Tennessee Digital Freedom Forum
Tennessee Digital Freedom Forum
Home | Profile | Register | Active Topics | Members | Search | FAQ
Username:
Password:
Save Password
Forgot your Password?

 All Forums
 Tennessee Technology Legislation
 Players
 People are talking
 New Topic  Reply to Topic
 Printer Friendly
Author Previous Topic Topic Next Topic  

jody

395 Posts

Posted - 06/12/2003 :  09:05:45 AM  Show Profile  Send jody an AOL message  Reply with Quote
GOOD MORNING FELLOW FREEDOM FIGHTERS!

Just when you thought the fizzle had futzed on this site regarding activity to defeat the Super DMCA, I had a chance encounter with someone from Vandy who was meeting with a large electronics manufacturer to discuss opposition to the bills. This reminded me that we still need to be active in meeting with our allies and with the funny people of the legislature. Please continue to make contact with as many people as you can in order to stay informed on meetings of any kind, not just the study panel meetings.

One of the factoids I gained from speaking with my Vanderbilt connection was that there may be some additional language that was formally introduced as amendments past amendment number 1. I believe Tony is checking up on that and will post any further documents to the site. It might seem like a trivial, if not moot point to talk about language during summer study. But it will be the basis of talks that go on between the advocates and opponents of this legislation and we will need to stay up to date on that where possible.

I hope those of you who developed contacts with legislators and their assistants are still calling on them periodically for updates. Also, if you have contacts with allies in the retail and manufacturing world keep after them to brief us on their activity to oppose the legislation. We need to have some flies on the wall working with any of the legislators who might be able to inform us on even the most sublime developments. We can't wait to be publicly informed of developments as we were in the beginning. The bill hasn't died by any stretch of the imagination, and people are talking.

Terry

2 Posts

Posted - 06/12/2003 :  2:59:29 PM  Show Profile  Reply with Quote
Just to let you guys know that Florida's governer has signed their version of the law.

Like most states where this bill is being introduced people found out late.

Below are 12 observations on that bill, seems like we could borrow some of this thought and languague.

Afterwards is a copy of a letter sent to the Florida governer by the Consumer Electronics group/assocaiation. Maybe we can start writing to our governer as well and combine points that have been developed by this group and the information below.

I like the way the messages convey the negative impact on economy and personal freedoms.

