| Author |
Topic  |
|
|
Tony
401 Posts |
|
|
Dubber
442 Posts |
Posted - 04/29/2003 : 1:38:55 PM
|
hah, silly Dubber this should have gone here... -----Original Message----- From: Luke A. Kanies [loosifer] Sent: Tuesday, April 29, 2003 12:23 PM To: TNDF-L ayt LIST.APSU.EDU Subject: House bill delayed?
I just talked to Rep. Briley's assistant, and she said that the hearing on the bill is being put off for a week. He's the sponsor of the bill, so this should be good information, but apparently another senator recently provided information to the contrary.
We'll continue to provide information as we find out. You can check out the current status here: http://www.legislature.state.tn.us/bills/currentga/BillCompanionInfo.asp?BillNumber=HB457 Although that's not guaranteed to be on time or anything, and it apparently doesn't even show the amendment.
Luke -- "War is God's way of teaching Americans geography." --Ambrose Bierce
|
 |
|
|
SKozicki
243 Posts |
Posted - 04/30/2003 : 1:41:44 PM
|
| Rep Briley has rescheduled on me three times now. This after it took 3 days to get my first meeting scheduled with him. Currently scheduled for next Tuesday at 10am. |
 |
|
|
nathan
49 Posts |
Posted - 05/02/2003 : 12:38:46 PM
|
Do you know if this meeting is with you specifically, or if members from other groups will be in attendance? hobbsonline posted a letter, reportedly from Rep. Briley, which invites the recipient to a 10:00AM meeting on Tuesday. The letter also suggests that Briley is rather satisfied with the amended bill, but he is open to further suggestions:
The amendment also makes it abundantly clear that legislation would not make illegal legitimate computer designs or applications relating to networks and firewalls, nor the encrypting of data associated with those applications. I am continuing to work on the amendment to address any specific concerns. However, the vast majority of those who have contacted me have not seen and/or read the amendment to the bill. To help people understand what the legislation will look like as amended, I have scheduled a meeting in my office, 17 Legislative Plaza, on Tuesday, May, 6, at 10:00am. Please feel free to attend this meeting. I look forward to working with you to develop a piece of legislation that accomplishes my intent without compromising your legitimate activities.
|
 |
|
|
SKozicki
243 Posts |
Posted - 05/02/2003 : 3:00:45 PM
|
| It appears that 10am on Tuesday is an 'all you can eat' meeting. That is to say that anyone who has thoughts on the bill can attend. More info as it becomes available. |
 |
|
|
rknop
3 Posts |
Posted - 05/04/2003 : 09:41:44 AM
|
I got the message from Briley in E-mail; he started it by complaining about all the "misinformation" about the bill, and stating that he'd never heard from the MPAA. (Is he being duped by them pushing the law via intermediaries? Or is this law really standing on its own, and not part of the MPAA campaign across the country?)
This is the response I sent back to him. I don't know if he'll read it, but I hope he does notice that somebody's reading the law and amendment, and still doesn't like it.
----------------
Rep. Briley--
Thank you for your response.
I have in fact read the bill in question, and it chills me. I have also read what I believe to be the amendment, and it does not do enough to eliminate the broad text of the law which chills me. The number of things this law makes forbidden is staggering; the use to which it could be put to choke off any further development of telecommunications is also very alarming. The amendment includes text that makes it clear that lawbreaking must be going on, but the very first page of the bill-- even with amendments-- makes the sort of legitimate activity I was worried about with my initial letter against the law! It takes very little imagination to simply make anything within this law as is "defrauding" a communications provider, and as such the amendment does little to weaken the parts of the law that alarm me. Moreover, not only does it forbid using these technologies for being used illegally, but it forbids trafficking in them; many legitimate technologies which do have legitimate uses will be outlawed. Do we outlaw cars even though they can be used in hit and run accidents?
I am glad that you are listening to the telecommunications and computer industries for their concerns about the law. Ultimately, though, it is the needs and worries of the individual residents of this state that should be the top concern.
Even with the amendment, I am strongly opposed to this bill. Even with the amendments, as written the law will make me a criminal simply for connecting my wife's computer to my cable modem connection using the network address translation (NAT) abilities of the Linux kernel. By extension, this law would make the very act of distributing Linux illegal, since Linux contains these capabilities-- and since the license of Linux requires that anybody who receives it be able to modify it. I hope that you and the rest of the legislature will think very carefully before passing this extremely broad and restrictive bill.
I have no confidence in laws which are passed with assurances that they are not intended to be used against legitimate activities. If they can be used against legitimate activities that some would rather see regulated, they will be. The federal DMCA is a good example. When passed, it was stated that it would only be used to help stop the flood of copyright violations on the Internet. Instead, we've seen it used to squelch free speech and free trade (even going so far as to allow printer manufacturers to prevent competitors from selling cartridges for inkjet printers). We have to be extremely careful about passing very restrictive laws with broad language about what technology is to be made illegal. Even if our intentions are the best, those laws could come back and bite us.
