Tennessee Digital Freedom Forum
Tennessee Digital Freedom Forum
Home | Profile | Register | Active Topics | Members | Search | FAQ
Username:
Password:
Save Password
Forgot your Password?

 All Forums
 Organization
 Meetings
 5/3 Meeting [was: Possible Weekend Meeting?]
 New Topic  Reply to Topic
 Printer Friendly
Author Previous Topic Topic Next Topic  

jody

395 Posts

Posted - 05/02/2003 :  11:10:13 AM  Show Profile  Send jody an AOL message  Reply with Quote
Even though I have a lot of personal life to do this weekend I think it may be worth our while to have another meeting prior to Monday night. As I mentioned in another post Vanderbilt and many other large entities are getting ready to make their presence known on this legislation. They will be at the hearings Tuesday and Wednesday. Right now I have no confirmation that any of them will be brought into the Tuesday morning meeting that Senator Person has set up for us, but it would be good if some of them were. We really need to be identifying and working with these other large opponents so as not to be marginalized. Though they oppose most of the legislation, there is plenty that doesn't concern them but still effects the average citizen. For instance, the CES is primarily interested in limiting it's members liability under this law; the same can be said for private healthcare institutions.

Scott, Jay, and anyone else who have been very successful in making contacts with the key players: are you seeing any trends towards concensus on this bill? I still think we have a unique concern that others may not be as interested in, but that effects the average citizen the most. I really think we need to start focusing on that aspect. For instance, many instituions may seek exemptions from the law in the same way state agencies have received one in the amendments. This would leave the average joe holding the bag. The CES version clearly tackles issues like "intent to defraud" in a way that is probably acceptable to us and is far better worded than anything we might come up with.

So, back to why I think a weekend meeting would be good: we can leave Monday night to work on our presentations and logistics during the two days of hearings that follow. An earlier meeting would give us a chance to refine our specific objections which are not addressed by other opponents. In particular, we can begin crafting language to suggest be added to the legislation that addresses our specific concerns. We need to be able to convincingly argue for the delay to summer study should we find everyone else okay with passing the legislation with their amendments. Yep, this could be passed out of committee next week and ready for a vote on the hill with some of our unique concerns not reflected in it.

SKozicki

243 Posts

Posted - 05/02/2003 :  3:09:35 PM  Show Profile  Send SKozicki an AOL message  Reply with Quote
I had originally floated the idea to a few key people that we should have a conference call on Saturday to discuss the results of meetings in the last 2 days. But it appears that we have A LOT of work to do in preparation for the hearings as well as some meetings scheduled for Tuesday mornign with the sponsors and the lobbyists.

There are issues as to what our strategy needs to be and how to articulate it. There are issues as to what preparation and materials are necessary for these meetings. There are issues as to garnering support from other interested parties. We have basically have only Monday in order to make phone calls and handle other business related to this endeavor. Without proper planning beforehand, Monday will get squandered.

So yes, we need to meet f2f and discuss these issues. I am proposing we meet at 11am at my house. I hope to have cookies available. Since a lot of our issues are related to 'dividing and conquering' tasks, it makes sense to bring in as many people as possible. There are lots of 'tasks' that need to be tackled and many hands make light work. So those of you who are planning on attending, please bring an interested party so that they can participate.
Go to Top of Page

SKozicki

243 Posts

Posted - 05/04/2003 :  1:48:55 PM  Show Profile  Send SKozicki an AOL message  Reply with Quote
Here is a summary of Saturday's meeting.

In attendance:
Luke Kanies
Scott Lyon
Jody Leavall
Jay Kosturko
Scott Kozicki

Thanks Jay for coming all the way to Nashville!

Our agenda was simple. We wanted to make sure that we had syncronized our strategy for upcoming meetings with key players. And we wanted to make sure that we had people responsible for preparing key documents and support material that would be needed for these meetings.

Within our discussion, we decided to pursure a two pronged approach. Plan A is to stop the bills progress completely (ie kill it). This involves rallying enough support within the Judiciary Committees to effectively stop the bill. Luke and Scott K seemed to be the most adamant about this tact and will present arguments in Tuesday's meetings with the intent of accomplishing this.

