Tennessee Digital Freedom Forum
Tennessee Digital Freedom Forum
Home | Profile | Register | Active Topics | Members | Search | FAQ
Username:
Password:
Save Password
Forgot your Password?

 All Forums
 Senate Bill 213 / House Bill 457
 Legislation
 Sen Person's Personal Cable Connection
 New Topic  Topic Locked
 Printer Friendly
Next Page
Author Previous Topic Topic Next Topic
Page: of 3

bobaloo

16 Posts

Posted - 05/15/2003 :  08:47:16 AM  Show Profile
HobbsOnline has many excellent posts regarding the Super-DMCA.
The Thursday AM, May 15th one is most illuminating regarding Sen. Person and his son and the cable industry.

bobaloo!

Dubber

238 Posts

Posted - 05/15/2003 :  12:39:45 PM  Show Profile  Visit Dubber's Homepage
Well, at least Hobbescame out and expressed his support for previous items Sen Person has had a hand in. Otherwise the article might have been too mean to a Person.
I understand wanting to assist a family member do their job well when you can. I support helping family members out when you can. For Sen. Person's sake, I hope we can get our bill substituted in place of SB213 so we can transform him into "the good guy" and he can actually be credited with improving the situation of his extended "Tennessee Family" (us, the residents of TN) as well as his biological family.
<apologies for the pun, I tried not to but I had to>
Go to Top of Page

SKozicki

212 Posts

Posted - 05/15/2003 :  12:50:08 PM  Show Profile  Send SKozicki an AOL message
This brings up a much larger topic that needs to be addressed. That is that we are attacking the BILL, not the PEOPLE behind it. Rep Briley has made mention more than once that he is not thrilled with the personal attacks, and considering Sen Person's demeanor towards us, it does us no good to start villifying him either.

It's just business, not personal. These are well respected men who do a difficult job. There's no need to drag them through the mud because they stand for something that isn't tasteful to us. If we're going to defeat this bill, let's do it with some class.

Hopefully the time won't come, but if it does, where we need to make a statement that legislation was passed which we do not agree with, we'll make that statement at the polls.
Go to Top of Page

utman

90 Posts

Posted - 05/15/2003 :  1:16:17 PM  Show Profile  Visit utman's Homepage  Send utman an AOL message
I agree 100% with Scott. If there is anyone who has been willing to work with us through this it has been Sen. Person.

Go to Top of Page

Tony

214 Posts

Posted - 05/15/2003 :  1:43:32 PM  Show Profile  Visit Tony's Homepage  Send Tony an AOL message  Send Tony a Yahoo! Message
If any ad hominem attacks are happening here, then the geek perps are violating the statement that they agreed to when they signed up:
quote:
In your use of these forums, you agree that you will not post any information which is vulgar, harassing, hateful, threatening, invading of others privacy, sexually oriented, or violates any laws.
Of course, that's the default agreement, but I think we'd all do well to abide by it.
Go to Top of Page

Dubber

238 Posts

Posted - 05/15/2003 :  2:48:22 PM  Show Profile  Visit Dubber's Homepage
But but but it was a *click-thru* license! You mean I was supposed to *read* it first?!
Go to Top of Page

Rick

9 Posts

Posted - 05/15/2003 :  3:07:47 PM  Show Profile  Visit Rick's Homepage
quote:
Originally posted by SKozicki
This brings up a much larger topic that needs to be addressed. That is that we are attacking the BILL, not the PEOPLE behind it. Rep Briley has made mention more than once that he is not thrilled with the personal attacks, and considering Sen Person's demeanor towards us, it does us no good to start villifying him either.

It's just business, not personal. These are well respected men who do a difficult job. There's no need to drag them through the mud because they stand for something that isn't tasteful to us. If we're going to defeat this bill, let's do it with some class.

Hopefully the time won't come, but if it does, where we need to make a statement that legislation was passed which we do not agree with, we'll make that statement at the polls.
While I've agreed to the principle that while this matter is ongoing the attack is on the bill and the process, I should make it clear (as I'm not the only one who has expressed these sentiments):

- When all is said and done, if this bill passes into law, I consider it my duty to work alongside those working to finish the careers of the legislators who sponsored it, and to the degree commensurate, to bring the consequences back to roost on those who worked for its passage.
- Neglecting to make it clear to the members of the legislature that this bill is a tarbaby in which they will be stuck with career-damaging consequences, is a mistake.

