Tennessee Digital Freedom Forum
Tennessee Digital Freedom Forum
Home | Profile | Register | Active Topics | Members | Search | FAQ
Username:
Password:
Save Password
Forgot your Password?

 All Forums
 Senate Bill 213 / House Bill 457
 Legislation
 House Bill Exclusions
 New Topic  Reply to Topic
 Printer Friendly
Next Page
Author Previous Topic Topic Next Topic
Page: of 2

stickman

2 Posts

Posted - 05/09/2003 :  08:23:37 AM  Show Profile  Reply with Quote
The amendment to the original house bill now contains several exclusions for government agencies and financial institutions. The bill is being pushed as a "cable theft" law, but why would these organizations need exclusions from stealing? You'll notice that there is a clause qualifying when a financial instition is allow to intercept, decrypt, and retransmit your communications. Unfortunately there is no clause stating the law enforcement and government agencies are restricted to acting under existing federal, state, or local laws. Under this bill, the TBI can intercept your email and other communications without cause.

Edited by - stickman on 05/09/2003 09:14:18 AM

Scott Lyon

80 Posts

Posted - 05/09/2003 :  09:06:04 AM  Show Profile  Reply with Quote
The exclusions are mostly to defuse worries about compliance costs. It doesn't change any of the procedural or due process restrictions on law enforcement, though it WAS supposed to exempt private educational institutions (or at least that's what I thought they said).
Go to Top of Page

stickman

2 Posts

Posted - 05/09/2003 :  09:13:19 AM  Show Profile  Reply with Quote
Why is there no qualifier like there is for service providers and financial institutions? It just seems odd that they would restrict two classes, but leave another totally open. It just seems like this introduces a little ambiguity into state law.

Edited by - stickman on 05/09/2003 09:15:12 AM
Go to Top of Page

SKozicki

212 Posts

Posted - 05/09/2003 :  11:28:08 AM  Show Profile  Send SKozicki an AOL message  Reply with Quote
It wouldn't allow anyone to break the law as you describe. TBI couldn't avoid due process just because this law doesn't say they have to. The fact of the matter is that the exclusions are unnecessary, admitted even by the lobbyist. They are token carve outs to people who were opposed but are too dumb to realize that a simple exclusion doesn't take them off the hook entirely. State universities are a good example. How are they going to insure that all student communications are compliant?
Go to Top of Page

bucket

47 Posts

Posted - 05/11/2003 :  05:03:10 AM  Show Profile  Reply with Quote
I notice that healthcare institutions (like Vanderbilt Hospital) that are subject to the provisions of HIPAA are not excluded. If VUMC has firewalls installed to protect patient records, and if filewalls are prohibited by Briley's amended version of TCA§ 39-14-149, then....................

Just a thought.
Go to Top of Page

SKozicki

212 Posts

Posted - 05/11/2003 :  2:41:36 PM  Show Profile  Send SKozicki an AOL message  Reply with Quote
A state law cannot trump a federal law. There was supposed to be language specifically stating that someone engaging in legal activity as required by law (ie HIPAA, Homeland Security, etc...) would not be in violation of the law, but this language is not present in the amendment. Beauchamp agreed to put the language in during the meeting with Briley last week.
Go to Top of Page

bucket

47 Posts

Posted - 05/11/2003 :  8:55:45 PM  Show Profile  Reply with Quote
Scott,

We seem that the mentioned languge should have been included, but, for some reason or another, was omitted from RB's Final Bill. Real poor drafting.


If you have time, please review § j of the amended bill. What exactly does that lengthy paragraph mean ?
Go to Top of Page

Scott Lyon

80 Posts

Posted - 05/11/2003 :  9:23:42 PM  Show Profile  Reply with Quote
Section (j) could refer to a couple different ideas that have been batted around.

1) Manufacturers could be required to install a proprietary chip from the communication service provider in order for the product to interconnect to the communication service. This would be a pain in the a**.

2) Something similar to the V-Chip was recommended to Congress which would require manufacturers of VCRs to use special sensing technology to determine if the media is copyright protected. This has not passed yet, but the amendment would not require manufacturers to sell products which utilize special features like this in order to sell their products in Tennessee.
Go to Top of Page

SKozicki

212 Posts

Posted - 05/11/2003 :  10:29:21 PM  Show Profile  Send SKozicki an AOL message  Reply with Quote
Scott, the way I read this though, it's calling for NOT requiring that to happen, such that it specifically avoids the potential of requiring manufacturers to utilize technology that would identify the recipient or you know... using technology to actually AVOID theft. Am I reading this wrong?
Go to Top of Page

Scott Lyon

80 Posts

Posted - 05/11/2003 :  11:41:32 PM  Show Profile  Reply with Quote
Sorry about that. I was unclear. I didn't explain myself fully.

