From: Fred von Lohmann EFF Sent: Friday, May 23, 2003 11:03 AM To: sdmca - effaustin.org Subject: [sdmca] CEI's C:Spin - 'Super-DMCA' Bills: Cable Companies Could Control Consumers' Choices
Great piece from the Competitive Enterprise Institute. It's not yet on the CEI web site, but should show up Real Soon Now at: http://www.cei.org/dyn/pubs_by_type.cfm?type=16
[ actually the link is: http://www.cei.org/gencon/016,03492.cfm ]
Begin forwarded message:
> CEI C:\SPIN > > This issue: 'Super DMCA' Bills: Cable Companies Could Control > Consumers' Choices > > This week's c:\spin is by Hanah Metchis, Research Analyst, CEI, May > 23, 2003. > > Let's begin with a little pop quiz. Suppose you are > redoing your kitchen, and you hear about a fantabulous new electronic > gadget. It attaches to your refrigerator and monitors the contents by > scanning the barcodes and measuring the weight of each item. When > you're running low on something, that item is displayed on a small > screen, and an internal modem allows you to order more with the touch > of a button using a grocery delivery service such as Peapod. Thrilled > by this exciting new convenience, you rush out to buy one. Here's the > question: Whose permission do you need to install this item? (a) The > manufacturer of your refrigerator, (b) The phone company, or (c) None > of the above. > For most of us, the answer is none of the above. But if > you live in Delaware, Illinois, Maryland, Michigan, Oregon, > Pennsylvania, Virginia, or Wyoming, the answer is the phone company. > And if you live in one of the nine other states where "super-DMCA" > bills are moving through the legislature, you might soon need to ask > your phone or cable company for permission every time you buy a new > piece of hardware – and in some cases, software too. > Despite the moniker, the super-DMCA bills are not much > like the Digital Millennium Copyright Act (DMCA) which became federal > law in 1998. They do deal with the same issue – the protection of > copyright in an age when digital devices make piracy an easy task – > but the state bills use much broader language. (The state bills differ > in their details, but are all based on the same model legislation.) > They outlaw any "communications device" used "without the express > consent or express authorization of the communication service > provider." That means your phone company, cable company, and ISP get > to decide what's legal and what's not. This is not a good idea for the > future of tech competition. > Internet providers are probably not particularly > interested in barring the installation of hardware that monitors the > content of your kitchen. Their most likely immediate target is digital > video recorders. Cable companies have brought lawsuits against > manufacturers of TiVo-like devices, but now they offer their own > proprietary products and services that do the same thing. Under a > super-DMCA law, cable companies would have the power to declare all > DVRs and even VCRs made by competing companies to be unauthorized > devices. And the legislation is so broadly written that it could even > let your cable company, phone company, or ISP decide what brand of > computer you can have and what software you can run on it. This would > give "communication service providers" unprecedented control over > consumer choices and the fates of entire industries. > In addition, provisions in some versions of the super-DMCA > laws forbid users to conceal certain types of online activity. This > could turn users and manufacturers of ordinary security and networking > software, such as firewalls and routers, into criminals. Any law this > extraordinarily overbroad is certain to stifle innovation. > The problem of protecting copyrights is a real one, and it > is difficult to solve. But the super-DMCA bills, in their attempt to > counter vague threats with vague language, create more problems than > they solve. Theft, fraud, and copyright violation are already illegal. > Making every "communications device" suspect and every consumer a > possible criminal is not the way to prevent piracy. > > C:\SPIN is produced by the Competitive Enterprise Institute.
|