Tennessee Digital Freedom Forum
Tennessee Digital Freedom Forum
Home | Profile | Register | Active Topics | Members | Search | FAQ
Username:
Password:
Save Password
Forgot your Password?

 All Forums
 Tennessee Technology Legislation
 Media
 National Bill Gaining Steam
 New Topic  Reply to Topic
 Printer Friendly
Next Page
Author  Topic Next Topic
Page: of 2

SKozicki

243 Posts

Posted - 06/22/2004 :  09:39:39 AM  Show Profile  Send SKozicki an AOL message  Reply with Quote
Time to join the fray?

utman

244 Posts

Posted - 06/22/2004 :  10:29:59 AM  Show Profile  Visit utman's Homepage  Send utman an AOL message  Reply with Quote
You can try, but i'm in a position here in Washington to know what is going on inside the committee.

I have "heard" that this bill is going nowhere, and not because of its merits.

Besides, I just heard from Ren at EFF and they want us to jump on electronic voting.
Go to Top of Page

Rick

24 Posts

Posted - 06/24/2004 :  12:29:32 PM  Show Profile  Visit Rick's Homepage  Reply with Quote
quote:
Originally posted by SKozicki

Time to join the fray?



There is indeed a lot of activity on this bill (despite claims to the contrary). I note that Fred von Lohmann is following it actively. I exchanged emails with Bob Schwartz (after contacting Sen. Frist's office) and he suggests pooling resources to express our concern over it. He's been in contact with a lobbyist for Vanderbilt (David Mills) and can put us in contact with him if we express an interest.

Rick
Go to Top of Page

critch

83 Posts

Posted - 06/24/2004 :  1:19:55 PM  Show Profile  Visit critch's Homepage  Reply with Quote
Don't forget that there is also the INDUCE act that we need to discuss with Frist. Frist is listed as a cosponsor. I think I need to go to his office as soon as my laptop is repaired and show them how easy it is to induce copyright infringement.

http://www.interesting-people.org/archives/interesting-people/200406/msg00152.html
Go to Top of Page

Rick

24 Posts

Posted - 06/24/2004 :  2:15:59 PM  Show Profile  Visit Rick's Homepage  Reply with Quote
quote:
Originally posted by critch

Don't forget that there is also the INDUCE act that we need to discuss with Frist. Frist is listed as a cosponsor. I think I need to go to his office as soon as my laptop is repaired and show them how easy it is to induce copyright infringement.

http://www.interesting-people.org/archives/interesting-people/200406/msg00152.html



Call me an idiot. I thought the link Scott mentioned was to the INDUCE act -- which is what I was talking about.

My letter to Bill Frist about INDUCE (actually called "IICA" since I guess they've taken the "save the children" bull**** out of the name) is online here:

http://www.rickbradley.com/chron/20040624/

The FvL and Bob Schwartz mentions I made were to INDUCE/IICA, and so was the offer for hookup with the Vandy lobbyist.

Rick
Go to Top of Page

critch

83 Posts

Posted - 06/24/2004 :  2:20:59 PM  Show Profile  Visit critch's Homepage  Reply with Quote
The piece Scott linked was an antiDMCA bill.
Go to Top of Page

utman

244 Posts

Posted - 06/25/2004 :  10:59:35 AM  Show Profile  Visit utman's Homepage  Send utman an AOL message  Reply with Quote
Hey guys.

I've been working with the IEEE Intellectual Property committee for about a month now. The INDUCE act has been explained to me by some very well-known authorities in the field, and I don't think it's a huge problem.

Basically, it is just codifying what has always existed in patent law. The bill is intended to provide an avenue to pursue entities which build and expressly advertise their software/hardware for infringement. Therefore, any software/hardware is safe as long as they don't make infringement an integral part of their business plan.

That said, I think that everyone is missing the PIRATE act. This is the one that allocates 2million in taxpayer dollars to have the DOJ file civil suits on behalf of the music companies and all collected damages would go to the music companies (not the taxpayers). This bill has already flown through the Senate without a hearing and is expected to do the same in the house.

