| Author |
Topic  |
|
|
kaylin4u
1 Posts |
Posted - 05/21/2003 : 1:58:45 PM
|
Can I borrow a cup of sugar?
Oh..I forgot, sharing something with family, friend or neighbor, when "you would normally have to go out and buy it", is considered theft!
And if the cable companies are loosing billions of dollars a year with analog signal theft, and the "white lie", then for heaven's sake, they need to pay their cable man to completely remove the cable!
Sorry to be that way, but the bills that are on the table are completely LUDICROUS! This is a market where RIAA and MPAA could make billions of dollars a year MORE than they ever have! It's about money making, nothing else!
I have no pity for any lawmaker pushing a bill so they can have more control over my home.
|
|
|
jody
395 Posts |
Posted - 05/21/2003 : 2:39:14 PM
|
| Amen brother. |
 |
|
|
SKozicki
243 Posts |
Posted - 05/21/2003 : 3:19:04 PM
|
| Not only is it about money making, but it's about HELPING A MONOPOLY make money. Considering that the 6 largest publically traded cable service providers are all losing money, in a monopoly industry, do we really need to help them out? |
 |
|
|
Scott Lyon
298 Posts |
Posted - 05/21/2003 : 3:36:48 PM
|
But Scott...how can they POSSIBLY make any money if we prevent them from tapping the $130 million of potential revenue they know is somewhere out there waiting for them? Whatever the societal cost, we ABSOLUTELY MUST protect this desparately struggling industry from doing the unthinkable.......innovating. 
Also heard a great piece on NPR a couple weeks back about cable providers making ESPN a premium service apart from basic cable because of the unreasonable (and rising) costs and conditions imposed by content providers. Makes me wonder how much the MPAA has its hand in the costs which make the cable providers "struggle". |
 |
|
|
mdchaney
9 Posts |
Posted - 05/23/2003 : 03:39:04 AM
|
quote: Originally posted by Scott Lyon
But Scott...how can they POSSIBLY make any money if we prevent them from tapping the $130 million of potential revenue they know is somewhere out there waiting for them?
What is this "potential revenue"? You seem to forget that this is a loss. Why, it's costing them $4000 for each pirate!
By the way, if you think this "loss" is as ludicrous as I do (remembering that lack of a gain does not constitute a loss, or stated another way, "you can't lose what you never had"), the cable industry in FL is claiming a loss of over $400M/year. As long as they're making up numbers, might as well make them impressive.
I'm fascinated by the fact that they are making the same claims in all states (huge "losses" for the cable industry, "MPAA? We've never been contacted by them", etc.).
Michael |
 |
|
|
SKozicki
243 Posts |
Posted - 05/23/2003 : 10:35:41 AM
|
When I told Sen Person that $130M in 'losses' was derived by dividing the NCTA's number of $6.5B by 50, he laughed. Ann Carr's face turned red. When I then told him that this number was not a 'loss' by any stretch of the imagination, he rebuked me by saying that even if one person steals, it's too many. But he did acknowledge that the numbers were crap.
The Republican Caucus meeting went even further. They were the ones that really latched onto the fact that this is a monopoly trying to legislate their problems away. They definitely understood that the numbers didn't make any sense.
Using their math, we can derive the following:
$130M in losses in TN alone $130M/$34.52/12 (NCTA avg cost of cable per month) = 313827 TN's stealing cable a year 313827 is almost 3x as many people who would fit in Neyland stadium 313827 is twice as many people that make up ALL OTHER THEFT offenses of any kind (including property, larceny, grand larceny, burglary, etc) in TN 313827 represents more than 22% of all TN's who have cable
so you mean to tell me that one in 5 steals cable? that cable theft is more rampant than all other theft? Does the Attorney General know this?
puhleeze. 376 |
 |
|
|
mdchaney
9 Posts |
Posted - 05/23/2003 : 3:11:52 PM
|
quote: Originally posted by SKozicki $130M in losses in TN alone $130M/$34.52/12 (NCTA avg cost of cable per month) = 313827 TN's stealing cable a year
Your math is incorrect, er, correct. Remember, the cable industry is making the ludicrous claim that they're losing $4000 per person (no time period specified) who steals it. It's likely that their math is more like $130M/$4K, which works out to only 32,500 cable thieves. Oddly, that number is still probably off by a factor of 10 or more.
As I said before, they're claiming $400M in FL, $6B/year nationwide. I would laugh if this weren't so serious.
And, as I said before, their marginal cost is effectively $0, particularly if someone else did the wiring job for them, so they are in reality losing nothing. And the final point is that, even if they are losing something, current law suffices to stop that if they care to. The fact that they don't use current law to stop it is proof positive that this bill is about something other than cable theft.
Michael |
 |
|
| |
Topic  |
|
|
|