I just met very briefly with Rep. McMillan, who is also Majorityleader. I believe it went quite well. She told me I had three minutes, because she was in a hurry, but I think I got at least five. She had someone else in the room, and he did most of the question-asking, and seemed to be relatively well versed with the bill. The major points I covered were: --This bill covers all services, currently including cable, satellite, and internet, but soon could cover electrical service if we can get internet over that. --This bill requires that the service provider in question approve every device connected to your service, including speakers, televisions, all software, Microsoft upgrades, TiVo (which the assistant was aware of). --This bill will bring us back to the equivalent of 1980 in the telecom world, when AT&T had to approve every device and charged for each of them. --I can have a stolen car for a month and it's one crime, I can possess cocaine for a month and it's one crime, but if I break this law for a month, it's 30 crimes. --This bill abridges free speech by eliminating our right to possess or distribute information related to the forbidden acts. --This bill abridges privacy, because it eliminates our ability to conceal the source of communication. I specifically stated that a whistle-blower could no longer make an anonymous tip-off because of this bill. --I also explained that instant messaging (which the assistant was also familiar with) as currently implemented would be illegal, because it conceals the final destination of the traffic (which is its whole point). --As I was leaving, Rep. McMillan asked how I found out about the bill (I said "Slashdot.org, kind of a geek/technical news site") and what I do ("computer consultant"). I explained that I work hourly and that it was costing me money to talk to them. As I said, they both seemed somewhat receptive. Rep. McMillan didn't speak much, but what she did say was mostly in the way of clarification of my statements and inquisition, which I think is good. As I was leaving, I handed them copies of Mike Gowan's summary of what's wrong with the bill.
Also, on my way back to work, I stopped by Cafe Coco here in Nashville and dropped off one of each of the flyers, and talked to the owner. They serve wireless, and he was very concerned, especially when I said that because he has an upstream service provider, it would be his responsibility to verify that each of the computers connected to his wireless network was not violating this law, which would mean inspecting every piece of software and hardware. He said he would make many copies of the flyers and "plaster" them all over his cafe. :) I also pointed him to our website and said yes, he could find his senators and representatives there, and he should definitely contact them.
-- If a `religion' is defined to be a system of ideas that contains unprovable statements, then Godel taught us that mathematics is not only a religion, it is the only religion that can prove itself to be one. -- John Barrow |