| Author |
Topic  |
|
|
jody
187 Posts |
Posted - 06/18/2003 : 09:43:15 AM
|
I don't know how many of you caught the headlines about Senator Orrin Hatch's public support of property destruction in defense of Copyright. If you didn't then I offer: http://www.beggingtodiffer.com/archives/2003_06.html#000149
And HOW does this relate to the Super DMCA? Here is my spin:
Senator Hatch, in his public support allowing the RIAA to destroy the computers of people it suspects has violated their copyrights with out due process and only a few simple electronic warnings, shows the degree to which Politicians are out of touch with the letter and spirit of the law, the common citizen, and how deeply sympathetic to a narrow interest they can be. In Tennessee you need only consider the politicians who sponsor similar legislation, like the Super DMCA to see once again where the politicians sympathy is. In the mind of such politicians it is a foregone conclusion that the narrow interest group they support has suffered "harm" at the hands of the general public and it is that politicians job to legislate some kind of relief. In other words, they are telling the general public "I am going to do something for this group so decide what you are prepared to concede and I might consider it." In Senator Hatch's example he is ready to concede the rights of citizens to due process and the empowerment of a narrow business interest to administer justice and property forfeiture outside of our judicial system. In the case of Tennessee's Super DMCA laws politicians were prepared to give over control of the internet to the cable and telecommunication monopolies to dictate to consumers what they can do with their internet connection and how much it will cost them. Supposedly this was to permit the content creators and distributors to prevent theft of their copyrighted works, even if it prevented all other legitimate uses consumers and other business interest may have. The principle is the same: the narrow interest group receives higher consideration then common citizens. I don't think any politician would ever come out and say that in public, though. |
Edited by - jody on 06/18/2003 09:45:27 AM
|
|
|
utman
76 Posts |
Posted - 06/18/2003 : 10:14:04 AM
|
Well said.
I stand more incredulous of recent events as each day passes. Someone, somewhere, has to put together a MASSIVE education program to get our lawmakers literate...that or try to get them replaced.
His statements left me speechless. |
 |
|
|
Scott Lyon
77 Posts |
Posted - 06/18/2003 : 1:13:20 PM
|
You know what's even worse than copyright infringement: shoplifting. Every year retailers suffer an ever-increasing ACTUAL PHYSICAL loss as a result of shoplifting (termed: shrinkage).
If left unchecked, this crime could put retailers out of business!! I support Sen. Hatch's level-headed approach to crime and punishment and suggest that we borrow an age-old Middle Eastern remedy: the first two times you steal, you will be warned, but on the third theft, the state will sever the offending appendages. I would support a government study to confirm my hypothesis, that amputees shoplift less than thieves with hands.
My hat is off to Senator Hatch for finally having the guts to say publicly what all of us extremists have only fantasized about! Bravo, Mein Herr!!! Bravo!!!
(forcibly removing tongue from cheek) |
Edited by - Scott Lyon on 06/18/2003 1:15:39 PM |
 |
|
|
Scott Lyon
77 Posts |
Posted - 06/18/2003 : 1:13:42 PM
|
| [self-censored] |
Edited by - Scott Lyon on 06/18/2003 1:14:23 PM |
 |
|
|
utman
76 Posts |
|
|
jody
187 Posts |
Posted - 06/18/2003 : 3:30:47 PM
|
I wonder if slashdot would be interested in posting a link to Senator Hatch's web site so people could check it out for themself?
Which reminds me: exactly what kind of destruction was the Senator imagining would be done to a violators computer? Did he conceive of a remote detonator that would explode inside the computer case? Maybe something with less collateral damage like a surge through the ethernet cable which fries the motherboard? Or maybe he meant excluding the RIAA from the piracy laws like the DMCA so they could root the target computer? Maybe it was something much simpler like a heat guided missle that locks on to a 2GHz processor like a bulldog? Hmmm, collateral damage again. ;-) |
 |
|
|
bucket
41 Posts |
|
| |
Topic  |
|
|
|