Tennessee Digital Freedom Forum
Tennessee Digital Freedom Forum
Home | Profile | Register | Active Topics | Members | Search | FAQ
Username:
Password:
Save Password
Forgot your Password?

 All Forums
 Tennessee Technology Legislation
 Legislation
 Sept 10 meeting wrap up
 New Topic  Reply to Topic
 Printer Friendly
Author Previous Topic Topic Next Topic  

SKozicki

243 Posts

Posted - 09/10/2003 :  1:46:04 PM  Show Profile  Send SKozicki an AOL message  Reply with Quote
Today's meeting was purely organizational, and fairly quick.

Announced at today's meeting was who would chair and co-chair the committee. Senator Larry Trail is chairman. Representative Gary Odom is co-chair.

On the surface, this looks like good news to us, since Senator Trail was mostly sympathetic to our cause in the spring. He voiced specifically that his concerns were that the issues became so vague and the terminology so foreign that it literally scared them off of the bill, but that something needs to be passed. I believe it was Senator Trail who uttered the classic line "I feel like I'm at the United Nations and my earpiece fell out." Senator Person quoted that line in today's hearing. Senator Trail asked that the committee appoint a 'translator' for all the 'technospeak'.

The various committee members talked about the judiciary hearings and what was the root issue behind the bill. They debated the merits of having a Cable Theft statute versus a Communications Theft statute. Representative Briley articulated very well the background and set the stage for the future, mentioning that there are already statutes that reflect stealing, stealing of a service, and stealing of a telecom service. He mentioned that the 1996 law is out of date and needs to be updated. This sets the stage well for our amendment language. The committee members asked that both sides (Us and Them) provide them with summaries of our issues to help those who weren't involved (and those that were) get up to speed quickly and refresh their memories.

Stacey Briggs the TCTA Director and I both had a few minutes at the podium. Ms. Briggs spoke first and mentioned that cable theft is still a huge issue in TN. She mentioned that the laws on the books are for an 'analog world' and that the industry is moving digital. She said that they would be happy to bring in various 'experts' to discuss the issues for the committee.

I got a chance to speak and stated that we would promise not to use 'technospeak'. I said that the spirit of the issue here is simple: don't steal service. It doesn't need to get any more complicated than that. I was asked if a 2 page law was sufficient and I agreed with that. I missed this as an opportunity to bring up our amendment. (Hindsight is 20/20, eh?).

I began a soliloquy by pointing out that one of our concerns is where does the TCTA get their numbers from? To our eyes, the $130M number that is being floated around for TN is simply the NCTA's $6.5B opportunity cost number divided by 50. Until we have some idea of what this number is clearly derived from, we cannot begin to select an appropriate response. I was asked what I thought this number was, and I responded by saying that this is opportunity cost, not actual costs. No telecom reports these as losses on their financial statements or SEC reports. This seemed to resonate with the committee.

I pointed out that the TCTA has provided no data on # of convictions for theft of service, # of attempts to convict, # of suspects, or any other scope data to help us determine how much of a real 'threat' cable theft is. Surely, any theft is bad, but do we need to create a law to fight 50 people? Does the cable industry not factor in 'shrinkage' into their financials?

I was asked what our issues were with the bill. I ticked off a list of the highlights: freedom of speech issues, economic chilling effect, anti-consumer behavior, support of monopoly business practices, chilling of research & development, etc. I mentioned that we have about a dozen key issues with the model bill. I was asked specifically about the freedom of speech issues. My reply was that the model bill and the amended bill still contained language that would prohibit anyone from having instructions (without clear intent language) or from distributing instructions on anything that could be construed as a means to 'steal' service. My example was that if you told your neighbor that connecting a splitter in the line would allow you to get a free service, you'd be a Class D felon automatically. This sent a shudder through the committee.

Representative Briley concluded by setting the stage for what needs to be done: craft a bill that prohibits the behavior of stealing without getting bogged down in specific technologies or methods. He added that Vanderbilt has a considerable concern about liability and other effects of the model bill.

Sen Person reminded the committee that significant work had been done to mark up the model bill by working with us. He emphasized that he felt like significant progress had been made to draw a consensus.

There were various discussions between committee members on scheduling and timing of further action. It's the belief of the committee that they will need to start sooner rather than later.

My subsequent conversations after the committee adjourned revealed that Representative Briley is still not interested in supporting the model bill or possibly even the amended bill. We are scheduled to get together soon to discuss details around this. I think he's 'seen the light' and is definitely on track to craft something that simply makes stealing service against the law.

Sen Person seems to be more inclined to pick up where we left off and continue to hammer on the amended bill. I told him that my concern is that we cannot do that and he responded that the committee would have to craft new language. After talking with Anne Carr and Stacey Briggs, I got the feeling that they are not willing to budge off of the amended bill, although I had a lengthy conversation with Stacey and she agreed to take a look at our amendment and make their suggestions to it. I think that's a positive sign, but the proof will be in the pudding as they say.

Overall, I believe we're in for another long tough fight. The MPAA and RIAA are fully in the open on this one. Ms Briggs said they would be bringing in a guy from the MPAA (in place of Beauchamp, who is equally despised on both sides I believe) as an expert witness. Tony Thompson, MPAA lobbyist for TN was present. This concerns me greatly in that we have upwards of six months of various hearings and scheduling conflicts to work through against a cadre of lawyers, shills, and professional influencers to contend with. If defeating this issue during the general session last spring was a sprint, this is the marathon. The positives seem to be that the House sponsor 'gets it', the chair of the committee 'gets it', and everyone keeps talking about dealing strictly and simply with the original intent of the law. However, this is politics - Tennessee style - so anything is possible since no one is committed until the vote's been cast.

I committed to providing the committee members with summaries of our issues with the bill, as well as working with Anne and Stacey on meeting to discuss compromises. They owe me a few documents and I owe them some. We are targeting the first or second week of October as a meeting date. Stay tuned...

jody

395 Posts

Posted - 09/10/2003 :  3:25:15 PM  Show Profile  Send jody an AOL message  Reply with Quote
I move that we have f2f meeting to verify the "won't budge" issues along with "can compromise" issues before Scott meets with Stacy or the committee to provide that list. Let's 'sign-off' on a printed version for consistency. It's time to get back in the game. Do I have a second?
Go to Top of Page

utman

244 Posts

Posted - 09/10/2003 :  11:16:53 PM  Show Profile  Visit utman's Homepage  Send utman an AOL message  Reply with Quote
Well i'll just say this.

Sounds like scott is doing a great job in Nashville. I'd love to chip in, but I have a VERY busy semester. I plan to really cut back on my classes and hours in the Spring so I can jump into the fray when this thing goes back to the floor.

Until then i'll be lurking :)
Go to Top of Page

david

5 Posts

Posted - 09/10/2003 :  11:58:57 PM  Show Profile  Reply with Quote
I would certainly be interested in another meeting if it would help us toward organizing our next moves. It is obvious to me that the cable lobby will not rest until something is passed. I do think there are some current laws that we need to address. I have not been convinced that new laws are necessary.
Go to Top of Page
  Previous Topic Topic Next Topic  
 New Topic  Reply to Topic
 Printer Friendly
Jump To:
Tennessee Digital Freedom Forum © 2003 TNDF.net Go To Top Of Page
Snitz Forums 2000