| T O P I C R E V I E W |
| Dubber |
Posted - 04/23/2003 : 6:43:26 PM From: "Jay Kosturko" <jay@k...> Date: Wed Apr 23, 2003 9:43 am Subject: comparison of existing laws
Gang- I'm going to try to do a comparison between the existing and proposed law for the section affected by SB213. This would be an excellent time for the lawyers in the crowd to step forward, cause I ain't one of 'em. My first reading of 39-14-149 is leading me to a few scary conclusions; * This law *does* need to be overhauled. Badly. * Network Address Translation (NAT) according to the existing law is already illegal. * The most noticeable difference in the laws appears in the penalties. They are enourmously larger in the new law.
I'm headed down to apsu to do some further research on this.
Thanks, -Jay |
| 11 L A T E S T R E P L I E S (Newest First) |
| Tony |
Posted - 04/28/2003 : 06:59:30 AM I've added a link to http://kosturko.com/sidebyside.html in the annotated links section of the website. Great work, Jay! |
| jay |
Posted - 04/28/2003 : 02:47:15 AM I've got an updated one posted to kosturko.com/SideBySide.html I need to get the stylesheet up, so that it highlights the amendment. |
| Dubber |
Posted - 04/25/2003 : 7:23:43 PM FYI: Jay's side by side comparison is at: http://dubber.org/tndf/SideBySide.html |
| utman |
Posted - 04/25/2003 : 2:14:57 PM I plan to get my mission tomorrow at the meeting. I don't want to work all night tonight only to find out that someone else has been doing the same thing :) |
| jody |
Posted - 04/25/2003 : 12:02:28 PM Since most everyone here understands the technical implications of this as well or better than I do I would like to focus my participation on the legal process question. Perhaps we could divide are efforts into three parts: technical implications, economic and social implications, and political/legislative implications. As I have said, I would love to stick to the legislative process question and leave the technical to others in this forum. Perhaps someone else could focus on the social and economic impact the bills will have the general public. Issues in this realm include security, fair use, public domain, etc. |
| jay |
Posted - 04/25/2003 : 04:34:19 AM Jody Leavell had an great idea: <snip> Also, the process by which the legislation has been brought before the house and senate is dubious in that the benefactor of the legislation writes the legislation and merely asks lawmakers to rubber stamp it. This is an abdication of responsibility on the lawmakers part. To ask for input on the wording of legislation and its intent is okay, but to actually craft the legal document which the lawmakers sign is very undesireable. A better way of dealing with it would be to invite experts from both the consumer interest groups and the industry to participate in a workshop with lawmakers who actually draft the legal document. This especially critical knowing that many of the lawmakers really didn't understand the technical implications of the industry crafted document. </snip>
I think that rather than suggest a total drop of the bill, we could reccommend that the bill be rewritten by a group of both technology providers and consumers. This would ensure that the law is both updated to protect internet access (it is already as I read it), and does not trample the rights of consumers.
I think that the best mix would be 2 consumers to 1 provider. While they are sure to balk at this, I don't think that it would harm the providers in the least. I no more wish to harm my provider of bandwidth than I do my provider of water or electricity. On the contrary, I think that this mix would ensure that the providers continued to have a steady stream of satisfied consumers. This would benefit both parties.
Also, I've completed an initial comparison of the new and existing legislation with a few starter comments. Feel free to email me any comments that come of this. This should be on the site by mid morning. |
| Dubber |
Posted - 04/23/2003 : 10:40:10 PM From: "Shawn P. Garbett" <Shawn@e...> Date: Wed Apr 23, 2003 12:08 pm Subject: Re: [tndigitalfreedom] comparison of existing laws
On Wednesday 23 April 2003 12:48 pm, Luke A. Kanies wrote: <LK> In five years, all TV signals will be encoded digitally,and will be sent digitally to your HDTV. They will also almost definitely be encrypted. If it is illegal for us to decrypt those signals except through their devices, then we have lost our fair use rights.</LK>
This is an area that the legislature would understand--tvs.
Go back even simpler and take the analogy of plumbing. Let's say my service provider (Metro Water), dictates that I can only have one toilet per house. I put in two and attach them to the same pipe, then I'm in violation of my service agreement. Is this fair? No. What do they do to not care how many toilets I have, they treat it as a utility and charge based on usage.
Now to step it up to tvs, once television signals are all encrypted, then under this law if I attach more televisions in my house than allowed or use a digital vcr, or watch a DVD on my linux laptop, these things can all be made illegal under the "service agreement". Unlike the idea of "fair use".
For example, if I put five golden toilets in my house or have one old porcelin one, the amount of waste water I generate remains constant. There's only one of me. Why should it be controlled so heavy handed, to dictate the number of tvs, vcr usage, or number of toilets that I'm allowed?
Shawn |
| utman |
Posted - 04/23/2003 : 7:28:04 PM quote: * This law *does* need to be overhauled. Badly.