Further, let me emphasize that everything I have heard is that the DMCRA is going nowhere this year due to some interpersonal issues between committee members.

Is anyone interested in electronic voting?
Go to Top of Page

Rick

24 Posts

Posted - 06/25/2004 :  1:21:33 PM  Show Profile  Visit Rick's Homepage  Reply with Quote
quote:
Originally posted by utman

Hey guys.

I've been working with the IEEE Intellectual Property committee for about a month now. The INDUCE act has been explained to me by some very well-known authorities in the field, and I don't think it's a huge problem.

Basically, it is just codifying what has always existed in patent law. The bill is intended to provide an avenue to pursue entities which build and expressly advertise their software/hardware for infringement. Therefore, any software/hardware is safe as long as they don't make infringement an integral part of their business plan.



On the other hand, I've been reading the analyses by other well-known names in
the field and they are very concerned about this bill. The analogies between
patent inducement and copyright inducement raise serious questions for a number
of reasons (not least of which are that inducements to violate patents are
concerned with methods, while inducement to infringe copyright is concerned
with content, and in particular speech). There are other fundamental
questions, many of which are frankly over my head because IANAL.

It's interesting that you mentioned the IEEE IPC since Mike Godwin sent a complaint to the IEEE-USA committee, which in part stated:

"What troubles me just now, though, is something different. It is whether
this listserv, and the IEEE generally, have been used to (effectively)
endorse such controversial legislation *prior to that legislation's being
circulated or introduced* and *without informing participants in the
discussion that they were, in effect, being asked to endorse a particular
bill*.

This strikes me as an exceedingly questionable way of proceeding when it
comes to developing IEEE policy and when it comes to involving IEEE in
ongoing legislation."

In other words, if the IEEE-IPC is your primary source of information you're
probably getting spoon-fed.

There is a significant problem here, and there is a lot of activity on this
bill which should not be on fast-track. The reason that I'm approaching TNDF
here is that Bill Frist is a sponsor and we can have a direct impact on getting
it knocked off fast-track. That and people in another forum (including EFF
lawyers, outside lobbyists, and various industry attorneys) were very excited
about the letter I sent. They know who Scott Lyons is and asked directly if I
could get TNDF interested. Bill Frist is a sponsor and TNDF can potentially
put pressure on him to push for this bill to be off fast-track. If it falls
off fast-track I (probably ignorantly) doubt that it will be a threat this
session.


I have posted a letter to my website which Bob Schwartz and Markham Erickson
are circulating urging organizations and companies to add their signatures to.
Lobbyists will be delivering this to Hatch / Leahy. If TNDF would like to add
their name to this letter we should send an email to Markham Erickson at:
[email protected]. This isn't some bull**** petition -- they will be
presenting this to the lawmakers. They will close the signature list at the
end of business (presumably EST) on Tuesday. If TNDF signs I'll push for them
to add Frist as a Cc: as well.

A copy of the letter (.doc only, sorry I didn't write it) is at:

http://www.rickbradley.com/misc/InduceHearingLetter.DOC

quote:

That said, I think that everyone is missing the PIRATE act. This is the one that allocates 2million in taxpayer dollars to have the DOJ file civil suits on behalf of the music companies and all collected damages would go to the music companies (not the taxpayers). This bill has already flown through the Senate without a hearing and is expected to do the same in the house.

Further, let me emphasize that everything I have heard is that the DMCRA is going nowhere this year due to some interpersonal issues between committee members.

Is anyone interested in electronic voting?



I agree that the PIRATE act needs more attention. Any concrete suggestions on
what to do about it? As for electronic voting.... well, the same question.

