| Author |
Topic  |
|
|
Dubber
441 Posts |
Posted - 04/25/2003 : 10:59:11 AM
|
I've seen several really good analogies here, so let me summarize what I remember reading, reply to this if you have others.
The bill would (by illegalizing obfuscating machine origins / illegalizing firewall type devices which are readily available on the market today / NAT / &c) create a system analogus to:
Charging per gallon of gas put in a car by number of seats (who said this one?)
Charging for water/sewer service according to number of toilets (from Shawn)
I don't remember the others, but lets consolidate them here...
|
|
|
mwjones
3 Posts |
Posted - 05/07/2003 : 7:45:18 PM
|
How about the telephone company limiting the number of phones you can have in your house.
quote: Originally posted by Dubber
I've seen several really good analogies here, so let me summarize what I remember reading, reply to this if you have others.
The bill would (by illegalizing obfuscating machine origins / illegalizing firewall type devices which are readily available on the market today / NAT / &c) create a system analogus to:
Charging per gallon of gas put in a car by number of seats (who said this one?)
Charging for water/sewer service according to number of toilets (from Shawn)
I don't remember the others, but lets consolidate them here...
Michael Jones |
 |
|
|
SKozicki
243 Posts |
Posted - 05/07/2003 : 10:09:41 PM
|
quote: How about the telephone company limiting the number of phones you can have in your house.
This is definitely a relevant analogy, and one that Rep Buck brought out in committee. It's *exactly* what is going on. The cable cos are trying to legislate what you can and cannot connect to their service. Their aim is to nickel and dime you for everything you connect to that service. It's not whether you are using it to defraud them, because by simply connecting something that enables you to utilize the bandwidth that's not expressly permitted, they consider it fraud.
They are claiming that they are losing $100M-$130M in TN alone. This is opportunity cost (revenue not realized), not actual loss. This is a big difference. It's akin to General Motors saying that they are losing $1B because people fix their own cars instead of going to the dealers. The difference is that GM doesn't have a law requiring people to go to the dealer to modify or alter their cars. The cable cos do in this bill.
As Rep Buck asked in committee: "If I connect a splitter to the line so that I can watch cable on 2 teevees at the same time, am I guilty?" The answer is yes. You are not only violating Comcast's TOS which prohibits such action, but you are now considered a criminal for this act. Not to mention that Comcast could take you to civil court and charge you a MINIMUM of $1500 per day per SPLITTER. All because they want to charge for each device connected to the cable.
When asked "if it wasn't in Comcast's TOS that I cannot connect a splitter when I signed up for the service, but then Comcast changes their TOS afterward, would I be considered in violation" the lobbyist's answer was "I don't know."
A variety of analogies fit. You can connect any # of devices to your electric utility as long as it's not dangerous. You can have as many faucets and taps in your home for water service. You can basically utilize any utility (even telephony) however you see fit once that service enters your home. All except cable. This bill would fortify that position with criminal and civil penalties. |
 |
|
|
RobertDupuy
9 Posts |
Posted - 05/08/2003 : 2:48:23 PM
|
it's like making a pencil illegal when its used to write a note for a bank robbery.
it doesn't make any sense, I agree with those who have said, this is just the arrogant cable monopolies expecting to have a broadband monopoly as well. |
 |
|
|
RobertDupuy
9 Posts |
Posted - 05/09/2003 : 10:14:59 AM
|
wow, you all are good at making your points, I learn a lot from this board.
Now, I want to say one other thing, which I will admit is a side issue to this central issue (see I learn)...but its this....again, my pet subject of free speech.
The Supreme Court in 1995 said that anonymous speech is a protected constitutional right, it also said a few years later, that internet speech, including political e-mail is also protected speech.
The problem here, is that acceptable use from comcast is so restrictive...they actually ban political messages from being sent from their service. This is not wrong, in itself, as private property rights would override free speech rights.
Except for one thing, they are a monopoly. Their monopoly status, actually allows them to outlaw in their acceptable use policy, what the state government doesn't have the power to outlaw.....constitutionally protected right to free speech through e-mail, including bulk e-mails!
Its an incredible power....outrageous they would even try, since commerical spam is the problem with spam...political e-mails are rare anyway.
But it gives you an insight into way Comcast executives think.
But I digress, yes comcast is a private corporation...they could write their acceptable use policy, and we could tell them to go take a hike...except for one thing...they are a monopoly...in cable tv, and increasingly, they don't feel competitive pressures even in the broadband arena.
Under this bill, you are not only in violation of their acceptable use policy....which is the case now...but you would be a felon.
In other words, you will be a felon for exercising your constitutional right to free speech, if your only access to the internet was through comcast...which because of their monopoly status may well be the case. My employer, for example, pays for my internet, but I have only one choice...comcast.
after talking with my employer yesterday, it will be extremely difficult for me to be the one to protest these new laws by violating the comcast acceptable use...afraid I will be silenced as well.
sorry, but I have a family to support.... still, I am encouraged to see some senators standing against this bill....
keep the faith
Robert |
Edited by - RobertDupuy on 05/09/2003 10:27:51 AM |
 |
|
|
jody
395 Posts |
Posted - 05/09/2003 : 10:55:46 AM
|
And going along with what Robert was saying, though it does diverge slightly from the topic at hand, when does a commercial service become a public utility? The evidence is mounting that "communication service providers" are becoming fewer in number and diversity while traditional "communication providers" like the cable companies and the telcos are increasing their share of the market. In this slightly old article on Salon( http://www.salon.com/tech/feature/2002/06/07/broadband/print.html ) a case is made for the impending concentration of market share in the hands of a few but singularly wealthy media companies. With such a trend the idea that consumers have a choice of "Terms of Service" in the market disappears. Though the internet per se may not be owned by these monopolits, they will have created a fence around it charging exorbitant prices at the gates of entry.
Following these trends are the growing reliance of the general public on the internet for all kinds of commerce and communication. The internet has become a public utility with growing importance in the lives of all individuals. Access to that public utility must be protected for the benefit of the people, and communications service providers must necessarily be restrained in providing that access. Whether this is done through governmental regulations or a free market system matters less than that the public utility be protected. However, depending on personal politics, the method of protection does matter. Libertarians would most likely see the Super DMCA laws as being a case of government intervention against the people in support of industry; being who they are they might oppose this legislation simply because it draws the government into our daily lives even more than what it is. Those individuals with more socialist tendancies would immediately object that the laws are only a half measure of government responsibility. They might suggest that such legislation necessarily obligates the government to create a regulatory framework to protect the public utility known as the internet. Either way, the Super DMCA laws are examples of bad legislation and bad government. |
 |
|
|
nathan
49 Posts |
Posted - 05/09/2003 : 10:48:09 PM
|
Perhaps one for the bill in general.
The original bill gave the cable/media industry a loaded gun. It was the ammunition to take out anybody doing anything they did not like. The bill has been greatly improved in many areas. Unfortunately, the bill is only as strong as its weakest component. Now, instead of being handed a loaded gun, they are being handed an empty gun, and they are at liberty to provide their own ammunition, in the form of their Terms of Service agreement. |
 |
|
|
Tholt1022
5 Posts |
Posted - 05/09/2003 : 10:55:21 PM
|
I am paying for a connection to the internet. That wire comes from the ISP. I am paying for that wire, and that connection. The ISP Does NOT care how many computers. It should not matter if I network that connection to 500 computers in my house. And if anyone has a say over it, it should be the ISP.
And this is really going to screw up Intel's new WI-FI movement, because I'm sure that McDonalds will totaly drop that. |
 |
|
| |
Topic  |
|
|
|