Tennessee Digital Freedom Forum
Tennessee Digital Freedom Forum
Home | Profile | Register | Active Topics | Members | Search | FAQ
Username:
Password:
Save Password
Forgot your Password?

 All Forums
 Tennessee Technology Legislation
 Legislation
 Joint Committee Hearing on 10/28/03
 New Topic  Reply to Topic
 Printer Friendly
Author Previous Topic Topic Next Topic  

Dubber

416 Posts

Posted - 10/28/2003 :  7:14:44 PM  Show Profile  Visit Dubber's Homepage  Send Dubber a Yahoo! Message  Reply with Quote
I'll be back shortly with my (albeit brief) reminisces - I forgot my pen today.

[edit @6:56am: here is a direct link to very good notes, by Tony of TNDF] /tndf/documents/20031028_hearingnotes_tc.htm

Today we heard from representatives from several industries, including TCTA, TimeWarner, MPAA, Charter, BellSouth, and a TN Municipalities Association. All, that were asked, were completely undone by 2 or 3 simple questions.

Q1: What, specifically, is missing in the current laws?
No substantive answers were given in my view

Q2. How many prosecutions have there been obver the last ~12 months under current law?
40-50 prosecutions seemed to be the agreed upon statistic

Q2a. How many successful prosecutions?
Hemmed & hawed then said ~40-50

Q2b. How many *un*successful prosectutions?
Hemmed and hawed and never really gave an answer beyond a dodgy sounding "we don't go after everybody" type answer. Plus the TW guy, I think it was him at least, said that his company was aware of at least 60,000 cable service thieves in Memphis alone?! Why aren't they prosecuting these? They've got 40-50 successful prosecutions *using current laws* -- showing that it can be done.

Q3. See Q1 - no presenter today had an answer for this.

My impression is that the proponents of the SB213/HB457 Ammendment #1 are merely looking for a big stick with a big statutory damage award to wave at people - as they serve cease and desist orders. To me this amounts to corporate vigilanteism since most 'average joes' do not have the clout to resist/fight back especially when they are not doing something unlawful.

The complaint seems, to me, to be the cable companies have to continually go around and police their lines to be sure no one is stealing service. IMHO, if the companies would merely require authentication from the cable boxes and 'cable modems' to the server head (the TW guy's term) the cable companies troubles would be quickly lowered. In the case of the digital filters allowing free Pay-per-View, the filter would block the authentication request and the viewer would not be authorized to receive the show.

Plus, there are technological remedies that are more effective than the blunt instrument of law. Heck, just turn the service off at the offending locations. Then, if the problem arises there again, the current theft statutes cover it - which was baldly admitted by the TW guy - and these have been shown to be effective 40-50 times in the last year.
-Aaron W. Dobbs
:-)'

jody

395 Posts

Posted - 10/28/2003 :  9:19:12 PM  Show Profile  Send jody an AOL message  Reply with Quote
Well, I just finished writing a long winded opinion when the login bogey man zapped me. Oh well, I'm sure I will get out my points sometime.

The 40 to 50 prosecuted cases, and the 60,000 potential cases, were all a part of Time Warners network. The same questions would still apply to all the other cable companies, and I doubt they could provide an answer to them. I believe Chairman Trail brought the inadequate or misleading fiscal impact statement to light following this testimony. But then that somehow led to an admission that it was civil and not criminal woop ass they were looking for. ...I think.

When will the cable companies learn how they are being used by the MPAA in this matter? They really looked foolish attempting to make their case or defend their allegations concerning the current law. Why? Because the existing law does protect them; it doesn't protect the MPAA very well, though!

Terms of Service
Oranges Resold
Breach of Contract
Intent to Defraud
Due Process
Judicial Discretion
Actual Damages
...it all just goes round and round and round....

Edited by - jody on 10/28/2003 9:30:37 PM
Go to Top of Page

Tony

400 Posts

Posted - 10/28/2003 :  11:08:50 PM  Show Profile  Visit Tony's Homepage  Send Tony an AOL message  Send Tony a Yahoo! Message  Reply with Quote
quote:
Well, I just finished writing a long winded opinion when the login bogey man zapped me.
You know, I never type anything but a brief message (like this one) online. Anything gets very involved, and I do in my favorite editor (UltraEdit, if your must know) and then copy/paste. The slings and arrows of outrageous website timeouts don't bother me then.
Go to Top of Page

jody

395 Posts

Posted - 10/28/2003 :  11:34:16 PM  Show Profile  Send jody an AOL message  Reply with Quote
Good point! But I started out brief and then just got carried away!
Go to Top of Page
  Previous Topic Topic Next Topic  
 New Topic  Reply to Topic
 Printer Friendly
Jump To:
Tennessee Digital Freedom Forum © 2003 TNDF.net Go To Top Of Page
Snitz Forums 2000