Concerns with Florida Theft of Services Bill

1. The bill suffers from a basic conceptual flaw. The prohibited acts are so broad that they cover literally all conduct (e.g., receipt, acquisition, transmission) performed by a consumer, service provider or device manufacturer in connection with communications services or the content and information provided over communications services. Absent “express authorization” of the “service provider,” all that stands between every citizen and enormous liability are certain specific exceptions and an undefined concept of “intent to defraud.” This places enormous power in the hands of the service provider to define what is “authorized” and what is “theft.” In essence, the bill prohibits naked “intent to defraud.”
2. The bill’s definition of communications service is overly broad. It includes not only every communications service, but also the content, information and data that are provided by a service. The term also extends to the Internet. Thus, any information provided on a web site or over a communications system is, itself, a “communications service.”
3. The bill does not focus on “theft.” Rather, it targets everyday activity—including receiving, transmitting and aquiring access to content. It declares such activity unlawful unless done with “express authorization” of the communications service provider. Authorization for many everyday activities is rarely “express.” As a result:
a. The bill treads on the rights of consumers to act after they have lawfully received content by prohibiting transmission, retransmission and assisting others to receive, among other things. This invades the province of copyright law and allows content providers to dictate the uses of content and consumer electronics devices. For example, the “fair use” transmission of a clip of news or other information to a family member, if not expressly authorized, could lead to liability.
b. The bill threatens everyday commerce on the Internet. Content on generally accessible websites has been considered to be freely accessible. Now, a simple statement telling surfers to “Don’t Go There” will subject individuals to potentially huge liability if they nevertheless visit a site.
c. The bill would interfere with the right of consumers to attach devices (and software) to their personal home network. If the service provider’s contract prohibits a personal video recorder, such as a TiVo, receipt of the service on such a device would not be with “express authorization,” and would subject the individual to huge statutory damages and possibly criminal prosecution.
d. The bill turns violations of terms of service agreements into statutory torts and crimes. If the service provider says an act is not within the scope of the fee paid for service, or will be allowed only upon payment of an additional fee, the service is not received with “express authorization.”
4. There is no apparent reason to focus the prohibition on devices. All of the identified acts involve some form of device. Thus, the bill inappropriately causes consumers to point the finger at the device provider.
5. The scienter standard provides insufficient comfort. Much conduct is done “knowingly.” “Intent to defraud” is undefined and may be proven by the circumstances surrounding the conduct. When is knowing conduct done without express authorization likely to be deemed not done with the “intent to defraud.” Florida allows proof of this intent entirely by presumption or circumstantial evidence. A definition of intent to defraud, involving artifice, should be included.
6. Paragraph 4 concerning the mere possession of devices does not even have an intent to defraud standard. Thus, it creates enormous risks for device manufacturers and retailers. The limitation with respect to the “primary usefulness” of the device provides limited protection given the breadth of the potential violations. For example, a device designed to connect to the Internet is intended primarily to receive content from websites. Most websites do not provide “express authorization” for viewing or even downloading content. Similarly unbounded liability is created by paragraph 5.
7. The exception for multi-purpose devices provides some protection for manufacturers, but it does not protect any of the users of our devices. Further, given the breadth of the prohibitions, the protection even for manufacturers may prove illusory.
8. The bill exposes legitimate service providers to huge risk if it provides services to those who act without authorization. The exception in paragraph 11 is limited by two of the elements of the offense in paragraph 2.
9. The prohibition on circumvention in paragraph 2 overlaps and greatly expands the scope of already controversial Federal anti-circumvention law.
10. The bill includes Draconian sanctions for the every-day conduct described above. Fines accrue “each day” and “for each device.” Further, each component of a device is, itself, a device. Attorneys’ fees are available for a prevailing plaintiff but not for a prevailing defendant, further encouraging questionable claims.
11. The definition of actual damages is similarly over-broad and unrelated to any injury actually caused. Attempts to prove the retail value of services “illegally available” to a person with a device will be rife with speculation. Statutory damages should not accrue for each device, and enhancements for “each day” and “each device” are even more unreasonable.
12. The over-broad definitions, damage presumptions and huge potential damage liability will ensure that the civil cause of action will be abused and stretched as far as words or resources permit.


**********************************************************************
************* Consumer Electronics Letter ***************************

June 3, 2003


The Honorable Jeb Bush
Governor
The State of Florida
PL-05 The Capitol
400 South Monroe Street
Tallahassee, FL 32399-0001


Dear Governor Bush:

The Florida Retail Federation requests your veto of HB 79, relating to communications services. Today’s ordinary consumer sales could become criminal or of uncertain legality under this bill. It creates new civil causes of action against retailers, and would seriously impede the availability of current and future generations of consumer electronics.

HB 79 was advocated by the telecommunications and entertainment industry as a means to end piracy of copyrighted materials by discouraging the sale and distribution of consumer electronics products that may be used for, or may be altered for the purposes of defrauding communications services providers. This bill targets the Retail Industry for litigation.

Committee staff analysis indicates that this legislation was presented as expanding the scope of present law, which already addresses theft of service, to cover new network services, and new digital home devices. However, the new coverage in this legislation extends primarily to home network devices that receive, display, and transmit or retransmit content or data after it has been lawfully acquired by the consumer. In this regard, as the staff analyses also note, it treads dangerously on federal communications (and, particularly, copyright) law and Florida constitutional law, in making other private parties the arbiter of the legality of consumer use of home network devices, the right of manufacturers to make such devices, and the right of retailers to stock and sell them.

This bill is not about the unauthorized decryption of network services, which is already addressed by existing law. Rather, its purpose and effect are to subject the use of new digital recording devices (e.g., a “Personal Video Recorder) and transmission devices (e.g., a “Wi-Fi” connection) to the specific authorization and private regulation of entertainment creators and content distributors. Consumer practices such as home recording, and peer-to-peer “sharing,” are controversial and may be legal or illegal under federal copyright and communications law. As governed by HB 79, however, they become not only state criminal issues, but also state civil issues that are subject to enormously enhanced actual and statutory damages.

