Note: You must be registered in order to post a reply. To register, click here. Registration is FREE!
T O P I C R E V I E W
Scott Lyon
Posted - 02/19/2004 : 3:46:45 PM I sat down with Senator Trail on Wednesday and explained our position. I particularly emphasized our concerns that the MPAA's bill and SB3101 are likely preempted by federal law. He seemed very open to our considering our objections and asked if federal copyright explicitly preempts state law on the subject and I told him that it did, but that I would send him some citations to back that up. The following is a letter sent to Senator Norris this afternoon:
quote: Dear Senator Norris,
I wanted to get back to you with a short answer to the federal copyright pre-emption question you asked yesterday. As you know, Article I, Section 8 of the Constitution granted Congress the power "To promote the Progress of Science and useful Arts, by securing for limited Times to Authors and Inventors the exclusive Right to their respective Writings and Discoveries." Based on this power, Congress passed the 1976 Copyright Act, of which Section 301 provides that:
"On and after January 1, 1978, all legal or equitable rights that are equivalent to any of the exclusive rights within the general scope of copyright as specified by section 106 in works of authorship that are fixed in a tangible medium of expression and come within the subject matter of copyright as specified by sections 102 and 103, whether created before or after that date and whether published or unpublished, are governed exclusively by this title. Thereafter, no person is entitled to any such right or equivalent right in any such work under the common law or statutes of any State."
The House Report on Section 301 (pp. 130-131) attempts to reinforce this federal preemption, and states that "[t]he declaration of this principle in section 301 is intended to be stated in the clearest and most unequivocal language possible, so as to foreclose any conceivable misinterpretation of its unqualified intention that Congress shall act preemptively, and to avoid the development of any vague borderline areas between State and Federal protection."
While the original MPAA bill regulating devices was drafted toward "devices" (in order to prohibit the targeted devices from performing actions which were permissible in federal copyright law), the current bill now crosses beyond regulation of devices to frustrate federal copyright law and directly regulates activities protected by federal "fair use" exceptions to federal copyright law. The question of whether it is permissible to "acquire, transmit, or retransmit" a communication service (which is likely copyright-bearing content) is a federal question subject to regulation by the Federal Communications Commission and federal copyright law, regardless of the "offender's" intentions. The federal courts have already weighed in on the question of devices used to infringe upon copyrights and have established caselaw on acknowledged "fair use" exceptions to federal copyright, as well as the "substantial non-infringing use" standard used to evaluate devices (such as the Betamax device at issue in the Supreme Court's Sony decision). While it is reasonable for the state to regulate theft of water, electrical, or telephone services (within jurisdictional limits, of course), the current SB3101 also regulates all forms of communications (including forms of communication which have not been invented yet) and is targeted to regulate the WAYS that Tennesseans can USE the content of that communication.
TNDF fears that not only will this bill alienate consumer electronics manufacturers and retailers in this state, but would also be an enormous waste of legislative resources to pass a bill on a subject which has been settled law for almost 28 years. We would encourage you to please reconsider sponsorship of this bill and instead push for a much more narrow bill, within the powers of the state of Tennessee. TNDF would be happy to offer the legal and technical experience of its members to accomplish this purpose.
If you have any questions or if I can be of further assistance, please do not hesitate to call my office.
Sincerely, Scott Lyon
1 L A T E S T R E P L I E S (Newest First)
utman
Posted - 02/19/2004 : 5:37:58 PM Excellent letter scott. I wish that I was a bit further in my education so that I might contribute to the legal analysys. You seem to be carrying the bulk of the weight there.