Tennessee Digital Freedom Forum
Tennessee Digital Freedom Forum
Home | Profile | Register | Active Topics | Members | Search | FAQ
Username:
Password:
Save Password
Forgot your Password?

 All Forums
 Tennessee Technology Legislation
 Message
 Competitive Enterprise Institute
 New Topic  Reply to Topic
 Printer Friendly
Author Previous Topic Topic Next Topic  

Dubber

441 Posts

Posted - 05/27/2003 :  09:00:14 AM  Show Profile  Visit Dubber's Homepage  Send Dubber a Yahoo! Message  Reply with Quote
From: Fred von Lohmann EFF
Sent: Friday, May 23, 2003 11:03 AM
To: sdmca - effaustin.org
Subject: [sdmca] CEI's C:Spin - 'Super-DMCA' Bills: Cable Companies
Could Control Consumers' Choices


Great piece from the Competitive Enterprise Institute. It's not yet on the CEI web site, but should show up Real Soon Now at: http://www.cei.org/dyn/pubs_by_type.cfm?type=16

[ actually the link is: http://www.cei.org/gencon/016,03492.cfm ]

Begin forwarded message:

> CEI C:\SPIN
>  
> This issue:  'Super DMCA' Bills: Cable Companies Could Control
> Consumers' Choices
>  
> This week's c:\spin is by Hanah Metchis, Research Analyst, CEI, May
> 23, 2003.
>  
>             Let's begin with a little pop quiz. Suppose you are
> redoing your kitchen, and you hear about a fantabulous new electronic
> gadget. It attaches to your refrigerator and monitors the contents by
> scanning the barcodes and measuring the weight of each item. When
> you're running low on something, that item is displayed on a small
> screen, and an internal modem allows you to order more with the touch
> of a button using a grocery delivery service such as Peapod. Thrilled
> by this exciting new convenience, you rush out to buy one. Here's the
> question: Whose permission do you need to install this item? (a) The
> manufacturer of your refrigerator, (b) The phone company, or (c) None
> of the above.
>             For most of us, the answer is none of the above. But if
> you live in Delaware, Illinois, Maryland, Michigan, Oregon,
> Pennsylvania, Virginia, or Wyoming, the answer is the phone company.
> And if you live in one of the nine other states where "super-DMCA"
> bills are moving through the legislature, you might soon need to ask
> your phone or cable company for permission every time you buy a new
> piece of hardware – and in some cases, software too.
>             Despite the moniker, the super-DMCA bills are not much
> like the Digital Millennium Copyright Act (DMCA) which became federal
> law in 1998. They do deal with the same issue – the protection of
> copyright in an age when digital devices make piracy an easy task –
> but the state bills use much broader language. (The state bills differ
> in their details, but are all based on the same model legislation.)
> They outlaw any "communications device" used "without the express
> consent or express authorization of the communication service
> provider." That means your phone company, cable company, and ISP get
> to decide what's legal and what's not. This is not a good idea for the
> future of tech competition.
>             Internet providers are probably not particularly
> interested in barring the installation of hardware that monitors the
> content of your kitchen. Their most likely immediate target is digital
> video recorders. Cable companies have brought lawsuits against
> manufacturers of TiVo-like devices, but now they offer their own
> proprietary products and services that do the same thing. Under a
> super-DMCA law, cable companies would have the power to declare all
> DVRs and even VCRs made by competing companies to be unauthorized
> devices. And the legislation is so broadly written that it could even
> let your cable company, phone company, or ISP decide what brand of
> computer you can have and what software you can run on it. This would
> give "communication service providers" unprecedented control over
> consumer choices and the fates of entire industries.
>             In addition, provisions in some versions of the super-DMCA
> laws forbid users to conceal certain types of online activity. This
> could turn users and manufacturers of ordinary security and networking
> software, such as firewalls and routers, into criminals. Any law this
> extraordinarily overbroad is certain to stifle innovation.
>             The problem of protecting copyrights is a real one, and it
> is difficult to solve. But the super-DMCA bills, in their attempt to
> counter vague threats with vague language, create more problems than
> they solve. Theft, fraud, and copyright violation are already illegal.
> Making every "communications device" suspect and every consumer a
> possible criminal is not the way to prevent piracy.
>  
> C:\SPIN is produced by the Competitive Enterprise Institute.
  Previous Topic Topic Next Topic  
 New Topic  Reply to Topic
 Printer Friendly
Jump To:
Tennessee Digital Freedom Forum © 2003 TNDF.net Go To Top Of Page
Snitz Forums 2000