In a conversation with someone personally close to Briley last week, it was noted that he "had kind of a rough time last election." I made it clear (with my instructions that he feel free to pass my point of view along) that it's likely going to be a hell of a lot worse next time -- and the bed is of his own making.

I don't for a moment harbor the illusion that the guys we're dealing with are selfless public servants giving their all for the People. Sure, they manage to do some good in the course of their politicking, but these are career politicians, with all that comes along with that. They're replaceable and they'll come to realize it.

"Well-respected", well-meaning, just doing their jobs, big whoop. There's a line of people waiting to climb that slippery pole. We'll get a different batch if this batch can't figure out which way is up.
Go to Top of Page

bobaloo

16 Posts

Posted - 05/15/2003 :  3:08:00 PM  Show Profile
Please, inform me if it was against the forum standards to post the link to Hobbsonline.
I felt it was a timely post from a professional journalist. Hobbs wrote some good things about Person, as have others here. But pointing out that Senator Person's son is a cable executive, while not a flattering revelation in this context, is certainly fair game. And since Hobbs published it, along with many other articles on the Super-DMCA, I felt it should be part of our informed discussion.
The link is certainly not intended to be a personal attack on Sen Person, whom I have a favorable opinion of, due to the comments on this board.

bobaloo!
Go to Top of Page

SKozicki

212 Posts

Posted - 05/15/2003 :  3:23:24 PM  Show Profile  Send SKozicki an AOL message
quote:
In a conversation with someone personally close to Briley last week, it was noted that he "had kind of a rough time last election." I made it clear (with my instructions that he feel free to pass my point of view along) that it's likely going to be a hell of a lot worse next time -- and the bed is of his own making.
I completely agree with this statement, and will do likewise. My issue is that there's a fine line on how hard you push. Rep Briley is *extraodinarily* aware of this sentiment, but it's now at the point where it has made him indignant, instead of fearful. Do you think that's helpful to our cause?
Go to Top of Page

Dubber

238 Posts

Posted - 05/15/2003 :  3:27:33 PM  Show Profile  Visit Dubber's Homepage
Posting a link to relevant articles, &c is most certainly *NOT* against forum standards, bobaloo.
(Posting the whole article would violate copyright, but that wasn't done on this topic :)
Timely, yes. - Helpful? Yes. - Balanced perspective? Yes. - Keep Posting? YES.
I was merely noting my approval that Hobbes helpfully provided context for his comments on the bill & the familial relationship to which he refered.
I suspect Scott was trying to make a macro point as well, which I have also tried to make more obliquely elsewhere, namely that personal attacks will have unintended consequences. Most likely they will result in a hardening of the target's resolve, making our primary stated aim (stopping or at least fixing HB0457/SB0213) much more difficult to attain.
Rick's points are also well taken. If this bill (in it's current form) does become law, who got it there? Not us, that's for sure. Take out the proponents (sponsors/HJC members who voted it on to FW&M/Sens & Reps that voted it into law/&c) in the next election.
(but don't take it out on them with personal attacks while the process is on going - reference what you feel might happen to them *in future elections* but don't personally attack them *now* while we can still try to work with them to improve or stop the bill)
-Aaron W. Dobbs
:-)'
Go to Top of Page

RobertDupuy

9 Posts

Posted - 05/15/2003 :  4:55:21 PM  Show Profile
quote:
My issue is that there's a fine line on how hard you push. Rep Briley is *extraodinarily* aware of this sentiment, but it's now at the point where it has made him indignant, instead of fearful. Do you think that's helpful to our cause?
Could you clarify what help you are expecting to get from Briley?
If we are losing out on some help, then we could change our strategy...although I have no idea what he means by 'abrasive.'

It is the right, even duty, of each citizen to participate in the
democratic process, if Briley doesn't like it, then thats his problem.
Respected legislator??? Not anymore...not with me.

Abrasive? Maybe...poor guy, maybe he should consider the threats his buddies in the RIAA are sending out to innocent people, like amigascne.org...maybe being threatened with jail time is abrasive to some people.

Passions run high...par for the course. Maybe spending 15 years of your life helping to build an information society, only to see this blatant attempt to steal it by corporate monopolists is a bit abrasive.

It's up to Briley to show IT professionals some respect, which so far, he has not.

There are all kinds of concessions thrown into this bill, for the people he does respect. But none, for TNDF.....I would be glad to see a modification, whereby, if a service provider is ever shown to have abused their 'accusotory' powers, by accusing someone innaccurately, that they have to pay an extremely stiff fine...automatically.

