| T O P I C R E V I E W |
| kelargo |
Posted - 11/21/2003 : 10:55:58 AM The response I have from my senator.
Ken
Subject: RE: SB213/HB457 Date: Fri, 21 Nov 2003 10:40:57 -0600 From: "Tim Burchett" <[email protected]> Add to Address Book To: "Kenneth Long" <[email protected]>
Thank you for your email and for voicing your concerns. I have had several folks contact me regarding this bill. It is my understanding that the sub committee is trying very hard to come up with language that would be acceptable to all parties. I have been advised that there is a committee meeting set up for December 4. Senator Trail is chairman of the sub committee and you can let him know your feelings about the bill. Thanks again, Sen. Burchett
-----Original Message----- From: Kenneth Long [mailto:[email protected]] Sent: Thursday, November 20, 2003 2:43 PM To: Tim Burchett Subject: SB213/HB457
My name is Ken Long, and I am a resident of Knoxville, TN. I am writing you today in regard to SB213/HB457 to strongly urge that you do not support this bill, which is currently being considered by the Joint Committee on Communications Security.
This is a piece of legislation which is designed by a very narrow, special interest group with the purpose of extending their rights under the Digital Millenium Copyright Act to the individual states, where it will be more difficult to reverse. Already there is growing support for limiting this act at the national level, which has led the sponsoring interest groups to target states with this, even more restrictive version.
The writers and sponsors of this bill would have you believe that it is needed in order to prevent cable theft and digital piracy. In reality, those issues are alreaedy effectively covered in existing legislation. The proposed bill however, extends the definitions to an incredibly broad scope, and empowers a few corporate entities with powers which fly in the face of the Constitution and all it stands for.
This is the kind of legislation which has already empowered corporations to subpoena personal information without having to go before the courts and request it. It has led to lawsuits and intimidating threats of high dollar litigation against middle school students and grandmothers, average citizens who don't have the money to stand up to billion-dollar businesses in court. But it gets worse.
Commonly used network technologies which prevent unauthorized access to secure computers would be illegal and prosecutable under this legislation. The technologies currently used to protect Tennessee's schools, businesses, government and private computer systems from virus attacks, unsolicited e-mail (spam), and malicious hackers would be illegal under the broad definitions of this bill. The very e-mail server I am using to write this message would be illegal, because of the steps I have taken to ensure that spammers cannot use it to flood inboxes with unwanted e-mails. If you have multiple computers at your home which you use to access the Internet over a cable modem or DSL line, this bill would make you a criminal. If you use encryption to secure a wireless network in order to prevent bandwidth theives (or even terrorists as the cable companies have suggested) from using your Internet connection, you would be breaking the law. If you use a firewall to keep hackers from stealing data off of your computer or to prevent them from using your computer to attack others, you would be in violation of this law.
The bills's corporate sponsors insist that they would not use the language of the bill to attack such technologies. But are you comfortable giving them such powers with only their word that they won't use them? I'm not. Are you ready to sign your name to a law which would force the law-abiding citizens of Tennessee to remove any and all security protections from their computers and networks? I hope not.
I understand that this is a very complicated technical issue, and can be very difficult to completely understand. I simply urge you to do anything you can do to put a stop to a piece of potential legislation which would give unprecedented powers of enforcement to a corporation whose only interest is their own profit margin. Let the people of Tennessee continue to secure their own information without becoming criminals.
Thank you for your time, and for your attention to this rather long message.
Ken Long
===== Kenneth James Long II
|
| 3 L A T E S T R E P L I E S (Newest First) |
| kelargo |
Posted - 11/27/2003 : 03:06:37 AM >I am disappointed that his position is so "on the fence" though.
I agree... :-(
Ken |
| utman |
Posted - 11/21/2003 : 11:54:45 AM Sen. Burchett is also my senator, and I plan to speak to him face to face about it when the legislative session comes a bit closer.
If there's one thing that i'm sure of it's that I can get quite a few letters from UT students on his desk when the time comes.
I am disappointed that his position is so "on the fence" though. |
| jody |
Posted - 11/21/2003 : 11:44:32 AM Ken,
Thanks for taking the time to write this thoughtful message to your local representative. I want everyone to be encouraged to make this kind of effort at a personal level and not as a TNDF member. This kind of communication compliments the effort of TNDF nicely. Please, talk to your relatives and friends and encourage them to do the same. |
|
|