Tennessee Digital Freedom feels that it must refute the following Nashville Post story on several points:
  • TNDF has never claimed "deception by lawmakers" on this issue. We contested the accuracy of Tom Tigue's 2/2 email given the official hearing record and attendees' statements, but Mr. Tigue is a state employee, not a lawmaker.
  • TNDF never claimed to be instrumental in stalling last year's bill, or partial responsibility for creating the Study Committee. Senator Person introduced SJR579 in order to develop a bill that corrected the problems identified in SB213 by several groups, including TNDF.
  • TNDF did not claim that we were deliberately excluded from the 1/26 hearing. The actual quote on our site was that "It appears that the opponents of SDMCA legislation, including TNDF and other organizations, may have been intentionally excluded from the process early on, with the intention of slipping this bill through the General Assembly with as little citizen involvement as possible." A subtle distinction, perhaps, but an important one.
  • The recording publicized in Bill Hobbs' 2/17 story did not "convince" TNDF that legislators were attempting to exclude us from hearings. We were already aware that cable lobbyists spoke at the last SJR579 hearing, and that there appeared to be no generally available public notice of the hearing. This led to the statement quoted above, not to a statement of conviction. The recording proved only that Mr. Tigue was aware of the other speakers, and had not left the hearing before their statements were made.
  • The quote attributed to Tony Campbell was constructed from various statements, and should not be in quotation marks. Campbell told the reporter that in his opinion, the questions raised by Bill Hobbs' story cast a "tincture of impropriety" over the handling of SB3101, and that until the questions that it raised were answered, it was in his opinion "a dirty bill."
  • Senator Person did not say that he had "personal interest in passing the bill." He invoked Rule 13, indicating that his son's position with Charter Cable could be construed as a potential conflict of interest, but reiterated that he acted only to serve the public interest in the introduction and sponsorship of SB213.
  • Tennessee Digital Freedom is known as TNDF, not TDFN. As far as we know, Alex Smirnov is the only journalist who refers to us as TDFN.
Other than on these points, we believe the following story to be largely accurate.

Local tech group claims legislators acted secretly on cable theft bill
by Alexei Smirnov

Tuesday, 2/17/2004 5:08 pm
— A group opposing cable theft legislation currently pending in the Senate Judiciary Committee claims deception by lawmakers.

Members of the Tennessee Digital Freedom Network, which was instrumental in stalling the controversial bill last year, were partially responsible for the creation of the Communications Theft Study Committee last summer. Now the group claims it has been deliberately excluded from the committee hearing on January 26.

Bill SB 3101, which is sponsored this year by Sen. Larry Trail (D-Murfreesboro) and was initially backed by the Tennessee Cable Telecommunications Association, aims to curb theft of cable services, but opponents said it would allow companies to pick and choose which customers could plug which technology and communications devices into the broadband service.

Scott Lyon, TDFN president, found out about the meeting and e-mailed Thomas Tigue, deputy legislative attorney for the General Assembly who was in charge of the recent reversions of the bill, to ask whether there was a reason why his group was not invited to the hearing. In an e-mail response, Tigue assured Lyon that he was the only presenter at the Jan. 26 hearing and that TDFN didn’t miss an opportunity to present its concerns.

However, Lyon said TDFN members later obtained a public audio record of the committee hearing, from which they learned that several speakers appeared before the study committee prior to and after Tigue’s appearance, seemingly making it clear that Tigue was aware of other speakers.

That discovery convinced TDFN members that members of the legislature are attempting to exclude the group from hearings on the cable theft bill.

“It’s a dirty bill at this point and it has questionable activity that needs to be addressed,” Tony Campbell, a Nashville programmer who is active with TDFN told NashvillePost.com Tuesday.

NashvillePost.com contacted the offices of Trail and Sen. Curtis Person (R-Memphis), who is also involved with the bill, seeking comment on the matter. They have not returned calls prior to this article’s publication.

The Senate Judiciary Committee was scheduled to conduct a hearing on SB 3101 this afternoon at the Legislative Plaza.

During the 2003 deliberations, Person disclosed that he could have personal interest in passing the bill due to his family ties. Person’s son, Curtis Person III, at the time was regional director of Charter Communications in Jackson, Tenn. and served on the board of Tennessee Cable Telecommunications Association.