line, but the "service" they provide is not necessarily a "communications service" (like telephone, cable, satellite, etc. etc.) Is that any clearer?
quote:
I did mean the industry of cable descramblers and cell phone theft tools. I think you are right, and I keep wandering down both sides of that argument. I don't like what DirecTV did about the smart card readers, and see it falling in here too, but I also don't like the idea of people stealing service and making people like us pay for it.
Then, like every other theft law, the solution is reporting people who steal, not passing overly broad laws. To prevent shoplifting, do we want to prohibit people from wearing coats and jackets inside stores, or wearing clothing with pockets? We'd probably deter a lot of theft that way, but I kind of like having someplace to put my car keys.
critch Posted - 03/02/2004 : 10:23:33 AM
I think your opinion of intent to defraud is flawed. Where is the trickery, deceit, or misrepresentation in using a cable descrambler on the end of a line that I have paid for service? If I tune into a channel that I do not pay for, it would be considered theft of service. Trickery, deciet, or misrepresentation all seem to require an interaction with another party. In cell phone cloning, I could see misrepresentation being that your equipment claimed to be something else. In the case of a cable descrambler, they don't need to talk to the headend, and therefore don't trick anything nor do they claim to be something they are not.

For (a)(2), being a programmer, I would say that it is trying to do too much and needs to be broken apart. It explicitely covers a couple of tecnologies that shouldn't be dealt with together. It deals with credit card information, telephone numbers, and access codes. I'll think some more on how it is best broken down later.

For (b), If you are receiving the content from a Internet source, how do you break down the service? This one is sticky due to the fact that the service is riding on top of another service. Of course it would probably just anooy Flourney to no end if we could explicitly write them out of this bill stating that the sale/rental of a copyrighted work is not a service and explicitely not covered under this law. In tailor making the definitions section to be tighter and possibly limited to some form of utility, we could eliminate the whole argument over what is content and what is a service.

I did mean the industry of cable descramblers and cell phone theft tools. I think you are right, and I keep wandering down both sides of that argument. I don't like what DirecTV did about the smart card readers, and see it falling in here too, but I also don't like the idea of people stealing service and making people like us pay for it.

In (i)(4), the whole indirect service provider is a problem. It is through this section that the MPAA gets it's self into the TN courts. Comcast is who I consider my service provider, they in turn provide me access to HBO, but HBO is just reselling other people movies, so in the end is Winona Rider a service provider when I watch Girl Interupted? Indirectly she comunicated to me via the movie industry, HBO, and comcast.

I know that example is an extreme that a judge would laugh at, but it points out that the indirect provider is a problem. I can see it's original intent is probably so that some service like Movielink can claim to be a communications provider and be protected even though they don't have a TN presence, nor do they own or lease the wires upon which their "service" is delivered. I think they shouldn't be protected under this law, but rather stick to copyright law.
Scott Lyon Posted - 03/02/2004 : 09:41:37 AM
All in all, the bill could probably still use some polishing, but I've tried tackling several of our issues.
quote:
Originally posted by critch

