| Author |
Topic  |
|
Dubber
441 Posts |
Posted - 05/16/2003 : 02:09:58 AM
|
| Finally, I have a source to win an [longstanding] argument with my wife! (and I'm actually *right*! mark it on the calendar) :-)' |
 |
|
|
SKozicki
243 Posts |
Posted - 05/16/2003 : 03:30:49 AM
|
Rick,
First, my question of whether 'you think this helps our cause?' was not rhetorical. I actually wanted to know what you thought.
Secondly, I'm glad you took the time to think through the strategy to such a degree. You have all the points on the board, and you certainly have a good grasp of the situation. It would've been extremely helpful if you had attended any of the meetings we had over the last few weeks. But I would respectfully argue that your analysis of the situation is (admittedly by you) subjective at best, and perhaps a bit misinformed.
quote: Taking the current statute and applying the changes to actually perform a "cable theft update", and adding in grammatical fixes puts you here ('F' for fixed):
P-----------------------+--F--------------------------A-S----M
That's exactly what (we think) our amendment has accomplished. It's not perfection by any stretch of the imagination. But as I put it in the meeting with Person, it's something we can get comfortable with. Modifying the MPAA versions of the bill are just varying degrees of extreme discomfort. In fact, I would say that our amendment puts us to the left of +, because it fixes things that are broken in the current statute, like using NAT or other 'concealing' technologies.
Sen Person asked explicitly, "can't we just write a bill that says if you steal it's a crime?" We feel like we accomplished that. There's nothing in our amendment that prohibits you from doing tomorrow what you're doing today, as long as you're not stealing service. Plus it's 3 pages compared to 14. I think any lawmaker can get behind it just for that reason alone. ;-)
But all of this is academic. Splitting hairs about this strategy or that strategy will ultimately get us nowhere. Where the rubber meets the road is down at Legislative Plaza, and you're going to have to make phone calls, make meetings, send emails and faxes, and shake as many hands as possible to get anything done. Pontificating about where we might eventually lie on a continuum is moot if we don't actually put some sweat into it. Which is why I won't be contributing any more to this thread, because I need to be spending my time doing the above. Or we're going to end up smack dab on M. |
 |
|
|
Rick
25 Posts |
Posted - 05/16/2003 : 12:12:58 PM
|
quote:
First, my question of whether 'you think this helps our cause?' was not rhetorical. I actually wanted to know what you thought.
I think that it is helpful to make it clear to the sponsors that they're digging their own grave(s). I think it harms our cause if that is the primary message.quote: Taking the current statute and applying the changes to actually perform a "cable theft update", and adding in grammatical fixes puts you here ('F' for fixed):
P-----------------------+--F--------------------------A-S----M
That's exactly what (we think) our amendment has accomplished. It's not perfection by any stretch of the imagination. But as I put it in the meeting with Person, it's something we can get comfortable with. Modifying the MPAA versions of the bill are just varying degrees of extreme discomfort. In fact, I would say that our amendment puts us to the left of +, because it fixes things that are broken in the current statute, like using NAT or other 'concealing' technologies.
Sen Person asked explicitly, "can't we just write a bill that says if you steal it's a crime?" We feel like we accomplished that. There's nothing in our amendment that prohibits you from doing tomorrow what you're doing today, as long as you're not stealing service. Plus it's 3 pages compared to 14. I think any lawmaker can get behind it just for that reason alone. ;-)
But all of this is academic. Splitting hairs about this strategy or that strategy will ultimately get us nowhere. Where the rubber meets the road is down at Legislative Plaza, and you're going to have to make phone calls, make meetings, send emails and faxes, and shake as many hands as possible to get anything done. Pontificating about where we might eventually lie on a continuum is moot if we don't actually put some sweat into it. Which is why I won't be contributing any more to this thread, because I need to be spending my time doing the above. Or we're going to end up smack dab on M.
(I recommend the use of "one" and "we"). Some people in this organization are much better at spending their days at Legislative Plaza than others, and it's best that they be employed there. Others are better at critical analysis and strategy. One of the reasons that I attend meetings other than those held by TNDF is that I find there's little extra I can contribute to the planning of politicking that TNDF is doing (though there are things I have been able to contribute to the politicking by people working in other directions). I've felt that strategically and critically there are people who are doing good work with which I can provide assistance. Some of that work is of benefit to TNDF, hence my post in this thread.
That said, could someone pass me a copy of the current TNDF version? I would like to subject it to a more rigorous analysis. In the examination I made the bill you describe does not fit the description of the bill I read.
While I've spent plenty of time on the hill in the past month (if you're directing your advice on how to expend resources at me, my guess is that you don't realize that we even exchanged words at the last hearing; sorry I couldn't save you a seat), at every point of encounter there have always been more of us than necessary to address the people who would listen. Sometimes I stay and speak, sometimes others. Granted, for the public hearings the show of a multitude of suits helps greatly. Considering how much we've gotten to speak, however, it's almost wasteful to have anything other than warm bodies in attendance.
