| T O P I C R E V I E W |
| jody |
Posted - 07/15/2003 : 08:18:38 AM Howard Dean is guest blogging for Lawrence Lessig today and he makes mention of a new FCC ruling allowing Cable and Telco operators who offer broadband services to classify their service as an "information" rather than "telecommunication" service. His implication was "that [ruling] could allow Internet providers to arbitrarily limit the content that users can access. The phone and cable industries could have the power to discriminate against content that they don’t control or-- even worse-- simply don’t like." My question is what does he know that we might not know? Is this another piece of the grand strategy used by the media giants? Clearly the implication is similar to what we faced with the Super DMCA laws. Anyone out there up for a little investigation?
GOTO: http://cyberlaw.stanford.edu/lessig/blog/archives/2003_07.shtml#001355
ps: I finished mowing the yard. |
| 9 L A T E S T R E P L I E S (Newest First) |
| SKozicki |
Posted - 07/18/2003 : 09:01:41 AM If you're interested in the ROW issues, google around (and check some of the links in these forums) for muni sponsored broadband. You'll get a good taste of what legal issues there are when they attempt to 'take back' the ROWs from the SPs, and some of the interference that the SPs are running to try and stop muni sponsored broadband.
It is not a simple process, and I wouldn't rank it high on a list of tactics to be used for expanding competition. |
| jody |
Posted - 07/17/2003 : 4:38:18 PM Your knowledge of the communications industry is far greater than mine and I appreciate your input. The ROW thingy, as you illustrate, is part of what I was getting at. So the big meanies think they can outslick the FCC and avoid regulations. But the local municipalities do have the ace up their sleeve in controlling ROW. They can employ the right of eminent domain to forcibly purchase the "plant", or parts of it back, I would think. There isn't a chance in hell that the private SP could do that without local government sponsorship. Now in my mind when a government cooperates to facilitate exclusive access to the ROW for a single vendor then it is a monopoly. So, if the public can persuade their local authorities to stop cooperating and take back that ROW then the SP is up SC. But that's how it would work in my simple world. What I don't know are all the little legal adjustments that have set counter precedents to common sense that would prevent a municipality from reasserting control over the "plant". If the municipalities could do that then they could bid out contractors to maintain the plant and stipulate rather than regulate the business practices. I think some rural areas have benefitted from that in the area of electrical distribution, but what do I know? |
| SKozicki |
Posted - 07/17/2003 : 3:22:42 PM quote: The third is to a 1999 bill sponsored in Congress forcing the FCC to allow cable companies and telco's to let multiple ISP's use their infrastructure. This is related back to the original classification of cable modem access as an "information service" because that restricts local authorities from requiring open access.
You hit the nail on the head here. There is a distinction between 'information' services and 'telecommunication' services. Essentially, info services don't get regulated nearly as much. Or taxed. The argument that Monopoly SPs are trying to make is that if it's packet switched, it's an info service. Therefore, if you used ATM or IP as your backbone instead of circuit switches, you could get out from under the FCC's rules and regs and start raping the public even more. It's important that we keep an eye on this, because it can be used as a very powerful tool to destroy competition as well as destroy the leverage the FCC could potentially have against the SPs.
Also, the right of ways for plant is usually municipally owned, but not always. It's almost always a split between the muni, and whoever's plant you're riding with. Case in point, when Knowledgy came to town and strung up their own fiber around town, they rode with NES lines and on BellSouth poles. So they paid both Metro, NES, and BellSouth for each piece. It's **very** tricky negotiating ROWs, and sometimes impossible to get coverage. Adelphia and NextLink (XO) had to sue over and over again to get ROWs in certain areas of town. The Holy Grail of ROWs is the remote terminal pads (those green and brown boxes on the side of the road). If the FCC required ILECs to open those like they do the COs, you'd see an immediate doubling of DSL reach and customers. |
| Dubber |
Posted - 07/17/2003 : 1:42:09 PM quote: Originally posted by jody THUD!
huh? |
| Tony |
Posted - 07/16/2003 : 9:20:20 PM I believe the state or municipality owns it; hence the term public right of way. That's what I always understood to be the case, anyway. Am I mistaken? |
| jody |
Posted - 07/16/2003 : 5:19:50 PM THUD! |
| jody |
Posted - 07/15/2003 : 3:00:04 PM This is for Scott Lyon, or anyone else who knows.
In the State of Tennessee who owns the Public Right of Way for Electric, Phone and CableTV runs? I realize this may be a multi-part answer. |
| jody |
Posted - 07/15/2003 : 11:24:31 AM Yes, I find his style quite like that. I just need a little more information so I can try and connect the dots he alludes to over at the FCC. Maybe he is referring to something that is a non-issue for us, but then again, maybe he knows something we have missed. Either way, I am in no way endorsing nor denouncing his views or campaign.
Well, I have found this much so far: http://www.fcc.gov/Bureaus/Cable/News_Releases/2002/nrcb0201.html http://www.newrules.org/info/access.html http://thomas.loc.gov/cgi-bin/query/z?c106:h.r.2637:
The first link is to the public announcement of the FCC ruling. The second is to a political group with a broad agenda which includes this subject. The third is to a 1999 bill sponsored in Congress forcing the FCC to allow cable companies and telco's to let multiple ISP's use their infrastructure. This is related back to the original classification of cable modem access as an "information service" because that restricts local authorities from requiring open access.
I will make the connection to the Super DMCA thusly: Such rulings by the FCC make it impossible for state and local authorities to provide for or promote diverse choices in "Communications Service Providers"; with such a narrowing of competition the passage of a "Theft of Cable Services" bill becomes more of a legislated terms of service for the consumer, including resrictions on content like internet telephony, home networking, and fair-use recording. The Super DMCA at that point becomes a legislatively supported monopoly control on the Internet for all citizens in it's jurisdiction.
An argument as to how this benefits the greater public is obliged at this point. In other words we are moving away from a non-monopoly controlled internet access model to a monopoly controlled access model. Presumably such market interference on the governments part is only justified when there is a greater benefit to the public than if it did not act all. The Super DMCA fails that test completely, and that might have been why the MPAA didn't get away with demanding it at the federal level to begin with. Perhaps the FCC said "we'll give you unfettered control over broadband by preventing local requirements of open access, but we can't give legislated terms of service, too."
It is too bad that Rep. Earl Blumenauer's (D-Ore.) bill did not progress. I think it was a bit too early to catch the public's attention. After the other recent FCC ruling, though, there may be enough broad public support for another initiative of that sort. But that is the national level of advocacy.
I think a ruse that most people miss is how the giant media distributors will accuse anyone who opposes their way with the FCC as being anti-competitive and pro big government. But nothing could be further from the truth, without the government sponsored and supported regulations these same companies would not enjoy the market protections they currently do. |
| utman |
Posted - 07/15/2003 : 10:30:08 AM I've been reading the posts and responses, and IMHO, he's either off to a slow start or is just pandering to the crowd.
I would like to see some more substantial, concrete posts on his position...not more blanket statements. |
|
|