New cable theft bill submitted
by Alexei Smirnov, The Nashville Post

Friday, 1/30/2004 4:10 pm (Updated 5:15 p.m.) — The debate over cable theft legislation in Tennessee has received a boost Thursday with the filing of a new bill in the state Senate aiming to increase penalties for unauthorized use of broadband services.

Filed by Sen. Larry Trail (D-Murfreesboro), the bill suggests harsher laws for broadband offenses, namely punishing cable offense as theft.

Senate Bill 3101 follows last year’s controversial Bill 213, which was sponsored by the Motion Picture Association of America. SB213 died at the end of the legislative session, in part due to opposition of the bill by a group of local technology enthusiasts, the Tennessee Digital Freedom Network.

The early review of the newly proposed legislation by TDFN members (/digitalforum/default.asp) shows the new bill doesn’t differ much from last year’s.

TDFN members said last year the bill defined “cable theft” too broadly, essentially allowing cable companies to pick and choose which customers could plug which technology and communications devices into the broadband service.

The bill will have to pass through the House three times before its gets to the Senate Judiciary Committee, which is chaired by Sen. Person, Trail told NashvillePost.com Friday afternoon. It will be at least a couple of weeks until the bill reaches the Judiciary Committee.

Trail chaired the study committee that reviewed last year’s bill and came up with the new language in SB3101. “This bill is much tighter,” said Trail. “It gives the industry some teeth to fight [cable theft], but not to the extent they wanted initially.” While last year’s bill went by the theory of “why use one word if you can use 23,” Trail said the new document has a better chance of becoming law within the next few months because, in his view, it has addressed many of the concerns of its opponents.

Rep. Rob Briley (D-Nashville) will remain the bill’s sponsor in the House, Trail said.

Trail is assisted by Sen. Curtis Person (R-Memphis), who sponsored it last year.

During the 2003 deliberations, Person disclosed that he could have personal interest in passing the bill due to his family ties. Person’s son, Curtis Person III, at the time was regional director of Charter Communications in Jackson, Tenn. and served on the board of Tennessee Cable Telecommunications Association, which was backing the bill here.