We are in agreement that we should be working the phones, showing up at the hearings, emailing, faxing, working with the press, etc. Where we differ is fortunately where there is room for diversity, where a wider front can do greater good.
|
 |
|
|
Scott Lyon
298 Posts |
Posted - 05/16/2003 : 12:47:26 PM
|
quote: Originally posted by Rick
That said, could someone pass me a copy of the current TNDF version? I would like to subject it to a more rigorous analysis. In the examination I made the bill you describe does not fit the description of the bill I read.
The bill posted on the tndf.com page is fairly representative. Several minor changes have been made in the past 72 hours, but a final copy will be posted shortly for everyone's review. In the course of your analysis, if you have any questions or would like any clairification, I would be happy to help.quote: Where we differ is fortunately where there is room for diversity, where a wider front can do greater good.
I guess my response is that we don't want TOO wide of a front. Although we represent the interests of the public at large, we are still something of a "minority" on legislative plaza. Initially I would agree that there was a lot of duplication of effort, which is natural considering that we were perfect strangers who came together in a short period of time. The TNDF core has coordinated its efforts and is presenting a united front to the lobbyists. We have also succeeded in allocating responsibilities based upon the talents we each bring to the effort, becoming more efficient in our opposition. It may take some time before we become a "polished" entity, if that is indeed the fate of our little group, but for now, I'm proud to say that we're working together effectively and bringing a lot of attention to bear upon the problems at hand.
Let me also add that we had no illusions that everyone would be happy with whatever amendment we produced. Everyone wants something different out of this bill and the best that we could produce was a compromise which we believed the legislature would find palatable. We did not want to offer up an amendment clearly biased in our favor and attempt to negotiate toward the middle. That negotiation is not appropriate in this circumstance because we are not trying to persuade the opposition, but to influence a third-party (the Legislature). We gain more credibility through reasoned discussion of the issues (which the legislature will not ignore) than staunch, unqualified opposition in hopes of striking a bargain. |
 |
|
|
utman
244 Posts |
|
|
Rick
25 Posts |
|
|
SKozicki
243 Posts |
Posted - 05/16/2003 : 2:48:25 PM
|
| Actually, just to clarify, there is a properly formatted version available here. It will be properly linked later today. |
 |
|
|
Scott Lyon
298 Posts |
Posted - 05/16/2003 : 3:16:09 PM
|
And just to beat the minutae critics to the punch: yes, section (c)(3) and (c)(4) should have a line break between them. While I hope this critical flaw will not cripple our amendment, I acknowledge it and accept full responsibility for it (as well as any grammatical flaws anyone may discover)..... |
 |
|
|
bucket
51 Posts |
Posted - 05/17/2003 : 04:43:47 AM
|
| Not to criticize, but § (e), the portion on civil remedies, could be drafted a but differently. If anyone wishes, I'll be glad to type up a proposed §(e) for your review. |
 |
|
|
Scott Lyon
298 Posts |
Posted - 05/17/2003 : 6:05:17 PM
|
| I admit the wording of the relief available in (e) is a little awkward, but at this point, we might want to limit changes to big changes to catch problems. Please go over this with a fine-tooth comb so we don't miss anything. The last thing we want is inadvertant consequences from our bill. I haven't spotted any yet, but please everyone take a critical look. |
 |
|
|
bucket
51 Posts |
Posted - 05/17/2003 : 6:51:57 PM
|
Scott,
I'll go upstairs & go over your proposed bill w/ a fine tooth comb, but in § e you might want to insert the word "reasonable" in front of attorney's fees.
There is a real big difference between "reasonable attorney's fees" and "attorney's fees" .
Real big. |
 |
|
|
utman
244 Posts |
Posted - 05/17/2003 : 9:25:37 PM
|
Scott:
I have professor reynolds giving it a look-see also. He is planning on giving me a written statement regarding it by monday. |
 |
|
|
bucket
51 Posts |
Posted - 05/18/2003 : 04:32:13 AM
|
After further review,
I might delete the word "any" in the exclusion portion (c)in (D)any public or private institution (E)any financial institution subject to.........
In § (c)(1), the phrase "of no substantial use" in [...a communication device capable of no substantial use other than acquiring or facilitating the...] just doesn't look right. I know exactly what was meant, but couldn't it be phrased a bit differently ? Sorry, but I wasn't able to come up with anything better that the phrase already selected.
§ e on civil remedies has already been discussed.
The rest of it looks great !!!
|
Edited by - bucket on 05/18/2003 04:35:29 AM |
 |
|
|
Scott Lyon
298 Posts |
Posted - 05/18/2003 : 09:37:12 AM
|
| Section (c)(6)(D) and (E) should have the "any" deleted (good catch). I also agree that for clarity's sake, we should make (e) read "reasonable attorneys fees." I'm not sure if the "no substantial use" language should be changed (I can't seem to formulate another string that says the same thing, but without awkwardness....I think the problem may involve grafting a copyright concept into this context). |
 |
|
|
bucket
51 Posts |
Posted - 05/18/2003 : 10:32:31 AM
|
Scott,
Before you change § e by adding the word "reasonable", would you like to examine what I typed up on that part ? A few words were omitted when you prepared your version of the proposed amendment.
|
 |
|
Topic  |
|
|
|