A more and more restrictive society is not what I want to see, nor is it in the interests of our country or our state. One basic problem with this law is that it establishes that only those communication devices explicitly allowed are legal; this can only serve to choke off innovation. Rather than passing restrictions that will make it difficult for those committing no crimes, go after those committing the crimes. Before this law is passed, it needs to be abundantly clear that not only does it address anything that isn't already addressed by existing law (and I'm not clear that that is the case), and also that it simply can not be used to restrict legitimate activities (another point I currently do not believe is the case). It is one thing to pass a law making it illegal to steal telecommunications services; it is another thing altogether to pass a law severely restricting how legitimate customers can use those services, and outlawing technology which could potentially be used for service theft. Hb0417 currently appears to be more in the latter category.
No law is better than a bad law, as the federal DMCA has amply illustrated; in that case, any copyright violation it might have helped stopped was already illegal under other laws. All it enabled was the chilling of freedom of speech and anticompetitive activities. I am sure that was not the intention of most of the lawmakers who wrote and passed that law-- nor is it likely they believed it was a bad law when it was passed. We cannot be too careful.
Thank you for your consideration.
-Rob Knop [email protected] [email protected]
|
 |
|
|
RobertDupuy
9 Posts |
Posted - 05/05/2003 : 09:03:21 AM
|
I hope you all will be at the meeting, but I do not know that I can attend.
But I continue to refine my own personal message as I talk about the bill.
Here is the thing. He says that be believes $130 million is being stolen per year.
What will the figure be after his legislation? 0 dollars?? Wrong, of course not, using traditional methods of law enforcement, a drop in the crime rate of even 10% is a huge victory. Is his goal 10% reduction? From $130 million to $117 million?
Or just to hold steady?
Will he consider this to be a failure, if crime continues to increase?
You see it all comes down to this, if he is really worried about the costs to the consumer, and he is passing a law that will costs millions in terms of law enforcement, court trials, and housing people in prison, hoping that the crime rate will reduce by 10%...well it looks a bit silly, when you compare it to, for example, when the providers can spend a few million themselves on encryption technologies, as DirecTV did with their Period 4 initiative, not ask the taxpayer to do it, and they can have an effectiveness rate of 90%.
But they don't want effectiveness, cause the losses weren't real anyway, and they are tax write offs.
I think you all are very very very accurate in calling this a super-DMCA bill, even if it doesn't address copyright issues.
The fact is, both the DMCA and now this super-DMCA bill were similar, in that they both suggested they were updating laws to reflect the new digital age, but what they did, in fact, was graft ancient concepts about law enforcement on top of the digital arena...an arena which was doing remarkably well, and still managing to be humane and encourage free speech at the same time.
Now these morons come in.....ya...I think they are plain morons....I know, that's hardly being a good politician...I can't help it. |
Edited by - RobertDupuy on 05/05/2003 10:31:02 AM |
 |
|
|
SKozicki
243 Posts |
Posted - 05/05/2003 : 11:06:58 AM
|
| Even better, how about taking that $130M saved and applying it to the fees for services? Even if they took HALF of that money, and applied it as a customer credit, spread evenly across the customer base, I'd be ecstatic. |
 |
|
|
NickDanger
6 Posts |
Posted - 05/15/2003 : 12:18:39 PM
|
| If he thinks this bill will save 160m, he should look at the fiscal note which assumes 2 (!) incarcerations a year. If those two individuals were that rich, they'd get off and serve no time. |
 |
|
|
Scott Lyon
298 Posts |
Posted - 05/16/2003 : 09:57:23 AM
|
I think the Nashville Post article was the perfect opportunity for Representative Briley to put his foot in his own mouth. I present you Exhibit A:
quote: Using such broad language helps avoid the problem with previous statues, Rep. Rob Briley (D-Nashville) who is sponsoring the bill, told NashvillePost.com. By listing what is illegal, “the Telecom Theft Act of 1996 gives a roadmap to [potential culprits] to go around it. The proposed bill could make the consequences more severe for broadband theft,” he added.
So, in order to keep people from circumventing the law, we should make it so difficult to understand that they won't know what's illegal and what's not. Or maybe the theory is that if people just assume everything's illegal, they'll go to their service provider for clarification (because what they say is the law anyway).
Hmmmm.....I thought the idea was to draft criminal laws which are understandable, so people know what actions are violations and can do their best to avoid breaking the law. This doesn't mean that every law needs to be understandable to the public at large, but it does mean that they should be able to go to their lawyer and get some advice on what conduct would be illegal. That's not possible with the SDMCA because it is so ambiguous that it can be interpreted in many different ways.
I also don't understand how increasing the "consequences" prevents people from "circumventing" the law. I have yet to see any case law in which a cable thief has escaped on a "technicality." |
 |
|
|
jody
395 Posts |
Posted - 05/16/2003 : 10:09:06 AM
|
| Get 'em tiger! Time for you to write a letter to the editor. Maybe the Tennessean would actually be interested in it. Go, go, go. Heck, tell me what to write and I would gladly write the letter and send it in. No, even better, maybe we could get Glenn Reynolds to post your opinion along with his on the issue. Damn, time to send him the link to the article. |
 |
|
| |
Topic  |
|
|
|