Note: You must be registered in order to post a reply. To register, click here. Registration is FREE!
T O P I C R E V I E W
mwjones
Posted - 05/07/2003 : 7:50:02 PM Rep. Casada,
I have been following HB0457 and am very disappointed to hear that the House Judiciary Committee has recommended passage as amended and referred it to the House Finance, Ways and Means Committee. I have come across a local organization that has formed in response to this legislation for the purpose of education and protecting our current freedoms. I would encourage you to check out their website at http://tonyc.com/tndf/.
I’ve been trying to think of parallels of existing services and technologies to help myself understand this legislation. Telephone service is the first thing that comes to mind. I can’t imagine the telephone company presuming to be able to control how many and what type, brand, style of phone you can connect to your phone lines. And even further, telling me what I can say while using that service and prohibiting everything else. And if the HB0457 legislation had been in place 20 years ago, I would bet there would not be an internet today. The first publicly accessible internet connections were through telephone lines. And those connection were made by modulating digital signals into sound (hence the MODEM) and sending them over a telephone line and then demodulating the sound back into digital format. You might say it was a “misuse” of the phone system. Was it done with “intent to defraud”? Who’s to say? Some would argue that Voice over IP (Converting sound to digital format, transferring it over the internet and then converting it back to sound) is an attempt to defraud the phone companies, however, I would have to argue that it’s just a creative use of existing technology. An innovation, if you will. And since the Comcast Subscriber agreement doesn’t expressly allow it, would appear to be unlawful when measure with HB0457! I’m just flabbergasted at the lengths to which Service Providers think they can go to control technology, innovation and the general public.
I would also point out that the Comcast Acceptable Use Policy indicates that DHCP is the only protocol allowed for “use of the service.” Since I was unable to find anything expressly authorizing the use of HTTP, SMTP, or POP3, or any other protocol, I would have to say that anyone surfing the web, sending and receiving email or even instant messaging friends or relatives would be in violation of Comcast’s Acceptable use Policy. And if Comcast could prove intent to defraud under the proposed legislation, which would make every Comcast user liable for every day that they violated the acceptable use policy, it would cost more than the proposed $14,900 increase as outlined in the Fiscal Note not to mention the increase in revenues to Comcast. I’m sure that wasn’t the intent of the legislation, but it certainly opens the door for this type of abuse. I am certainly starting to believe that no new legislation would be better than HB0457.
Well, again, I thank you for your time and consideration, and I hope I’m being helpful. Please feel free to forward my concerns to anyone you deem appropriate and feel free to contact me if you have any questions.
Comcast High-Speed Internet Service Subscriber Agreement 5. Acceptable Use Policy; Prohibited Uses of the Service a. Acceptable Use Policy: You expressly agree not to use the Comcast Equipment or the Service, directly or indirectly, to undertake or accomplish any unlawful purpose or in violation of any posted Comcast policy applicable to the Service, including without limitation any Comcast Acceptable Use Policy (the "AUP") or other policy posted on the Service's web site at www.comcast.net or on another web site about which you have been notified, and that the AUP or other policy may be modified by Comcast from time to time. Notwithstanding anything to the contrary in this Agreement, you acknowledge and agree that the terms of the AUP and any other applicable Comcast policies may be put into effect or revised from time to time without notice by posting a new version of the AUP or the other policy as set forth above. Accordingly, you and other users of the Service should consult the AUP and all other posted policies regularly to conform to the most recent version. b. Prohibited Uses of the Service: Use of the Comcast Equipment or the Service for transmission or storage of any information, data or material in violation of any federal, state or local law or regulation is prohibited. In addition, unless you are subject to a Service plan that expressly permits otherwise, the Service is to be used, and you expressly agree to use it, solely in a private residence, living quarters in a hotel, hospital, dormitory, sorority or fraternity house, or boarding house, or the residential portion of a premises which is used for both business and residential purposes. Without limiting the generality of the foregoing, the Service is for personal and non-commercial use only and you agree not to use the Service for operation as an Internet service provider, a server site for ftp, telnet, rlogin, e-mail hosting, "web hosting" or other similar applications, for any business enterprise, or as an end-point on a non-Comcast local area network or wide area network. 6. Representations and Warranties of Customer. You represent and warrant that a. Age: You are at least 18 years of age. b. Customer Information: The Customer information that you have provided and will provide to Comcast during the term of this Agreement, including without limitation your legal name, address, telephone number(s), the number of computers on which the Service is being accessed and payment data (including without limitation credit card numbers and expiration dates) is accurate, complete and current. You agree to promptly notify us, in accordance with the terms of this Agreement, if there is any change in the information that you have provided to us. Failure to provide and maintain accurate information constitutes a breach of this Agreement. c. Multiple Users: The Service and the Comcast Equipment shall be used only by you and by members of your immediate household living with you at the same address. You acknowledge that you are executing this Agreement on behalf of all persons who use the Comcast Equipment and/or Service by means of the Customer Equipment. You shall have sole responsibility for ensuring that all other users understand and comply with the terms and conditions of this Agreement. You further acknowledge and agree that you are solely responsible for and liable for any and all breaches of the terms and conditions of this Agreement, whether the breach is the result of use of the Service and/or the Comcast Equipment by you or by any other user of the Customer Equipment. You agree to indemnify, defend and hold harmless Comcast and its affiliates and agents against all claims and expenses (including reasonable attorney fees) arising out of the use of the Service and/or the Comcast Equipment or the breach of this Agreement by you or any other user of the Customer Equipment. d. Export Laws: You will comply with all export and re-export control laws, including but not limited to the Export Administration Act, the Arms Export Control Act and their implementing regulations, and you will not transfer, by electronic transmission or otherwise, any content derived from the Service to either a foreign national or a foreign destination without first obtaining any required government authorization. You further agree not to upload to the Service any data or software that cannot be exported without prior written government authorization. The terms "export" and "re-export" mean transferring or releasing technology to another country or to a national of another by any means - physical, electronic or otherwise. This includes the electronic transmission of information and software to foreign countries and to certain foreign nationals. e. No Tampering: You will not service, alter, modify or tamper with the Comcast Equipment or with the Service, or permit any other person (unless authorized by Comcast) to do so. This prohibition includes, without limitation, altering a cable modem to change the downloading or uploading capacity of the cable modem. f. IP Addresses: Comcast will provide you with dynamic Internet protocol ("IP") address(es) as a component of the Service and these IP address(es) can and do change over time. You will not alter, modify, or tamper with these dynamic IP address(es) or those of any other customer. You agree not to use a dynamic domain name server or DNS to associate a host name with the dynamic IP address(es) for any commercial purpose. You also agree not to use any software on or in conjunction with any computer(s) or network device connected to the Service that provides for static IP address(es). If applicable, Comcast will release and/or recover the dynamic IP address(es) upon disconnection, discontinuance, or termination of the Service or this Agreement. g. Theft of Service: You will not connect the Service or any Comcast Equipment to more computers, either on or outside of the Premises, than are reflected in your account with us. You acknowledge that any unauthorized receipt of the Service constitutes theft of service, which is a violation of federal law and can result in both civil and criminal penalties. In addition, if the violations are willful and for commercial advantage or private financial gain, the penalties may be increased.
Network, Bandwidth, Data Storage and Other Limitations You must comply with all then current bandwidth, data storage and other limitations on the Service established by Comcast and its vendors and providers. In addition, you may only access and use the Service with a dynamic Internet Protocol ("IP") address that adheres to the dynamic host configuration protocol ("DHCP"). You may not access or use the Service with a static IP address or using any protocol other than DHCP unless you are subject to a Service plan that expressly permits otherwise.