--Rick
Go to Top of Page

utman

244 Posts

Posted - 06/25/2004 :  3:29:31 PM  Show Profile  Visit utman's Homepage  Send utman an AOL message  Reply with Quote
Ok, I was wrong on the INDUCE act. I have been finding some of the knee-jerk reactions by many out there to be unconvincing. However, I did come across this post on Lessig's blog by Andrew Greenberg:

The significance of this complaint is not that Apple would likely lose under the new standard, but rather that the complaint can be filed. Moreover, contemplate how one would Answer and raise counterclaims and, most importantly, how one would hope to proceed on summary judgment.

My initial, though not fully considered concern, is that Apple would NOT prevail on SJ. Accordingly, the case goes to trial with a downside liability that might be measured at $750 times the number of recorded musical works in circulation, of which there may be millions (does anybody know a better approximation?)

While Apple should prevail, for it did not induce infringement by its distribution of the iPod, a reasonable person is not the same as a juror, and the finding of fact as to scienter would be unassailable on appeal.

Who would roll those dice? who would invest in a company rolling those dice? Imagine life without innovation in consumer electronics resulting, not from a serious fear of actual liability, but rather from the ad terrorem effect of receiving the complaint.

The significance is NOT how that complaint would be litigated, but how a corporation receiving a demand letter with an accompanying draft complaint like that would respond. If innovation is stifled by this new form of technology regulation, we will all lose.

The problem with INDUCE is that it extends copyrights to grant patent-like protection against innovative technologies to non-technologists for an indefinite period of time.

A cause for copyright inducement is not a bad idea. A carefully circumscribed for of inducement liability could comfortably replace the now-dangerous “control” standard that cases such as Napster and Aimster have grafted onto Sony. Patent inducement is well-understood and responsibly balances important policy concerns.

That being the case, why would we ever run off on this new adventure, rather than simply adopting a patent-like standard of active inducement, and evolving from there if need be? The answer is apparent: INDUCE is not sound policy, but rather a dangerous piece of special interest legislation to appease those concerned about technological circumvention by P2P suppliers of the RIAA’s ill-gotten legal fruits of Napster. Napster and aimster may well have lost under an appropriate inducement standard, but at least more fundamental sharing technologies would be saved!

the point is that contribution should almost never occur with the manufacture of general-purpose duplication or distributino machines, capable of substantial non-infringing use, unless the vendor actively induces people to use that technology for illicit purposes. In such a case, they would be punished, NOT for the technology, but for their independent conduct inducing the infringement. The mere distribution of the technology, without more, would be unassailable and prevail upon summary judgment as to contribution. The mere marketing of the technology, without more, would be unassailable and prevail upon summary judgment as to inducement. As it should be.

If network effects are created by direct or plainly implied reference to the fruits of infringing conduct, inducement is a sound inquiry. The Federal circuit and district courts been breathtakingly good at distinguishing the “nod-and-a-wink” cases from genuine cases of non-inducement. That standard works. Why not use it?
Go to Top of Page

utman

244 Posts

Posted - 06/25/2004 :  3:36:04 PM  Show Profile  Visit utman's Homepage  Send utman an AOL message  Reply with Quote
Does this mean that we're getting reorganized? :)

I was surprised as hell to see scott kozicki posting here.

Also, I think we should definitely get our name on the letter. I'll see if I can contact Scott Lyon about it on Monday.
Go to Top of Page

Rick

24 Posts

Posted - 06/25/2004 :  4:11:26 PM  Show Profile  Visit Rick's Homepage  Reply with Quote
quote:
Originally posted by utman

Does this mean that we're getting reorganized? :)

I was surprised as hell to see scott kozicki posting here.

Also, I think we should definitely get our name on the letter. I'll see if I can contact Scott Lyon about it on Monday.



Good deal.

FWIW, both ART and PIRATE passed the Senate today. ;-(
Go to Top of Page

Dubber

441 Posts

Posted - 06/27/2004 :  5:26:24 PM  Show Profile  Visit Dubber's Homepage  Send Dubber a Yahoo! Message  Reply with Quote
quote:
Originally posted by Rick
FWIW, both ART and PIRATE passed the Senate today. ;-(

Sorry to be so late on the reply, I'm pretty sure the PIRATRE Act only passed out of the Legislative SubCommittee, though. I told the legislative counsel for ALA's OITP, based in the Washington Office, that I'd heard PIRATE passed the senate & she about jumped out of her skin, thinking I'd meant the full chamber.

