| Author |
Topic  |
|
|
SKozicki
243 Posts |
Posted - 05/20/2003 : 12:57:16 AM
|
| I have again updated the talking points document to reflect some good feedback, and to make sure that it is correctly inline with the current amendment of the bills. You can find it here. |
|
|
bucket
51 Posts |
Posted - 05/22/2003 : 05:35:51 AM
|
One of the talking points is: SB213/HB457 would allow an end-run on law enforcement
What disturbs me about this legislation is that: 1) Statutory penalties are provided for violations of these bills. 2)CSPs (including cable companies) are given a private right of action to sue for these statutory penalties. 3)CSPs (including cable companies)are given the power to define exactly what is a violation for which they are allowed to recover their statutory damages.
This legislation goes far beyond an end run on law enforcement.
|
 |
|
|
SKozicki
243 Posts |
Posted - 05/22/2003 : 08:40:33 AM
|
This may sound a little like advocacy for the other side, but I'm purely pointing it out because this is the rebuttal you'll get if you make the points that you did.
1) It's common to included statutory penalties. In fact, it might be preferred. In our amendment, we leave it open to the court, because we believe that the court will do the right thing in determining ACTUAL LOSSES. IF there is to be any punitive damage, then it's also in the domain of the court. The current bill sets the minimum @ $1500 per day per device. Not setting it explicitly allows $0 to be the number that's determined. We think that's simpler, and certainly the court can determine what's best on a case by case basis instead of hard wiring it in the law.
2) This is also common. If someone stole something from you, would you not also want the ability to sue them in civil court? Particularly if the state didn't (or couldn't) pursue them? The key difference here is that you're not a humongous monopoly with almost unlimited finances compared to any of the potential targets of the bill. This particular section, while common, is certainly open to abuse and basically gives the CSP the ability to utilize their own stick to enforce the law. Unacceptable despite appearing as a 'right' of the plantiff.
3) This is actually not true to a point. They would have to argue in court what the violation is, and the court would have to see it their way. It's frankly unlikely that a lot of the egregious examples we give would actually get prosecuted in court. Reason would set in, and the defendant would probably prevail. Of course, there's always the possibility that they wouldn't and that's why we're trying to defeat the bill. It opens the door, however slight, to this kind of abuse. The key thing to remember here is that most of these cases won't ever get to court. Here is where the real abuse comes. Because of the ambiguous language and sweeping nature of the bills, it opens the door far wider for predatory lawyers to draw people into paying settlements. When you could potentially be on the hook for $1500/day/device, you're going to try and settle.
So in the end, we don't want to look like we're trying to strip away the rights of the plantiff to the point where they're defenseless. Afterall, there are some people who actually think this bill helps stop cable theft. But let's point out the exceptional flaws that occur by granting those rights, and the potential abuse that may result. |
 |
|
|
Dubber
441 Posts |
Posted - 05/22/2003 : 08:54:59 AM
|
| I've forgotten, in the "little get together" Rep. Briley called several week ago, didn't he say he "is a plaintiff's lawyer" in his day job? |
 |
|
|
bucket
51 Posts |
Posted - 05/22/2003 : 09:18:32 AM
|
It looks like, again, I didn't make myself sufficiently clear. My problem was with all three points taken together. To me, the provisions appear to constitute a real bonanza for a plaintiff's attorney.
|
 |
|
| |
Topic  |
|
|
|