I think we would have a much better chance of success if we could propose our own set of amendments. If the current law really does need to be overhauled then we would be doing a disservice to everyone involved by not finding the best solution. |
| Dubber |
Posted - 04/23/2003 : 7:02:08 PM From: "Luke A. Kanies" <luke@m...> Date: Wed Apr 23, 2003 10:58 am Subject: Re: [tndigitalfreedom] Re: comparison of existing laws
On Wed, 23 Apr 2003, Scott Kozicki wrote:
<SK> I was thinking about this last night. Perhaps our strategy should be more along the lines that service providers (SPs) do not need a law to enforce their own service policies. Every SP has a TOS document that each customer agrees to be bound by. If a customer violates that policy, then they should expect to have their service terminated after several steps of mediation. But I don't see why the state should be involved in that relationship, either as watchguard or punitive executor. It's up to the SP to maintain and safeguard their own service.</SK>
Unfortunately, that's an easy answer here: The reason the state needs to be involved is for the people who don't actually have service contracts, i.e., are stealing service outright.
This bill attempts to address 1) stealing the service in the first place 2) doing stuff with the service you aren't supposed to do, and 3) what devices you're allowed to use to do the stuff you actually are allowed to do.
Number 1 is already illegal, and I don't think it's worth spending much (any?) time on that.
Number two is entirely encryption-related; that is, the thing they're most going to make illegal that currently isn't is decrypting media.
Number three is the kicker, and is in my opinion the weakest part of the bill, and thus the part most open to attack. This requires that the ISP approve all software and hardware we ever use, in every combination and iteration, which is just evil.
And for those who haven't read the EFF's line-by-line comments, I highly recommend looking over them.
<SK> If we try and say that there are already existing anti-fraud laws on the books that accomplish the goal of protecting SPs, then we're going to run into a situation where the bills will be modified to 'further define' those existing laws, rather than killing them outright. This is what has happened in TX.</SK>
Yeah, this is a good point. I read through the TX bills, though, and they weren't _nearly_ as problematic.
If we can focus on our future rights, especially WRT decryption of media we have fair use rights to, then I think we have the best shot at coming out of this with what we want, which is our rights, intact.
<SK> The analogy that was brought forth regarding Ma Bell's policy of only attaching Ma Bell's equipment is a good one. In today's world, consumers should have choice. We want to eliminate the possibility that with 'further defined' language in the bills, an SP still has the right to determine what equipment gets connected and what doesn't. This would open the doors to allow the SP to say that you need a $1000 NAT box if you're going to run NAT, effectively outpricing the market. This is still unacceptable.</SK>
And as I mentioned, once the SP provides what you want, you doing it with your own device constitutes "intent to defraud". What's worse, if the SP provides a $50 product but charges $5000, then you "cost" them $2000 according to this bill.
I would really like to somehow relate this to real theft. It reminds me of the Mitnick case, where Sun claims that Mitnick cost them $180million, but of course you never saw that listed on their SEC filing, i.e., they didn't actually lose that money.
Is there any way we can force the punishment to be related to _actual_ loss, the kind of loss that would be filed with the SEC, not these "virtual" losses, which really don't even count as loss of opportunity in most cases.
<SK> I think our strategy needs to be total eradication of the bills. With that strategy, we'll be lucky if we only get passage of the bills with some better definitions and much less punitive effect.</SK>
I concur. Get rid of them entirely; we need clear, concise laws, not this vague crap.
Luke -- We're not surrounded, we're in a target-rich environment! |
| utman |
Posted - 04/23/2003 : 6:48:48 PM Maybe instead of concentrating solely on killing the current bill, why don't we continue along these lines and offer a series of amendments that still accomplish the objective, but without the unintended consequences. |
| Dubber |
Posted - 04/23/2003 : 6:47:45 PM From: "Scott Kozicki" <scott@b...> Date: Wed Apr 23, 2003 5:46 pm Subject: Re: comparison of existing laws
Jay Kosturko writes:
<snipped full text of Jay's post which is included in parent>
I was thinking about this last night. Perhaps our strategy should be more along the lines that service providers (SPs) do not need a law to enforce their own service policies. Every SP has a TOS document that each customer agrees to be bound by. If a customer violates that policy, then they should expect to have their service terminated after several steps of mediation. But I don't see why the state should be involved in that relationship, either as watchguard or punitive executor. It's up to the SP to maintain and safeguard their own service.
If we try and say that there are already existing anti-fraud laws on the books that accomplish the goal of protecting SPs, then we're going to run into a situation where the bills will be modified to 'further define' those existing laws, rather than killing them outright. This is what has happened in TX.
The analogy that was brought forth regarding Ma Bell's policy of only attaching Ma Bell's equipment is a good one. In today's world, consumers should have choice. We want to eliminate the possibility that with 'further defined' language in the bills, an SP still has the right to determine what equipment gets connected and what doesn't. This would open the doors to allow the SP to say that you need a $1000 NAT box if you're going to run NAT, effectively outpricing the market. This is still unacceptable.
I think our strategy needs to be total eradication of the bills. With that strategy, we'll be lucky if we only get passage of the bills with some better definitions and much less punitive effect.
Thoughts? ~Scott |
|
|