Here's what ALA and other library related associations have on their burners this year:
----

ALA supports efforts to amend the Digital Millennium Copyright Act DMCA) and to urge the courts to restore the balance in copyright law, ensure fair use and protect and extend the public domain.

“Digital Media Consumers’ Rights Act of 2003” (DMCRA)
(H.R. 107)
Sponsors: Reps. Boucher (D-VA), Doolittle (R-CA)
Introduction: January 7, 2003
· Proposes 3 key changes to sections of the flawed Digital Millennium Copyright Act (DMCA)
· The bill reaffirms fair use in the digital environment and is an important first step in recognizing the rights of copyright users
· Hearing held May 12 by House Energy & Commerce Subcommittee

“Consumers, Schools and Libraries Digital Rights Management Awareness Act of 2003”
(S. 1621)
Sponsor: Sen. Sam Brownback (R-KS)
Introduction: September 16, 2003
· Creates voluntary notice and labeling standards for digital media products using digital rights management (DRM) technology
· Prevents manufacturers from using DRM technologies to restrict consumer resale of digital media products they lawfully own or elect to donate to educational institutions and libraries

“Public Domain Enhancement Act”
(H.R. 2601)
Sponsor: Reps. Lofgren (D-CA), Doolittle (R-CA)
Introduction: June 25, 2003
· Provides a simple mechanism to ensure that abandoned copyrighted works pass into the public domain

“Public Access to Science Act”
(H.R. 2613)
Sponsor: Rep. Martin Sabo (D-MN)
Introduction: June 26, 2003
· Works resulting from substantially federally funded “scientific research” would be excluded from copyright protection

“Benefit Authors without Limiting Advancement or Net Consumer Expectations Act of 2003,” (“BALANCE Act”)
(H.R. 1066)
Sponsor: Representative Zoe Lofgren (D-CA)
Introduction: March 4, 2003
· Bill proposes to protect fair use, allow first sale rights of digital content and provides for permissible circumvention to enable
fair use and consumer expectations

“Digital Consumer Right to Know Act,”
(S. 692)
Sponsor: Senator Ron Wyden (D-OR)
Introduction: March 24, 2003
· Requires producers of information and entertainment content to inform consumers about technological features that would restrict their use of the content
· Requires Federal Trade Commission to issue rules for disclosing technological measures that restrict consumer use


Threats to fair use continue unabated. As Congress becomes increasingly sympathetic to content providers’ complaints about the economic impact of Internet piracy, we expect continued efforts to pursue database protection and digital rights management legislation that would enable copyright holders to restrict access to and use of their content.

“Database and Collections of Information Misappropriation Act of 2003”
(H.R. 3261)
Sponsor: Rep. Coble (R-NC)
Introduction: October 8, 2003

“Consumer Access to Information Act of 2004”
(H.R. 3872)
Sponsor: Rep. Stearns (R-FL)
Introduction: March 2, 2004
· H.R. 3261 provides overly broad and unnecessary protection for commercial database producers
· Inadequate exception for educational, scientific, research institutions
· Approved by House Judiciary Committee in Jan. 2004
· House Energy and Commerce Committee unfavorably reported out H.R. 3261 in March 2004, then favorably reported H.R. 3872, a narrowly focused approach to misappropriation of databases
· Libraries support H.R. 3872 as a reasonable alternative bill

“Piracy Deterrence and Education Act of 2004”
(H.R. 4077)
Sponsor: Rep. Smith (R-TX)
Introduction: March 31, 2004
· Enhances criminal enforcement of copyright laws, requires Justice Dept. to educate the public about copyright infringement
· Makes it an offense to record, transmit or make copies of a motion picture in a theater with a audiovisual recording device (federal version of state “camcorder” legislation)
· Amends Copyight Act to allow criminal prosecution of someone who "makes available" one work worth $10,000 or more, or 1,000 or more works of undetermined value
· Markup hearing held March 31, 2004

