Tennessee Digital Freedom Forum
Tennessee Digital Freedom Forum
Home | Profile | Register | Active Topics | Members | Search | FAQ
Username:
Password:
Save Password
Forgot your Password?

 All Forums
 Tennessee Technology Legislation
 Legislation
 [OT]ridiculous bill on Ohio governor's desk
 New Topic  Reply to Topic
 Printer Friendly
Author Previous Topic Topic Next Topic  

Tony

400 Posts

Posted - 11/23/2003 :  10:15:50 PM  Show Profile  Visit Tony's Homepage  Send Tony an AOL message  Send Tony a Yahoo! Message  Reply with Quote
[Cross-posted from TNDF-L@LIST . APSU . EDU]
<http://www.legislature.state.oh.us/BillText125/125_HB_179_PS_Y.pdf>

Stuck in the middle of a bill to prevent theft of services, such as revoking the drivers' licenses of those who leave a gas station without paying for gas pumped, we find this legislative gem:
quote:
Sec. 2913.07.
(A) As used in this section:
(1) "Audiovisual recording function" means the capability of a device to record or transmit a motion picture or any part of a motion picture by means of any technology existing on, or developed after, the effective date of this section.
(2) "Facility" includes all retail establishments and movie theaters.
(B) No person, without the written consent of the owner or lessee of the facility and of the licensor of the motion picture, shall knowingly operate an audiovisual recording function of a device in a facility in which a motion picture is being shown.
(C) Whoever violates division (B) of this section is guilty of motion picture piracy, a misdemeanor of the first degree on the first offense and a felony of the fifth degree on each subsequent offense.
[...]
Seems like the MPAA has been busy at the state level again (in addition to the camcorder/prosecute-our-employees bill they floated for Congress). Evidently this bill has reached the governor's desk in Ohio.

Anybody know if the stench of this thing has been wafted in TN?

Rick
--
http://www.rickbradley.com MUPRN: 824
| have tried with it seem
random email haiku | to understand the signal
| it is sending out.

utman

218 Posts

Posted - 11/23/2003 :  11:09:17 PM  Show Profile  Visit utman's Homepage  Send utman an AOL message  Reply with Quote
I'm having a hard time coming up with anything wrong with it. Certainly, taking a camcorder to a theater in order to record it isn't really behavior we should be protecting.
Go to Top of Page

Tony

400 Posts

Posted - 11/24/2003 :  01:06:06 AM  Show Profile  Visit Tony's Homepage  Send Tony an AOL message  Send Tony a Yahoo! Message  Reply with Quote
quote:
Certainly, taking a camcorder to a theater in order to record it isn't really behavior we should be protecting.
True. Nor should we protect cable theft, but we do fight against overbroad language and draconian penalties out of proportion to any damages.

Want to become a felon in Ohio?
  • Wait until this bill is signed into law.
  • Walk into any Ohio "retail establishment" that sells camcorders, digital cameras, PDAs or anything else with an "audiovisual recording function."
  • Pick one up and use that function.
  • Repeat.
Congratulations, you're now an unconvicted felon. Assuming, of course, that "a motion picture is being shown" anywhere in that facility. Have you ever been in a Best Buy and not seen some movie showing somewhere?

Note that the bill does not require the motion picture to be shown for a profit, or even to be shown legally. It also does not require the "audiovisual recording function" to actually be used to record the motion picture. Also, since the term "motion picture" is not defined in this bill, violations would not be restricted to the MPAA's notion of a motion picture.
Go to Top of Page

Tony

400 Posts

Posted - 11/24/2003 :  02:19:07 AM  Show Profile  Visit Tony's Homepage  Send Tony an AOL message  Send Tony a Yahoo! Message  Reply with Quote
I've submitted this story to Slashdot; there's a copy of the submitted story in my journal.

[Update: The story was published by Slashdot.]
Go to Top of Page

utman

218 Posts

Posted - 11/24/2003 :  10:31:35 AM  Show Profile  Visit utman's Homepage  Send utman an AOL message  Reply with Quote
I see your point and agree.
Go to Top of Page

jody

395 Posts

Posted - 11/24/2003 :  12:54:03 PM  Show Profile  Send jody an AOL message  Reply with Quote
While it is certainly unpleasant to read about the Ohio shenanigans we don't want to side-track ourselves for their cause...yet. I have a feeling we may well see a similar attempt in Tennessee next legislative session. The lesson I get from Ohio is that we need to be monitoring all of the new legislation for such technology related efforts here at home. Perhaps we can divy up the bills as they are entered into the record and scour through them looking for potential technology related initiatives. Once identified we can converse about our findings and establish a list of which ones to watch further and which ones require action. I wish we could get a sneak peek at the bills currently in gestation, but we have to wait until January, as far as I can tell, before we can begin reviewing.
Go to Top of Page

nathan

48 Posts

Posted - 11/25/2003 :  5:32:04 PM  Show Profile  Reply with Quote
quote:
Originally posted by utman
I'm having a hard time coming up with anything wrong with it. Certainly, taking a camcorder to a theater in order to record it isn't really behavior we should be protecting.
Here's another scenario:

We decide to hold our sons birthday party in the "Party Room" at the local pizza shop. As part of the party, we stick in a video of The Lion King so the kids can watch it (if they would just stop running in circles long enough to notice it is on). As with any kid's birthday party, at least one video camera is rolling. Will this long honored tradition now come to a screeching halt?

Last year we rented a room at the YMCA, and a TV was on in the adjoining room and several other rooms in the facility. Several video cameras were going. I just wonder if the Y would count as a "Facility" under this bill's definition.

Jody, you are absolutely right. We need to come up with a plan of divying up and reviewing the bills next session. However, will we yet have the capacity to deal with any of them beyond the Theft of Service bill? At the very least, I propose we post info about such bills in a dedicated forum. This way, those who are interested can at least be made aware of such legislation and write their legislators to let them know how they feel.

While scouring, it is important to remember to re-check the bills periodically. I think they could have language added to them right up to the time the reach the floor.
Go to Top of Page

Tony

400 Posts

Posted - 01/31/2004 :  10:02:47 AM  Show Profile  Visit Tony's Homepage  Send Tony an AOL message  Send Tony a Yahoo! Message  Reply with Quote
This legislation was introduced here in Tennessee on Monday, albeit in an improved form, by Senator Person. Rep. Briley is a cosponsor of the House version which was introduced on Wednesday.

Please direct discussion of SB2683 to this topic in Secondary Targets.
Go to Top of Page
  Previous Topic Topic Next Topic  
 New Topic  Reply to Topic
 Printer Friendly
Jump To:
Tennessee Digital Freedom Forum © 2003 TNDF.net Go To Top Of Page
Snitz Forums 2000