As has been said before, this bill grants no rights to the people of TN, only to big interests.

I will work to defeat Briley, whether or not the bill passes.
Go to Top of Page

SKozicki

212 Posts

Posted - 05/15/2003 :  5:06:36 PM  Show Profile  Send SKozicki an AOL message
quote:
Could you clarify what help you are expecting to get from Briley?
I'm not expecting any.

I agree that you sleep in the bed you make. But my point is that we don't need to engage in pissing contests with people at this point. And definitely not publically. There's a much more gentlemanly way of making our points known. When the appropriate time comes to send a message, we will send it. Gift wrapped with a bow.

I guess it's the hockey goon in me talking.

Edited by - SKozicki on 05/16/2003 03:38:00 AM
Go to Top of Page

Rick

9 Posts

Posted - 05/15/2003 :  5:32:59 PM  Show Profile  Visit Rick's Homepage
quote:
Originally posted by SKozicki
I completely agree with this statement, and will do likewise. My issue is that there's a fine line on how hard you push. Rep Briley is *extraodinarily* aware of this sentiment, but it's now at the point where it has made him indignant, instead of fearful. Do you think that's helpful to our cause?
If someone were calling him up daily and saying "Hey, Briley, we're gonna run you out of office," it would be an annoyance that would probably damage our cause. When he gets people discussing the bill, the process, support, complaints, etc., and mixed in he's taking some heat for not having a good reason for supporting this thing, with the occasional "we'll remember this, buddy." thrown in -- if he's such a crybaby that it damages our cause then his opinion and livelihood aren't worth worrying about past this affair.

Another thing to consider (and I think we should definitely be considering this with Person at this point, even more than with Briley) is that if the sponsor got in over his head and would really like to get rid of this hot-potato, it's likely that he needs an "out" to save face with the people who are pushing this thing in the first place.

In that case, from a negotiating standpoint, you have a shot to make an offer that's further away from the lobbyists' offer because the sponsor will take it to save himself. He doesn't find himself in that position unless he knows that he's risking taking damage on this thing.

I looked at the proposed amendment TNDF wrote when I was in the hall, just prior to yesterday's hearing. I'm on record for hating the thought of amending the bill (because we don't "need to pass something" -- the fact that some Senator or Rep. got himself into hot water for doing the MPAA's bidding is a sob story I don't have a small enough violin for -- why the **** do we elect people who are just going to outsource their diligence and our rights to the highest bidder?), but let me spout a bit. There are some things that appear to need saying with pictures to make the point crystal clear, and there are some resources I have that you may want to take advantage of:

Imagine a scale where the extreme cable-shill/lobbyist position is on the right and a position which annihilates the current statute is on the left. We've got a continuum which looks like this:

P-----------------------+------------------------------------M

Where '+' is the current statute, 'P' is an extreme position which gives the People control of their lives, and 'M' is the position espoused by the MPAA model bill.

Through massaging the model bill to get it to line up with the type of language in the current TN statute, we actually pulled away from the severity of the model bill slightly ('S' is the Senate bill as originally introduced):

P-----------------------+-------------------------------S----M

Giving the TCTA the benefit of doubt, the amendments have massaged things a bit, but haven't really changed much (so, 'A', is the position of the amended bill) (in fact I actually think 'A' is actually to the right of 'S', but let's pretend):

P-----------------------+-----------------------------A-S----M

The threat the opposition produced is one of not passing anything, which puts us at '+' at the end of the session -- not good for a lobbyist worth his cigars.

So, Sen. Person says "get together and work on something you can both live with". So the TNDF comes up with an amended version that (to my eyes) lies at 'T':

P-----------------------+------------------T----------A-S----M

The process of negotiation will only pull 'T' closer to 'A','S', and
'M', to produce a final bill ('F' here):

P-----------------------+------------------T------F---A-S----M

This is a simple fact of negotiating with competent negotiators. This is also game-set-and-match for us and the shills go home happy. This is also why we're better off just stalling things and trying to kill the bill in committee -- if we kill it we stay at '+', which is a big win over the negotiated bill. If we move to the General Assembly we can play this whole game there with a few rhetorical bonuses that I've harped on before.