“Artists’ Rights and Theft Prevention Act of 2003”
(S. 1932) Sponsors: Sen. Cornyn (R-TX), Feinstein (D-CA), Hatch (R-UT), Smith (R-OR), Alexander (R-TN), Graham (R-SC)
Introduction: November 22, 2003
(N.B. H.R. 4077)
· Makes it an offense to record, transmit or make copies of a motion
picture in a theater with a audiovisual recording device (federal version of state “camcorder” legislation)

“Protecting Intellectual Rights Against Theft and Expropriation Act of 2004” (“PIRATE Act”)
(S. 2237)
Sponsors: Sen. Leahy (D-VT), Hatch (R-UT)
Introduction: March 25, 2004
· Amends Copyright Law to allow government to seek civil penalties, as well as criminal penalties, for willful copyright infringement
· Directs Justice Dept. to develop civil enforcement program
Other Federal Copyright Protection Legislation


Proponents of legislation to permit copyright owners to control access to and use of their products are aggressively pushing for help from Congress. In 2004 proposed legislation emphasizes deterrence of piracy and enforcement with stiff penalties. The Department of Justice announced the formation of an Intellectual Property Task Force in April 2004.
Note: Copy protection systems are also referred to as digital rights management (DRM). The need for government mandated DRM standards is controversial.

“Anticounterfeiting Amendments of 2004”
(H.R. 3632)
Sponsor: Rep. Smith (R-TX)
Introduction: March 31, 2004
“Anticounterfeiting Act of 2004” (S. 2242) Sponsors: Sen. Biden (D-DE) and Nelson (D-NE) Introduction: March 26, 2004
· Prohibits trafficking in illicit authentication features, counterfeit documentation and packaging that is attached to computer program, motion picture, or audiovisual work.
· Current language in both bills could inadvertently apply to legitimate electronic distribution of copyrighted works
· Markup on House bill held March 31, 2004


State Copyright-related Legislation Content owners are also promoting their copyright protection agenda at the state level with several obscure enforcement bills with overly broad language that could
apply to libraries and educational institutions.

“Uniform Computer Information Transactions Act” (“UCITA”) is a proposed state contract law that validates enforceability of “shrink-wrap” contracts. Despite lack of promotion by drafters, UCITA continues to have potential for introduction.
· Anti - UCITA “bomb-shelter” legislation is active in MA and LA
· Troublesome UCITA-friendly amendments to Articles 1 and 2 of Uniform Commercial Code expected in 2004 “Super DMCA” bills propose to update existing state laws prohibiting theft of cable and satellite service by implementing provisions similar to DMCA anti-circumvention prohibition, but without the narrow exceptions and limitations that permit libraries to conduct legitimate activities.
· 2004 activity: CO, MD, MI, SC, TN
· Bills have already passed in AK, CO, FL, PA, MD, DE, IL and MI

“Camcorder” Legislation is another effort to stop digital piracy by prohibiting the recording of movies in a facility in which a motion picture is being shown. The term facility is often not defined and could apply to libraries.
2004 activity: AZ, CO, FL, GA, KS, MD, MA, MI, MN

Court case: MGM, Inc. v. Grokster, Ltd.
Case on appeal in U.S. Court of Appeals (9th Circuit) involves companies that produce software for peer-to-peer file sharing. Libraries joined amici curiae (“friends of the court”) brief on behalf of Grokster (September 26, 2003).
· The record companies and movie studios sued Grokster et al. (P2P companies) for contributory copyright infringement and vicarious liability.
· The plaintiffs in this important case are challenging the validity of the landmark Sony v. Betamax case, in which U.S. Supreme Court held that that the makers of the VCR should not be held liable for copyright infringement simply because the device could be used for infringing purposes.
· Oral arguments were held Feb 3, 2004.

