| Author |
Topic  |
|
|
jsbthree
2 Posts |
Posted - 12/17/2003 : 01:31:51 AM
|
Im not sure if this can be called a policy or a lack of a clear policy but I got one of those vague acceptable use letters that stated I had exceeded their invisible bandwidth limit. I thought it was a mistake because I pay comercial rates and we don't use it to serve anything. We do download alot of isos trying to keep up with Red Hat (now Fedora) but I fail to see how that is any business of Comcast or how it can exceed their limit.
The chilling effect on potential business is obvious. I don't know if anyone has noticed but the major software distributors (Red Hat, Suse, Novell, IBM - especially IBM ) have moved to a nearly exclusive online distribution model. Very little incentive exists to go back to cds and FedEx and for good reason. A few years ago it cost more to download a three cd Linux distro than to ship it across the country on a truck. Not so anymore. Its far cheaper to upload to servers ride the prevailing bandwidth rates. Not to mention the turnaround speed is much faster if you don't have to print, lable and ship. ect..
But the real issue is Comcast's outright false advertising. Go to any paid add they've run in the last year and you will find the word "unlimited" applied to their service. Over and over they brag about unlimited downloading ect...
There is a good discussion going on at Slashdot right now. I posted this today... my question to all is this: Has anyone else gotten this letter in Tennessee or am I alone???
The following was an answer to someone who said he didn't mind paying more for Newsgroups and that Comcast should allow people to pay more. The fact is that Comcast counts ANY bandwidth including that which youu alread pay extra for. Strange that they can get away with this and still cry for protective legislation.
I know because I have a letter sitting here in which they say - direct quote follows:
<quote> Excessive bandwidth usage may be the result of many different activities. Activities that could contribute to exceeding bandwidth limitations may include, but are not limited to:
* Commercial or business applications, * Peer to peer networking, * Newsgroup downloading * file sharing, * Streaming music, video * Voice and/or video services </quote>
Now.. After reading the above I can help Comcast save a more valuable and truly limited resource -- trees. They can cut down of the amount of paper needed to send their obnoxious letters by summing up the above as "broadband" for it pretty much defines what most people consider to be the reasons to actually shell out extra for internet service. So they can reword the whole thing and simply say that using broadband internet contributes to "excessive" usage and to be certain you are not being excessive you should use dialup.
 |
|
|
jody
395 Posts |
Posted - 12/17/2003 : 09:18:22 AM
|
| You bring up a good example of the problems consumers of internet access are having today. More importantly, your example is not that of a residential end-user but of a commercial enterprise who has a "business" reason for unlimited bandwidth. You are right that if they have advertised, without exception, an unlimited bandwidth that they have engaged in false and deceptive advertising. Report them to the BBB first, then start talking to other business owners, especially businesses that are already a part of some business association, and use that as leverage to negotiate with them. Also, in partnership with other businesses that require broadband access, start lobbying both the state and federal government. So far in our state legislators have only heard from business interest that sell products for broadband use and not businesses which depend on broadband access. I believe we have seen a lobbyist for small businesses in our state show an interest in the proceedings on theft of communication even though he hasn't been asked to represent anyone in the matter, yet. |
 |
|
|
utman
218 Posts |
Posted - 12/17/2003 : 12:29:29 PM
|
I agree that this borders on false advertising. I don't think we are in a position to address that issue right now, though.
It looks like something to put on our long range watch list though. |
 |
|
|
jsbthree
2 Posts |
Posted - 12/18/2003 : 07:59:10 AM
|
I got Comcast on the phone today to clarify what my service is supposed to entail. I have the "Pro" which is exactly twice the prevailing consumer rate. For that I get 5 ip addresses and a download speed of (this part is bs but I'm telling you what it says) 4 mpbs with upload of approximately 300 kbps which is only about 25% more in each case than the consumer grade. Now here is what is interesting. Why am I paying for this at all? I was told it was for "professional use" and being that it is called "Pro" it sort of makes sense that it would be used for professional purposes. And again what is it one is supposed to do with 5 ips when of course you can put a router on the home version and have 5 or more (need a proxy server too) computers behind one nat. I didn't want to "steal" or "misrepresent" anything so I opted in good faith to pay the extra $$. This is why people are so mad about the RIAA. The deck is stacked against anyone for anything these corporate behemoths decide they don't like on a whim. Never mind that they made a deal. They have fine print that can change at a whim and it us up to us to check their web site every day and read the multipage legal garbage to see if we are in compliance with a vaguely written and irrelevant document.