Let's look at things from a different POV. So, here we are:

P-----------------------+-----------------------------A-S----M

I've run some analyses on the text of the bills and amendments in play in an attempt to see what the cable co's are trying to do. You'll probably want to do this yourself. Grab "billdiff" from http://www.rickbradley.com/code/billdiff/ , look at the bill comparisons I've done (on the same page), and play along at home with the bills and amendments of your choice. You will want to compare the model bill with the original proposed bill, the proposed bill with the current statute, and the amendments with original the proposed bill.
I've done cross-comparisons of all the pieces of legislation I have at my disposal at the moment.

Without looking at these bills systematically we're at a disadvantage. Fortunately we can use our technical skills to compete with $500/hr. lawyers who work by brute force.


The primary language changes to support the "cable theft update amendment" argument are systematic and small. Change the word "telecommunications" to "communications", add in some provisions to include "satellite", "microwave", "Internet", etc. as means of transmission (these are not necessary, btw, as they are covered by existing language).

The remainder of the language changes are of two types: (1) grammatical updates (the original statute has some grammatical problems), and (2) MPAA changes which do nothing to address cable theft, but everything to address moving civil matters to criminal courts (and taxpayers wallets), and guaranteeing Hollywood criminal protection of an otherwise failed business model.

All of (2) must go.

Taking the current statute and applying the changes to actually perform a "cable theft update", and adding in grammatical fixes puts you here ('F' for fixed):

P-----------------------+--F--------------------------A-S----M

This is a much better position from which to start negotiating, and has the benefit of addressing the cable shill's claimed "needs" for something to be passed, depriving them of their strongest arguments (it also provides Person with the "out" I think he might want). It b asically leaves the (bad) statute "as is" and provides protection against the Bill That Keeps Coming Back.

The difference in outcome (where we end up on the axis) is the result of starting from the opposite direction. Instead of working from 'A' and going towards '+', we'd be working from '+' and going towards 'A'. This is also why I slurred Scott earlier when I said that if he thinks that we can write an amendment using the MPAA's pen.... etc.

This process can be taken a step further. Scott's right when he says that the current statute is egregious. It is. Big parts of it should be excised. We could selectively find some pieces to drop or neuter and create a bill which gives the cable shills what they claim they "need", while fixing some existing problems that we have with the bill. That would actually put us here ('G' for good):

P-------------------G---+-----------------------------A-S----M

We will *have* to make concessions from any amended bill we submit as "livable". If we're going to play this stupid game we should make our "livable" bill be as far to the left of the scale as possible. Part of being able to do this is knowing where on the scale we are. I think the analysis we can do lexically provides some insight on laying out the continuum above and helping to meet their "need" arguments while staying as far to the left of the scale as possible.
Go to Top of Page

jody

217 Posts

Posted - 05/15/2003 :  5:55:48 PM  Show Profile  Send jody an AOL message
I think it is not only possible but imperitive to recognize that playing nice here and mean there are not exclusive. If you plan to work with legislators directly then it only makes sense to be civil to them in order to motivate them to cooperate. If that is your strategic approach you really should avoid all connection with defaming the person(little p) you are meeting with. That doesn't mean that you cannot also work the street a little. Believe me, the lobbyist and the legislators do the very same thing. One of the advantages of a group approach is that you can choose which role you want to stress: antagonist or cooperator. You must only avoid connecting your self with both styles in front of the man you are trying to influence. Personally, I take it a little further, the more inflamatory I tend to be the more I dissociate from the group which seeks to gain a legislators cooperation. When the time comes to support our efforts on the inside I do my best to tone it down. I don't think they have given little ol' me much thought, but what I helped be made known publicly sure pisses them off! :)
Go to Top of Page

pcdoc

3 Posts

Posted - 05/15/2003 :  6:39:55 PM  Show Profile  Visit pcdoc's Homepage
http://www.lp.org/lpnews/0306/aff_tenntomato.html
Go to Top of Page

Tony

214 Posts

Posted - 05/15/2003 :  11:05:21 PM  Show Profile  Visit Tony's Homepage  Send Tony an AOL message  Send Tony a Yahoo! Message
pcdoc refers to this bill, which declares, "The delicious tomato, Lycopersicon lycopersicum, is designated as the official state fruit."

Ready for the really funny part? This bill runs counter to federal law, since the Supreme Court ruled in 1887 that the tomato is a vegetable.
Go to Top of Page
Page: of 3 Previous Topic Topic Next Topic  
Next Page
 New Topic  Topic Locked
 Printer Friendly
Jump To:
Tennessee Digital Freedom Forum © 2003 TNDF.net Go To Top Of Page
Snitz Forums 2000