Court cases: RIAA v. Pacific Bell Internet Services
(U.S. Court of Appeals, 9th Circuit)
RIAA v. Verizon Internet Services
(U.S. Court of Appeals, D.C. Circuit)
RIAA v. Charter Communications
(U.S. Court of Appeals, 8th Circuit)
· ALA joined amicus briefs filed on behalf of the Internet service providers resisting efforts by RIAA to obtain identities of users alleged to infringe copyright. These cases challenge the propriety of the recording industry serving subpoenas on ISPs without judicial oversight.
· U.S. Court of Appeals for D.C. Circuit ruled Dec. 19, 2003, in favor of Verizon; RIAA petitioned U.S. Supreme Court to hear appeal May 24, 2004
· Other cases are still pending in the appeals courts.

FCC “Broadcast Flag” Rulemaking
Nov. 2003: Federal Communications Commission mandated the use of copy
protection mechanisms for DTVs (digital televisions), personal computers
· In Jan. 2004 libraries and other public interest organizations petitioned U.S. Court of Appeals for the D.C. Circuit to set aside the FCC’s rulemaking.
· Petition charges the FCC acted in excess of its authority and contrary to the factual evidence in the record.

International Copyright Issues
International agreements and trade treaties may adversely impact libraries and U.S. copyright law
· ALA is a member of the U.S. Delegation to the Hague Convention on Exclusive Choice of Court Agreements
· Free Trade Area of the Americas Agreement (FTAA) and bi-lateral free trade agreements (FTAs)
· Continuing implementation of the World Trade Organization's (WTO) General Agreement on Trade in Services (GATS)

See updated text of above listings

And that's what I know at the moment at the federal level.
-Aaron W. Dobbs
:-)'
Go to Top of Page

utman

244 Posts

Posted - 06/28/2004 :  11:07:28 AM  Show Profile  Visit utman's Homepage  Send utman an AOL message  Reply with Quote
I talked to Scott, and we think that it is too late to try to get a vote together, so if you would like your name on the letter then post here.

I suppose we can sign our names and make it clear that we are associated with TNDF.

We would need more time for something greater though.

Rick, Scott is going to look over stuff later on this evening and then shoot you an email.

Go to Top of Page

Rick

24 Posts

Posted - 06/28/2004 :  5:37:53 PM  Show Profile  Visit Rick's Homepage  Reply with Quote
quote:
Originally posted by utman
Rick, Scott is going to look over stuff later on this evening and then shoot you an email.



Sounds good.
Go to Top of Page

Scott Lyon

298 Posts

Posted - 06/29/2004 :  07:42:27 AM  Show Profile  Reply with Quote
I took a look at the suggested change and I can understand why IP lawyers would have a problem with this bill. It pretends to be a modest change to fill a perceived "chink in the armor", but it actually manages to be both redundant and open-ended at the same time. It's redundant because most imaginable circumstances where this could be applied are already developed under caselaw on "contributory infringement." At the same time, it's intended to be a separate standard under the law, which means that courts will have to figure out how to read this into the overall copyright infringement structure. We face the very real problem that different federal courts will have different interpretations of when a device "induces" infringement, which pose interstate commerce problems and threaten innovation.

I'd be happy to help, but right now I'm overwhelmed with work and studying for the Florida bar exam. I'll chime in every now and again, but I'm afraid my role in this fight will be limited (though I'm more than willing to add my name to a letter or petition in opposition).
Go to Top of Page

utman

244 Posts

Posted - 06/29/2004 :  12:54:40 PM  Show Profile  Visit utman's Homepage  Send utman an AOL message  Reply with Quote
Btw, you can sign my name to the letter

Jeremy Tunnell
Tennessee Digital Freedom
1700 Clinch Ave Apt 512
Knoxville, TN 37916
Go to Top of Page
Page: of 2  Topic Next Topic  
Next Page
 New Topic  Reply to Topic
 Printer Friendly
Jump To:
Tennessee Digital Freedom Forum © 2003 TNDF.net Go To Top Of Page
Snitz Forums 2000