What I believe is going on here is something even worse than just plain lying -- which is what this is. I suspect Comcast has been peering (no pun intended) into what people are doing with all the bandwidth. It’s probably the online version of racial profiling that goes like this: We've snooped on a random sampling of X people and among those who exceed Y (y is of course an arbitrary and invisible number they won't reveal) bandwidth Z percent of them are either engaging in "file trading" or downloading porn. Therefore we can send out the threatening letters and they will be scared to say anything lest we reveal what they've been doing."" Or something likes that anyway.. There is a term for this kind of thinking plus the peering part is probably illegal. What would people do if they thought Comcast was watching what they download???
At this point its hard to overestimate what goes on in their minds. On the one hand they are STILL RUNNING THE ADDS SAYING "UNLIMITED" while sending out threatening letters to people becasue they have surpassed their limit. It is hard to beleive but people have come to expect this kind of thing and the mentality is so pro business these days its okay to treat your customers like criminal because well they are all criminals right? Look this guy has been downloading huge files with names like Suse and Woody. Got to be porn .. Right?? |
 |
|
|
utman
218 Posts |
Posted - 12/18/2003 : 11:31:32 AM
|
quote: I suspect Comcast has been peering (no pun intended) into what people are doing with all the bandwidth.
I doubt this is the case because if it was and they got caught they would lose their common carrier status. They would then be responsible for all illegal data that traversed their network. |
 |
|
|
Scott Lyon
271 Posts |
Posted - 12/18/2003 : 11:36:47 AM
|
quote: Originally posted by utman
quote: I suspect Comcast has been peering (no pun intended) into what people are doing with all the bandwidth.
I doubt this is the case because if it was and they got caught they would lose their common carrier status. They would then be responsible for all illegal data that traversed their network.
Wasn't Comcast the one who, a couple years ago, revealed they had tracked users' "surfing patterns" and sold the marketing data? I suspect that a company like Comcast isn't above "snooping", but you're absolutely right about the risks. The DMCA carved out a safe harbor for ISP's under the logic that "we can't check ALL that traffic". If it's revealed that they've developed systems to monitor traffic based on indicators they have identified, Congress may decide to reconsider their safe harbor status. |
 |
|
|
nathan
48 Posts |
Posted - 12/19/2003 : 12:45:11 AM
|
quote: Originally posted by jsbthree
I got one of those vague acceptable use letters that stated I had exceeded their invisible bandwidth limit.
First, wouldn't the statment that you have exceeded their bandwidth limit imply that they actually meter bandwidth? And hasn't metering been mentioned around here along with a demarcation point? I think somebody mentioned that metering each customer is probably not something Comcast has taken the hassle/time/money to put in place. (Though they may have trialed on a random few just for kicks.). I would imagine that, while they do not normally monitor individual customers, they probably do monitor their main lines, and if one if becoming taxed more than they anticipated, they may try to find out why. This would be my uneducated guess for what happened to you, and they thought sending you a nastygram would be better (cheaper) than fixing a customers demand needs.
Regardless, I would have to agree with you that, as a business user, you should get business grade service. I would be very loud and call every day (squeaky wheel gets the oil). Unfortunately, it shouldn't have to be like this. If you are in a business area, I would consider a T1 (or whatever is fairly cheap these days) and ask my neighbors if they would want to share. I've actually considered this for my residential service, but the upfront fees would eat me alive. |
 |
|
|
Dubber
416 Posts |
Posted - 12/19/2003 : 09:08:45 AM
|
quote: Originally posted by nathan
quote: Originally posted by jsbthree I got one of those vague acceptable use letters that stated I had exceeded their invisible bandwidth limit.
First, wouldn't the statment that you have exceeded their bandwidth limit imply that they actually meter bandwidth? And hasn't metering been mentioned around here along with a demarcation point?
True, metering and demarcation points have been discussed here, on the forum, as a possiblly viable business model. However, 'jsbthree' bought a package that was advertised as "unlimited' - so the letter he received either indicates false advertising or a mistake. Sure, mistakes are understandable and unfortunate. They are not excusable and this one, to me [ianal], seems actionable as false advertising.
I think the situation would not be so bad if there were viable competition in the marketplace, ergo to be able to switch providers. But that seems not to be the focus of governmental policy today. [The focus seems to be on protecting monopolies, to me]
-Aaron W. Dobbs :-)' |
 |
|
| |
Topic  |
|
|
|