Tennessee Digital Freedom Forum
Tennessee Digital Freedom Forum
Home | Profile | Register | Active Topics | Members | Search | FAQ
Username:
Password:
Save Password
Forgot your Password?

 All Forums
 Tennessee Technology Legislation
 Legislation
 Simple example of questionable legality.
 New Topic  Reply to Topic
 Printer Friendly
Author Previous Topic Topic Next Topic  

critch

72 Posts

Posted - 02/20/2004 :  2:46:22 PM  Show Profile  Visit critch's Homepage  Reply with Quote
While thinking through devices that would and should be considered illegal, I came across a few interesting thoughts on why these devices should still be legal.

In my home, I already subscribe to Comcast digital cable plus HBO. This coupled with my cable modem means I pay the substantial amount of ~$120 a month to Comcast for service. In this bill from Comcast, I also have to pay for 2 digital cable receivers at a cost of $4.95 a month.

I do not know what ruling it was that said that cable companies couldn't charge a per TV connection charge, but these receivers essentially reinstated it through a loophole.

Anyways, I pay for probably 80% or so of all available content on the cable line coming into my home. Shouldn't a device capable of descrambling the channels for me, if used for channels I pay for be legal. After all I pay for a service. The only thing I wouldn't be paying for is another cable receiver.

BTW, lets leave the DMCA out of this as I know the descrambler would technically fall as for foul of it as the DeCSS library does.

Now lets come to current litigation. In the recent Grokster case, it was ruled that with the amount of data flowing over it's system that the 5 or 10 percent non-infringing file transfers amounted to significant non-infringing use and therefore the service wasn't illegal.

So moving back to the hypothetical descrambler in my home. If I am paying for 80% of the content coming into my house, and taking Brian Allens quote about not knowing for sure what you watch in your home without having sat there with you, is there anyway for them to say the device was used in a manner that had anything more than slight infringing use?

If so, I think cable descamblers in the home of a person paying for x% of the content available would then be legal to own, but not necessarily to ue to it's full capacity.

Anyways. Just some thoughts on how we could push this bill back some more.

utman

219 Posts

Posted - 02/20/2004 :  5:44:23 PM  Show Profile  Visit utman's Homepage  Send utman an AOL message  Reply with Quote
I think the key difference between the two situations is in the Grokster case, the question revolved around Grokster itself being the "communications device". The trial was about whether it is legal or not to use a device that may have substantial noninfringing uses.

The bill that we are dealing with is much more geared toward communications services. Really the only reason for mentioning a "communications device" is to provide the court with some way of determining the extent of the illegal use (i.e. number of devices).

So in what we're dealing with, the question isn't about the legality or illegality of the device. The question is about the legality or illegality of using the service for a purpose that is contrary to what the service provider wishes.
Go to Top of Page

kelargo

21 Posts

Posted - 02/24/2004 :  02:21:48 AM  Show Profile  Reply with Quote
keep in mind...

the Broadcasters of television are required to convert to DTV standard.

The cable companies have "digital" cable, but this is NOT the same as
DTV.

One can buy a Digital Tuner and pick of DTV signals now...
One can even buy HD DTV tuners. They are still not compatible with Cable Digital TV. You have to rent a Digital tuner from the cable provider and your DTV tuner is not worth anything in picking up
the signal off cable.

If you want cable HDTV, you have to rent the cable companies box even through the signals are available for free off the air from Broadcasters.

The tuners should be compatible between the two mediums.

Go to Top of Page
  Previous Topic Topic Next Topic  
 New Topic  Reply to Topic
 Printer Friendly
Jump To:
Tennessee Digital Freedom Forum © 2003 TNDF.net Go To Top Of Page
Snitz Forums 2000