The bill creates onerous criminal penalties for retailers, including felony penalties, for the mere holding of retail inventory of consumer electronics products. Under the expansive definitions in the bill, even consumer electronics products as innocuous as a desktop computer may be determined to have been sold for the purposes of piracy and fraud.

The bill provides for the impoundment of devices, and for statutory damages of $50,000 per device (and per component of device!), based on a “primary use” test that is inconsistent with federal copyright law (which, in the landmark 1984 “Betamax” case, established that a product may be lawfully distributed if it has any commercially significant lawful use). Retailers stocking 50 or more items face felony charges, in addition to catastrophic damages and attorneys’ fees in private actions. Their only protection are “multipurpose device” and “intent to defraud” clauses with fundamental loopholes:

¨ a Betamax VCR could fail the “multipurpose device” exclusion if its lawful uses were found to be “limited,” or if distributed with “knowledge” of a violation;

¨ the requirement of an “intent to defraud” is undefined, and subject, under Florida case law, to constructive interpretations based on ordinary conduct. Such a finding could be based simply on continued sale of a digital video recorder, a Wi-Fi product, etc., to consumers once a private party has sued any consumer claiming that a particular installation or use of such a home network product is “unauthorized.” The entertainment industry proponents of this legislation have consistently resisted any statutory definition of “With Intent To Defraud,” even though one is available based on jury instructions used in federal signal theft cases.


To err on the side of caution under such law would lead retailers to simply refuse to sell broad categories of consumer electronics products. It would deny Florida consumers access to leading edge technologies, or lead Florida consumers to the murky waters or remote sales, from which the state rarely receives due sales & use taxes.

Private litigation pursuant to this bill also could do damage to Florida’s business climate -- after electronics manufacturers, retailers, and consumer groups focused on the breadth and consequences of such provisions, a similar bill was vetoed by Governor Owens of Colorado and withdrawn by its sponsor in Oregon; high profile debates resulted in the recent failure to pass of similar provisions in Tennessee and Texas. In Arkansas, the governor has indicated that their law, passed around the same time as HB 79, will be reviewed in a special session.

Should HB 79 be signed into law, Florida will offer one of the most favorable litigation climates for the entertainment industry. There is a good likelihood that Florida will become the center of a massive litigation effort that the entertainment industry has been longing for.

The Florida Retail Federation regrets that HB 79 did not come to our attention until late in the regular session. Flying under the banner of a bill relating to communication services, it was brought to our attention by national consumer electronics retailing businesses. While we did engage in limited dialog with the advocates of the legislation, they did not agree to amend or modify the bill to address our concerns. Published reports have indicated that the motion picture industry finally is willing to consider the substantial modifications that have been proposed by the Consumer Electronics Association and others. We are committed to working with the entertainment industry on reasonable solutions in the future.

For all the foregoing reasons, we respectfully ask that you veto HB 79.

Sincerely,


Bill Herrle
Vice President, Government Affairs
& Political Action

Best,
Go to Top of Page

jody

395 Posts

Posted - 06/12/2003 :  3:40:25 PM  Show Profile  Send jody an AOL message  Reply with Quote
Thanks for the hard work on this one Terry. Without thoroughly reviewing the point by point I find what I do see to be the best so far produced. Who gets the credit for it? I also like the CEA letter to Jeb, especially the part about loss of revenue on a whole class of electronic devices. If one posits that the CEA is better able to judge the effectiveness of arguments to persuade lawmakers then one can certainly learn from their example.

NOTE: The above is all relative to the Florida version of the bill. Perhaps there is a need to transmutate it to fit the Tennessee version.

Edited by - jody on 06/12/2003 3:53:06 PM
Go to Top of Page
  Previous Topic Topic Next Topic  
 New Topic  Reply to Topic
 Printer Friendly
Jump To:
Tennessee Digital Freedom Forum © 2003 TNDF.net Go To Top Of Page
Snitz Forums 2000