Plan B is to 'delay and amend' the legislation. This is a parallel process and one that is complimentary to Plan A. The idea here is to cause the bill to be questioned enough that it doesn't get put to the floor for general votes before the end of this session, and that it possibly ends up in summer study session. In addition, we are working on language of our own to be added to the existing statute which would be a 'compromise' position that we'd like the legislature to consider. It is possible that we might get our own sponsor for this bill to compete with the existing bills. Scott L and Jay will head this initiative on Tuesdays meetings, but we are all working towards this end as well.

Some responsibilities were assigned:
+ Scott L is still working on updating the legal brief to be delivered on Monday. If you haven't read it, please do. Please make comments ASAP.

+ Scott K is consolidating the 'one-pagers' so that there is a single one which everyone can reference.

+ Jody is now deigned 'Minister of Propaganda' and is responsible for grass roots marketing efforts, like stickers/buttons, signs, and anything else that might bring visibility to our cause on the Plaza, as well as in the media in general. Please contribute any contacts you may have to Jody so that he can follow up with them.

+ We identified the need for someone to contact and compile a list of 'related parties' - people who may be allies or that have a stake in this legislation. The retail associations are at the top of this list. I have added some of these contacts to the players db. But someone needs to own this piece of the pie. Be prepared to get a call from me asking you to take it over!

+ Scott K and Scott L will work on putting together amendmants to the existing statutes that cover what we believe to be the spirit of the law and helping to deter cable theft.

+ For Tuesday's meetings, the group was arranged as follows:
Scott K, Scott L, Jay, and Luke will attend both meetings, but Scott K and Luke will leave for Rep Briley's meeting if Sen Person's meeting runs over.

Some interesting points were raised:
+ There is a total lack of enforcement issue. There is little enforcement now of the existing law in criminal prosecution. Prosecutors are obviously not that interested in pursuing violators of the existing statute because there are too few, or because they are isolated offenses. And there is no way possible that the proposed law could be enforced. We believe that the proposed law is an effort on the part of the SPs to end-run the prosecutors and allow them to do their own prosecution in civil courts. We believe that this should raise more eyebrows.

+ We feel as though the existing laws are built to cover cable THEFT. Whereas the proposed laws are built to cover service FRAUD. The difference being that if someone is outright stealing service today, they are covered in the existing law, but if they are a paying customer who is not contributing the amount of revenue that the SP *desires* (by way of additional computers, additional set-top boxes, ppv, vod, extra fees, etc) that they will be covered in the proposed law. This is not consistant with the lobbyist's claims that the law is built soley to go after cable THEFT.

+ We find it unusual that the most technologically savvy service providers (ie Cable and Telecom) have the least capability of determining fraud of their service. We question the ability of other utilities such as electric, water, and gas to be able to determine if they are being stolen from and to deter theft without the need for draconian legislation. We all know as technologists (and some of us as former SPs) that it is very easy to determine who's using your services and for what purposes.

There were few cookies remaining at the end of the meeting.
Go to Top of Page

utman

244 Posts

Posted - 05/04/2003 :  7:36:41 PM  Show Profile  Visit utman's Homepage  Send utman an AOL message  Reply with Quote
I put together a 2 page condensed version of Scott Lyon's legal analysis. I think it touches on the biggest issues with the bill. I am planning on using this in my presentations this coming week.

I sent it out to the mailing list (my ftp isn't working correctly to my web space currently).
Anyone want to comment on it? Should I edit it a little more or just forget it?
Go to Top of Page

jody

395 Posts

Posted - 05/05/2003 :  10:10:27 AM  Show Profile  Send jody an AOL message  Reply with Quote
When, if, whoever becomes the "Alliance Coordinator" responsible for contacting retail associations, institutions, etc who are allied players in opposition let me know and I can hand over my contact here at Vandy.
Go to Top of Page
  Previous Topic Topic Next Topic  
 New Topic  Reply to Topic
 Printer Friendly
Jump To:
Tennessee Digital Freedom Forum © 2003 TNDF.net Go To Top Of Page
Snitz Forums 2000