| T O P I C R E V I E W |
| Tony |
Posted - 06/04/2003 : 1:09:28 PM Folks, here is a forums issue that needs to be resolved. Most of you have probably noticed spelling corrections, tidied links, and formatting fixes occurring in your posts soon after they were posted. In a lot of cases, that's me--and the "Post Elves." I've done this for the sake of readability, and to present the best face possible to those who visit here and who potentially cut-and-paste into their emails, blogs and newsletters. The most extreme being when I recently deleted two duplicate topics, as well as the apology of the dupe poster to preserve consistency. On some occasions it involves correcting a glaring mistake in a post as well as a comment in a reply which points it out, in order to preserve consistency and avoid confusion. Such a correction happened here, and evoked an exchange which encouraged me to post this topic.
I am comfortable with doing this so long as nothing that I do changes the poster's message. If nobody has an objection to this, then the Post Elves will continue to do their little jobs. If someone does object, and would rather I do my job differently, I'd like to hear that as well.
Thanks for your input! |
| 7 L A T E S T R E P L I E S (Newest First) |
| jody |
Posted - 06/04/2003 : 5:18:06 PM Wow, I just looked back at that whole thread for the first time. I'm glad I glossed over it. I try very hard not to take the bait MrM... and some others like him dish out on forums like this. The best way to deal with them is just let them have their say and don't respond. I feel like I'm treading on hypocritical ice by saying that, as I often like to stir the pot a bit, but at some point discussion is either meaningful and going somewhere, or it isn't. I believe I mentioned this offline to someone that forums attract problem personalities who only care about consuming everyones time to get attention. They don't have to be part of a conspiracy, though they could be. My approach to the problem is to simply not feed them the energy they seek.
The internet sure has made for some wierd human dynamics...this might be a textbook example. |
| Tony |
Posted - 06/04/2003 : 3:03:52 PM quote: Originally posted by Dubber imo, the most extreme being when an entire post was deleted and later restored here.
The "Post Elves" weren't involved in that one, Dubber--they are so named because they often work behind the scenes, changing "thier" to "their" and "teh" to "the," without calling attention to their actions or even leaving any indication except for a suddenly correct post.
The post in question was submitted by an unknown person who registered on the forums under a false identity, claimed to have lots of connections, and indicated that working with an "amateurish" group like TNDF (we who make "idle threats" and show "all our cards on a BB") would cost him both his contacts and his hard-won respect. (Remember that at the time, many of us were paranoiacally awaiting a flood of critical posts from industry shills, and this looked a lot like it might be the first.) The post violated the standards of behavior to which we had all agreed, and so I took it off and posted a statement about visitors' acceptable use of the forums.
I called Dubber and discussed my intention of reposting the message for everyone to judge for themselves, with the understanding that if we began to be flooded with such messages, it might be a two- or three-person job to keep the SNR down. I restored the message's content, adding an explanatory note at the top. Dubber also posted a statement of solidarity, and implied that the unknown poster should have been "adult enough" to register under his own name. Taking this as an accusation of immaturity, the poster made a petulant farewell post intimating what a loss to the group his departure represented, then apparently picked up his marbles and went home.
Only Mutant Post Elves from Hell would be involved in such a police action, and none are on staff here, so in the one instance that's occurred so far it has fallen to me instead. As it was, I had asked the pertinent "what if" question several days before at a meeting, and everyone agreed that if in my opinion a post should be spiked, I should spike it. I did so in this case, but only halfway and halfheartedly, and still not without criticism. If we start to get frequent and flagrant posts of this type from unknown posters, it may come to that yet again, but I hope it won't.
Hopefully, that's all I'll have to say on that topic. |
| Dubber |
Posted - 06/04/2003 : 2:26:57 PM quote: Originally posted by Tony ...The most extreme being when I recently deleted two duplicate topics, as well as the apology of the dupe poster to preserve consistency. On some occasions it involves correcting a glaring mistake in a post as well as a comment in a reply which points it out, in order to preserve consistency and avoid confusion. Such a correction happened here, and evoked an exchange which encouraged me to post this topic.
I am comfortable with doing this so long as nothing that I do changes the poster's message...
imo, the most extreme being when an entire post was deleted and later restored here. Be that as it may, pointing at myself, I would rather see/do minimal spelling edits than possible reinterpretations/restatements of OPP. (Flame retardant suit on, just in case. I'm not trying to be combative here, I just think people's self expression, should be relatively inviolate) |
| Tony |
Posted - 06/04/2003 : 2:26:01 PM quote: Originally posted by Tony It's never all or nothing in the forums--
Originally posted by Dubber Too true.
That seems a bit out of context, so I guess I should clarify. I was responding to jody's statement, "I'd hate to see them [the Post Elves] go because it was all or nothing," by saying that I would be happy to limit them to whatever level of cosmetic/syntactical/grammatical fixing with which the group feels comfortable. If that's the status quo, none, or anything in between, I'll be more than happy to oblige.
The most important thing in my opinion is that when someone posts in the forums, that they can trust that their ideas and opinions will be read as they intended. That's my goal, and I and the Post Elves will only make fixes and tweaks that support that goal. |
| Dubber |
Posted - 06/04/2003 : 2:09:45 PM quote: Originally posted by Tony It's never all or nothing in the forums--
Too true. I'm of the opinion that admins should 'touch' posts as little as possible. I can, and suspect will, be overruled. Either way, I won't be changing my editing behavior unless told to not do the small amount of editing I do:quote: Originally posted by Dubber: ...I occasionally correct egregious fat finger errors (I'm neither a good grammarian nor a gud speler) in other folks posts...
|
| Tony |
Posted - 06/04/2003 : 1:44:30 PM It's never all or nothing in the forums--only on the Hill. I'd be glad to decrease their activity to any degree that the group saw fit. |
| jody |
Posted - 06/04/2003 : 1:31:06 PM I would be the last to complain about the job the Post Elves are doing. They take the time to do what I often don't. They make me look better, if that is possible, and always warn me when it became necessary. I'd hate to see them go because it was all or nothing. I trust them, but I also know how to object if they make a change I don't like. Maybe I can post a flag outside my door that lets them know they are welcome. |
|
|