Tennessee Digital Freedom Forum
Tennessee Digital Freedom Forum
Home | Profile | Register | Active Topics | Members | Search | FAQ
Username:
Password:
Save Password
Forgot your Password?

 All Forums
 Tennessee Technology Legislation
 Message
 My letter to Briley
 New Topic  Reply to Topic
 Printer Friendly
Author Previous Topic Topic Next Topic  

RobertDupuy

9 Posts

Posted - 05/02/2003 :  9:06:42 PM  Show Profile  Reply with Quote
Folks...its all about how we want to run society.
Take a grocery store...take out the alarms, security guards
everything...its all an expense anyway, and just have the
government cut people's hands off if they steal something.
Thats one way to run society... a ridiculous one. But it
lowers the costs to the consumer.

With technology, we have the opportunity just to make it impossible
to steal...then we don't have to have a whole new class of felons
rotting away in our jails...this is the civilized way, and with
a bit of effort, this can be real...and it will be real.

Anyway, I tried not to sound too crazy, and I sent this letter to
briley:

-----------------------------
Mr. Briley,

I do sincerely hope to be able to attend your next meeting. The question I
will be most interested to know, is
the source of this $130 million dollar figure. How is this estimate derived
and how does it compare to the profits in the same industry?

The reason I ask, is because, frankly, crime is something we deal with in
every industry. I worked for the cable companies in the past, and also
Dollar General, and now a publishing house. So I think I have some
knowledge of managing this cost.

As you have correctly noted, I am concerned about losses to the citizens of
TN, and I am concerned about crime. And I agree that it is the domain of
the legislature of TN to deal with crime in this state. However, it is not
the exclusive domain of the legislature. The fact is, in all industries I
have worked in, it has been up to each corporation to manage losses due to
crime.

At Dollar General, we had to install security systems in stores, alarms, in
some stores even guards, and this was a cost, a cost passed on to customers.
However, by managing the cost of shoplifting more efficiently than our
competitors we could offer better prices. Of course, I don't represent
Dollar General now, but you understand my premise, I think.

And what I find in other industries, like digital media, in some cases they
have the opportunity to almost entirely eliminate losses through technology.
However, they have a reason not to do this.

Now, before I get into this too much, I want to say in one industry I know
about, it makes a lot of sense to take very high losses, because the losses
aren't real anyway, but they can be written off on taxes. I'm talking about
the credit industry. They don't try to eliminate certain types of losses at
all, but in fact encourage them.

So, my question...and it is indeed a question, is how much of these losses
are real? And the other question I have,
is did they behave responsibly in managing their losses as other industries
do?

Or as their competitors did...or are they simply asking the state government
to pick up the tab. Is it corporate welfare?

You see, in this instance, I believe it is likely that it is corporate
welfare. At Dollar General we never asked
the legislature to make shoplifting a felony, and to house all these new
felons in our state prisons, because it would
have helped our bottom line a bit...perhaps we could even take out the
alarms, and saved money, after turning over this duty to the state of TN.

I am sorry for being facetious, I don't mean too. Actually, I'm just not a
natural politician and I'm trying to word
my concerns as best I can.

OK, I want to site a real example...DirecTV, which is part of Hughes
Communications, in turn part of General Motors, spent $25 million dollars on
security on their satellite systems. It was called Period 4. Is that a lot
of moneyt? Yes. Was it passed on to their customers, yes. Is it out of
line for their market segment? No.

The fact is, in the digital realm, corporations have the opportunity to
completely eliminate losses, of certain types, if they will invest in the
technology responsibly. Period 4 is a great success, and someday, they will
eliminate piracy
of satellite technology completely. Hackers just don't the resources of
General Motors. Too much is made of Hackers in the media. Sure in the
early days, a 14 year old working in his bedroom could outsmart the
lax and simple security systems of those days. But as time goes on, it
won't exist.

Did these people behave responsibly to eliminate their losses?

My fear, is that the losses aren't entirely real. They are tax write offs.
They do have some real losses, but
they are asking the state to eliminate what technology and research could
have eliminated. They will
watch their real losses go down, but report even higher losses in the
future...and come back asking for more
welfare.

You may say, this is too much without proof. I really want a chance to
examine those losses, if they
will provide how they arrived them, I think I can do a good job of asking
the right questions about them.
I would also like to suggest how encryption technologies could help, and how
they can actually
eliminate theft of subscription services.

I don't really know the best way to participate. But I'd still like to
help.
And I'm sure the existing laws could be tweaked to the benefit of all.
But I do not think that all the groups you mentioned represent all the
interests of TN.
Though I cited DirecTV as a good example, they are also big business too.

The consumer is still under represented, because when we shift one cost to
the taxpayers
of TN, the consumer still has not necessarily benefited. At least now I
don't have to
buy cable tv...I can buy the better managed Satellite TV service, or I can
choose not to bother with
any of them.

But we all pay higher and higher taxes every year.

Thanks very much for listening to me...sorry it was so long,

Robert

bucket

51 Posts

Posted - 05/10/2003 :  05:58:20 AM  Show Profile  Reply with Quote
Here is a copy of my short email to Briley:
**********************************************************************
Rep. Briley,

I am a registered voter and, like you, am a practicing attorney.
My office law office workstation is protected by a firewall.
When I send confidential data by email, it can be protected by
an encryption program.

Soon, however, both the firewall and the encryption program may be
illegal in Tennessee. At the behest of the Motion Picture Association
of America, a super DMCA bill is before you- House Bill 547 and
Senate Bill 213.

I *strongly* oppose this piece of legislation. It may advance the
interests of the MPAA, but, if passed, may adversely affect my, and
your, ability to practice law.
s/
**********************************************************************


I sent modified versions of the above email to my legislators, Sen. Jim Bryson & Rep. Beth Harwell.
Go to Top of Page
  Previous Topic Topic Next Topic  
 New Topic  Reply to Topic
 Printer Friendly
Jump To:
Tennessee Digital Freedom Forum © 2003 TNDF.net Go To Top Of Page
Snitz Forums 2000