| Author |
Topic  |
|
Rick
17 Posts |
|
|
Dubber
400 Posts |
|
|
jody
395 Posts |
Posted - 01/29/2004 : 10:30:23 PM
|
I just finished reading it. Hmmmmmmmmmmmm
Perhaps I am wrong, but I think Tom Tigue is the author and probably relished the thought of surprising both sides. Quick initial reaction:
1) The subject of protection, the actual theft construct is still WRONG. Mostly because of the broad and overly general nature of the definitions in use.
2) The style and efficacy of the bill, assuming its subject is valid, is greatly IMPROVED.
It appears that Tom was listening to both sides and agreed with our side on the inappropriate proscriptions for due process, punishments, and determinations of guilt in the original bill. I think he has acceded to the nebulous theft issue without understanding the subtle difference between existing laws and that requested by the MPAA and cable industry. Certainly, I think I have to acknowledge the true compromise he has produced to move this thing forward, however, compromise does not translate into just law in this case. We have to hammer on the scope of the theft issue and this current incarnation IS NOT ACCEPTABLE. |
Edited by - jody on 01/29/2004 10:37:29 PM |
 |
|
|
Scott Lyon
244 Posts |
Posted - 02/02/2004 : 11:52:27 AM
|
Here is a copy of my letter to Tom Tigue (legislative counsel):quote: Dear Tom,
I was surprised to hear that the draft bill you were preparing for Senators Trail and Person and Representative Briley was not forwarded to our group for commentary. The members of our group have done some research and noticed a new SB3101. Is this the same bill you were drafting?
The article in the Chattanoogan suggests not only that it is the same bill, but that a Communications Theft Study Committee meeting was held on Monday, January 26, 2004, where the bill was discussed and recommended for passage. It was my understanding that our group was not going to be excluded from the committee discussions, especially considering our involvement to date. Was there a reason we were not notified and invited? Is there another committee meeting scheduled? The bill website just mentions that the bill was filed for introduction and does not indicate any future meetings. There are several provisions of the bill (particularly relating to unintentional effects upon existing technology) that we believe need to be discussed.
If you have any questions, please feel free me at any time.
Sincerely, Scott Lyon President, Tennessee Digital Freedom Network
Needless to say, I am disappointed at the Committee's attempt to exclude us from the legislative process. Although I would like to believe that the scheduling of this meeting without public notice or notice to our group was accidental, I'm afraid I know better (I believe it's fair to say that the MPAA and cable lobbies were kept in the loop). |
 |
|
|
critch
68 Posts |
Posted - 02/02/2004 : 12:38:45 PM
|
Out of curiosity, has anyone thought of adding a rider essentially to this bill that would be sure to make the telecom companies turn on it. Specifically my recent concerns have been on the fact that the cable cos can change their AUP without notice to make certain activities against their AUP, and the potential for the violations of the AUP to be considered theft of service. Add to that the recent HDTV lineup change, and the fact that I lost 1 premium channel without a reduction in my bill. Carry that over to the telcos with the changes Cricket made maybe 6-10 months ago where the paper bill they provided was going to be an added charge even for those who had been with their service for a long time.
Basically, I think it would be a good thing if the bill could be drafted as a telecomunications theft and consumer protection bill. This would make it politically difficult for the members of the committe to stomp on too hard as it is about protecting their constituents from the abuses of monoplies. |
 |
|
|
Tony
396 Posts |
Posted - 02/02/2004 : 1:13:04 PM
|
Scott, this is indeed Tom Tigue's bill. Senator Trail made that clear in last Wednesday's Sidelines article:quote: "It was our consensus, because we were ... unable to pull the two sides any closer together, we asked Mr. [Tom] Tigue [legislative attorney] to draft a bill that might be equally unacceptable to both sides," Trail said. "He came up with a bill that sent a lot of people crying to my office, so he must have done a pretty good job."
Since Mr. Tigue has already stated that his duty is to his client, Senator Trail, he may very well have felt that his duty was done when he submitted the finished bill to the senator. It was then up to Senator Trail to decide on the best way to proceed, and he apparently decided that "the best way" did not require our immediate involvement.