I think the intent to defraud language still sucks in that it doesn't take into account the idea that some services a consumer can provide for themselves and avoid the cost from the service provider. Is it intent to defraud if you don't purchase the firewall option from your ISP but you turn around and buy a linksys at walmart? Is it intent to defraud to use a TiVo instead of using a PVR from Comcast, or subscribing to their video on demand service? Both of these actions would be an effort to avoid paying a service provider for a service.
But intent to defraud requires using trickery, deceit, or misrepresentation (see (i)(1)), competition is allowed under (f)(2), and sharing a service among multiple devices is allowed under (f)(1).
quote:
Section 1(a)(2) still potentially is broken with regards to a VoIP gateway.
Hmmm....I see your point on (a)(2)....what if we limited the language to "access codes" to avoid compensation to the CSP who provides the communication service the access code relates to (i.e. no using cable access codes to defraud cable, but a cable access code can't defraud telecomm)? Any suggestions on better phraseology please?
quote:
Section 1(b) may need to be modified still. Think of the bit of information provided by Flourney about internet delivery of movies. If you do something to fall foul of his law by sending the movie you just purchased to another computer under your control, what all devices are subject to confiscation? Home PC and any networking gear, Work PC and that networking gear?
I thought about this, and the only device subject to destruction is the device "used" to violate the statute. But once the service has been captured, you're not passing the "service" to the other device; you're passing the content. That makes it a federal copyright violation (possibly protected by fair use). That's the philosophy I've taken in this bill: right up until it is "received" in your home, it's a service, but once it's received (the signal converted for viewing, decrypted, whatever), it's now "content" protected by federal copyright law. The communications access device is the nexus where the signal converts into content. That's the way to draft this bill without treading into federally pre-empted territory. But the device itself isn't necessarily good or bad; it's what you do with the device, based on the permissions (and rights) you have that determines whether it's a violation or not.
quote:
Seems this is missing the language regarding the business of theft. There isn't a extra damages to be awarded for a company making large profit off of theft to be sufficiently discouraged from continueing to do so. Tigue and Trail seemed paticularly proud of that section.
I'm not sure what a company "in the business of theft" is (unless we're talking about the Gambino crime family). If we're talking about someone selling cable descramblers, I think we need to be really careful about this, because it will be enforced by a civil plaintiff. I would like Tennessee to be as friendly to tech manufacturers and retailers as possible, and I'm not about to easily let Comcast chase them off with threats of lawsuits unless they agree not to carry the next generation TiVo-like device. If "business of theft" means the landlord WiFi'ing his building: the industry can change its' business model to charge based on the amount of service used (so the landlord is paying for the amount of the utility coming into the building, no matter how it is redistributed - the lowest he can offer the resold service is at cost).
quote:
I still think the definitions section is still just problematic.
Which definitions in particular? I can work on some language fixes where the definitions are either too long or too short.
critch Posted - 03/02/2004 : 09:25:56 AM
I would like someone else to see if they could shoot holes in the idea that even this amended bill could potentially outlaw discount calling cards.

Two methods for it to fall afoul of the law:
  1. Calling cards use 1800 numbers to avoid paying the connect at a pay phone where the call originates
  2. Calling cards allow you to bypass the toll service offered on the phone line you subscribe to.
That means the purchase of the card then could make you a felon and the same for the person selling the cards.
critch Posted - 03/02/2004 : 08:30:47 AM
I don't think enough was modified to make this bill acceptable.

I think the intent to defraud language still sucks in that it doesn't take into account the idea that some services a consumer can provide for themselves and avoid the cost from the service provider. Is it intent to defraud if you don't purchase the firewall option from your ISP but you turn around and buy a linksys at walmart? Is it intent to defraud to use a TiVo instead of using a PVR from Comcast, or subscribing to their video on demand service? Both of these actions would be an effort to avoid paying a service provider for a service.

Section 1(a)(2) still potentially is broken with regards to a VoIP gateway.

Section 1(b) may need to be modified still. Think of the bit of information provided by Flourney about internet delivery of movies. If you do something to fall foul of his law by sending the movie you just purchased to another computer under your control, what all devices are subject to confiscation? Home PC and any networking gear, Work PC and that networking gear?

Seems this is missing the language regarding the business of theft. There isn't a extra damages to be awarded for a company making large profit off of theft to be sufficiently discouraged from continueing to do so. Tigue and Trail seemed paticularly proud of that section.

I still think the definitions section is still just problematic.
Dubber Posted - 03/02/2004 : 07:07:12 AM
I know stuff has been trimmed, but I have no idea what stuff. A redlined version would be most appreciated, but too late now as I am about to get in my car to drive down to Nashville and have no time to billdiff or otherwise play with it.

Tennessee Digital Freedom Forum © 2003 TNDF.net Go To Top Of Page
Snitz Forums 2000