Section (j) is an attempt to ease the worries of manufacturers who thought they might be forced to comply with the two ideas above down the road. It basically says that the manufacturer doesn't have to incorporate any technology to either utilize or respond to any theft-of-service technology by the provider. But it was BECAUSE the media giants had considered forcing this technology that they were worried in the first place. Section (j) is the consolation to get them on-board.

Edited by - Scott Lyon on 05/11/2003 11:42:49 PM
Go to Top of Page

bucket

47 Posts

Posted - 05/12/2003 :  05:24:53 AM  Show Profile  Reply with Quote
Ths convoluted § j of the amended version of Briley's bill appears to be the same as § g of the MPAA Sample Legislation revision dated (04/01/03).

I'm gonna really have to work to get up to speed on the Super DMCA.

Edited by - bucket on 05/12/2003 07:04:57 AM
Go to Top of Page

bobaloo

16 Posts

Posted - 05/12/2003 :  10:39:59 AM  Show Profile  Reply with Quote
Please, point me to the exclusion language for universities...
Can't seem to locate it at http://www.legislature.state.tn.us/bills/currentga/Amend/HA0395.pdf


thanks,

bobaloo!
Go to Top of Page

Tony

214 Posts

Posted - 05/12/2003 :  11:17:55 AM  Show Profile  Visit Tony's Homepage  Send Tony an AOL message  Send Tony a Yahoo! Message  Reply with Quote
bobaloo, §(d)(2) exempts any "State or local government agency, municipality, or authority," which would include public schools, colleges and universities.

In nathan's excellent report on the 5/7 House Judiciary Committee hearing, he noted:

"Rep. Cochran asked why there were exemptions, to which Beauchamp replied that no 'real exemptions' were required due to the 'intent to defaut' clause. The exemptions were added just to make certain. Rep. Cochran further questioned why public colleges were exempt but not private institutions. Mr. Beauchamp admitted that this was an oversight and that it would be corrected in the amendment."

No such correction made it into HA395, apparently.
Go to Top of Page

bobaloo

16 Posts

Posted - 05/12/2003 :  12:40:12 PM  Show Profile  Reply with Quote
Tony, I thought that might be it.
As I understand from reports on this forum, Betty Nixon made the case for Vanderbilt, and I assume, other private institutions to be excluded.
Questions I have for our representatives...
Do these exclusions apply only to the institutions themselves or do they include employees, students and guests? Shielding them from civil and criminal liability?
Would this also exclude these same people (if covered) from communications they do from their homes? Many login from work we know. And if they were accused could claim they were doing "homework."
And of course it must said again, why are carve-outs needed at all if this is a just bill? These exclusions appear to place 100's of thousands of Tennesseans above the law.

bobaloo!
Go to Top of Page

SKozicki

212 Posts

Posted - 05/12/2003 :  2:00:16 PM  Show Profile  Send SKozicki an AOL message  Reply with Quote
It is unclear whether the language could be applied to a student or employee. You'll just have to get sued to find out basically.

As for why these exclusions are there (and why they will remain there despite the 'adequate intent to defraud language') is because they make rich and powerful interests complacent about the bill.
Go to Top of Page

bucket

47 Posts

Posted - 05/13/2003 :  04:03:24 AM  Show Profile  Reply with Quote
§(d)(2) of the amended bill, which exempts from liability "State or local government agency, municipality,or authority...", probably covers state schools. That clause may be construed as covering employees, but I kinda doubt it. I wouldn't think that that it covered students at all unless they were, say, teaching assistants. A TA, an employee of the school, might be exempted.

I wish that Glenn were on board to comment on this.

Edited by - bucket on 05/13/2003 04:17:20 AM
Go to Top of Page
Page: of 2 Previous Topic Topic Next Topic  
Next Page
 New Topic  Reply to Topic
 Printer Friendly
Jump To:
Tennessee Digital Freedom Forum © 2003 TNDF.net Go To Top Of Page
Snitz Forums 2000