Also, SJR579, which authorized the formation of the Joint Committee on Communications Security, stipulated that the Committee would report its findings to the GA by February 1, 2004, and at that time would be dissolved. So the Joint Committee will meet no more.
SB3101 was introduced and passed first consideration today, by the way. I assume that it will pass second consideration soon and then be passed back to the Judiciary Committee, but we'll need to monitor its status to be sure. |
 |
|
|
jody
395 Posts |
Posted - 02/02/2004 : 1:41:37 PM
|
Hey Jeremy?
Can you get Glenn Reynolds comments on this new bill? Maybe he hasn't had the time to review it yet. Maybe he hasn't heard about it yet. Could you be the one to let him know? |
 |
|
|
utman
209 Posts |
Posted - 02/02/2004 : 3:03:25 PM
|
I can give it a shot.
He's a very busy man, and it will probably be a week or more before he can get back to me.
|
 |
|
|
jody
395 Posts |
Posted - 02/02/2004 : 3:07:39 PM
|
| What ever time he can give us will be good. Thanks. |
 |
|
|
Scott Lyon
244 Posts |
Posted - 02/02/2004 : 3:11:48 PM
|
Here is Tom Tigue's reply to my e-mail:quote: Scott:
I did as I told everyone in my last e-mail I was going to do. I did a bill at the request of my clients. Because it was requested by members of the General Assembly, attorney-client confidentiality attached and I was not at liberty to release the draft. I gave it to the requesting members on Wednesday the 21st. It is my understanding that they released it that day although that is something over which I had no control. As was the meeting on the 26th for which sunshine notice was given. Scheduling of the meeting and notice of the meeting is something that is done out of the member's office and not mine. In this case, it was Senator Trail's office. The bill was discussed at the meeting on the 26th and it was recommended by the committee at that time. I was the only speaker at that meeting so you did not miss a chance to speak by not attending.
It is my understanding that there will not be another meeting of the Study Committee but that it will now go to the regular standing committees as any other bill.
I am sorry if you feel you and your group have been excluded from the process but you really have not. As I told everyone earlier, I could not release the bill and did not release it to anyone but my clients and no one else had input into it during the drafting (at the request of my clients). And there was not outside discussion of the bill at the last meeting of the Study Committee. I feel certain you will have ample time for comment during the regular legislative process.
If you have any further questions, feel free to contact me.
Tom
|
 |
|
|
jody
395 Posts |
Posted - 02/02/2004 : 3:38:46 PM
|
| Scott, from Tom's personal point of view I can see his point. The legislators on the committee, and not Tom, are the ones who should have been more forthcoming with us. I do disagree with him regarding not being left out. We were left out, along with many of the committee members themselves. We need to express our anger/disappointment towards Trail, Person, et. al. |
 |
|
|
joshuablevins
2 Posts |
|
|
Tony
396 Posts |
Posted - 02/04/2004 : 2:06:47 PM
|
| Yes, it's on our home page, too. |
 |
|
|
nathan
48 Posts |
Posted - 02/05/2004 : 1:07:10 PM
|
Ladies and Gentlemen, we have sponsors for HB3391.
Briley, Stanley & Coleman have stepped up to the plate. |
 |
|
|
jody
395 Posts |
Posted - 02/05/2004 : 1:14:47 PM
|
And the other shoe drops! 
If we do have any objections to this bill we had better get our b^##s in gear. Both sides of the legislature have a bill ready to go through standing committees and the next stop is the general assembly, then on to the governors desk. |
 |
|
|
kelargo
21 Posts |
Posted - 02/07/2004 : 10:48:03 AM
|
the previous post on AUPs is important.
the CC's base what is previeved as theft on the AUP and that can be changed at will.
One company use to advertise "unlimited internet access". That marketing term was removed from their advertisements and they started sending out notices for violation of the AUP. Saying something about excessive bandwidth usage. But these letters fail to identify what is the bandwidth usage, how much was in excess, how much is acceptable. The letter simply states that continued usage will result in termination. The user, not knowing the boundry then has service cut off. The whole process of identifying the usage is arbitrary.
That is still nebulous and not acceptable. |
 |
|
Topic  |
|
|
|