Tennessee Digital Freedom Forum
Tennessee Digital Freedom Forum
Home | Profile | Register | Active Topics | Members | Search | FAQ
Username:
Password:
Save Password
Forgot your Password?

 All Forums
 Tennessee Technology Legislation
 Legislation
 Joint Committee Hearing on 10/29/03
 New Topic  Reply to Topic
 Printer Friendly
Previous Page
Author Previous Topic Topic Next Topic
Page: of 2

Scott Lyon

271 Posts

Posted - 11/03/2003 :  10:26:00 PM  Show Profile  Reply with Quote
quote:
Originally posted by kelargo
  • Who certifies a device as being Unlawful?
  • What does it cost a manufacturer to certify their device is Lawful?

  • - There isn't a certification process under their proposed bill. The decision of whether or not a device is "unlawful" depends on the outcome of litigation started by someone challenging the possession, sale, use, etc. of a particular device. So, I suppose the best way to answer this question is: the manufacturer would pay its own attorneys fees defending its device in court.
    quote:
  • Can a TN Manufacturer export their certified TN Unlawful device into another State where the device is Lawful?

  • - Under their proposed bill: no. The bill does not respect state borders, so long as some part of the offense is committed in Tennessee. Thus, it is illegal to import or export a device into or out of Tennessee, even if it is legal in other states.
    quote:
  • If a Manufacturer in another state sends their product to TN resident, who is liable for this TN Law? The Manufacuter in another state or the resident in TN?

  • - Under their proposed bill: both (depending on who had an "intent to defraud" (an undefined term, which nobody knows how to apply right now)). The unlawful device is illegal to make, illegal to possess, and illegal to use, if you have an intent to defraud (or presumably, enable another to defraud).
    quote:
  • What if a person in another state where the device is lawful moves to TN- What procedure must this new resident perform to avoid breaking the Law for owning a suddenly new Unlawful Device? What does this cost?

  • - The person must avoid transporting the device into the state. The cost: ?
    quote:
  • What if a Manufacture in another State, where the device is lawful, ships the device overnight to another state where it is also lawful, but the shipment travels across TN state line. Who is breaking the Law? Manufacuter in other state, Resident in other state or shipping company in TN? (located in Memphis, perhaps?)

  • - This gets tricky, because it's mixing state and federal issues. The federal government (a la Congress) has power over "interstate commerce", which they don't share readily with states. Basically, states can't pass laws which would unduly hinder interstate commerce. In order to avoid coming into federal conflict, the bill would have to be read as evaluating the device at point of origin and point of destination, and purely transporting the device across the state as freight would be excluded (Courts try to construe laws in a way to keep them constitutional, so I think this is how a Tennessee court would read the law, but it's anyone's guess if this is what actually happened).
    quote:
  • Who pays for the ceritification?

  • - There is no certification process under their bill.
    quote:
  • How does a manufacture provide updates to their product and avoid accidently creating an Unlawful device?

  • - Under their proposed bill, I don't know if this can happen. If the analysis depends on a state of action (possessing, selling, assembling) and a mental state (intent to defraud), I'm not sure that modifying the device without changing these other two conditions will affect the legal status of the device.
    quote:
  • How expensive is this certification to perform for "time to market" value add to the cost of creating a new product?
  • How can the certifying agency ensure the new product will not be exposed to other manufacturers who are also having their product certified? Who could possibly loose market competitive edge from a spy at the certify agency?

  • - There is no certification process.
    quote:
  • What happens when a product is Lawful with one TN Service Provider and Unlawful with a different Service Provider?

  • - The device isn't really "lawful" to anyone at any time. It's just a question of whether someone wants to claim that a device is unlawful. Every provider can at any time claim that a device is unlawful and that you have an intent to defraud. Even if you succeed, the issue is not res judicata for the next provider, who can also sue you.
    quote:
  • What happens to a resident who has a Lawful device with one Service Provider and switches to a different Service Provider who declares the device as being Unlawful?

  • - See the response above.
    quote:
  • Who is responsible for informing the new user their device is unlawful?

  • - Under their proposed bill: no one. They don't have to give any notice at all, of anything.
    quote:
  • How is the new user informed that their device is unlawful?


  • - Under their proposed bill: they are served with a summons, or the police seize their equipment.
    quote:
  • What can the owner of this unlawful device do regarding the depreciation of their unlawful device, if it was used for commercial reasons, such as Network Management and Troublshooting services.

  • - Not sure how this fits into the bill. Could you clarify the question please?
    quote:
  • Can a manufacturer of a Unlawful device export their product to another Country, where the device is Lawful?


  • - Under their proposed bill: no. As long as the device has some connection to Tennessee, this Tennessee law would apply.
    quote:
  • Again, What exactly is an Unlawful Device?

  • - It could be anything under their proposed bill. The bill does not limit the definition (to avoid excluding devices the service providers may want to outlaw).
    quote:
    Can devices really be unlawful? or just the ACTIVITY and USE of the device be considered unlawful?
    - We have some good discussion in this forum about the risks of confronting exclusively conduct, and why this may be one of the problems with their bill.
    quote:
    Is it unlawful to own a gun? Or is it Unlawful to shoot and kill someone with a gun?
    - It may not be unlawful to own a gun, but it may be unlawful to own a bazooka or vehicle-mounted machine gun. One of the things I think we tried to accomplish in our bill is to make this distinction. We can punish people for committing acts against the public (or against the service provider) without necessarily outlawing the object that was used in the crime or offense (the gun in the above example). But at the same time, there are some items (such as the bazooka) which have very little legitimate use but pose a greater risk of harm, and these items it may be reasonable to prohibit (i.e. devices with no substantial use other than committing a theft of service).
    Go to Top of Page

    kelargo

    21 Posts

    Posted - 11/08/2003 :  2:46:19 PM  Show Profile  Reply with Quote
    quote:
    It may not be unlawful to own a gun, but it may be unlawful to own a bazooka or vehicle-mounted machine gun. One of the things I think we tried to accomplish in our bill is to make this distinction. We can punish people for committing acts against the public (or against the service provider) without necessarily outlawing the object that was used in the crime or offense (the gun in the above example). But at the same time, there are some items (such as the bazooka) which have very little legitimate use but pose a greater risk of harm, and these items it may be reasonable to prohibit (i.e. devices with no substantial use other than committing a theft of service).
    This is a very good point and you it exactly what I am saying.

    Bazookas and such are regulated devices, at the federal level (ATF), not at the State level.

    As such, if a device should be unlawful, it should be regulated at the Federal level, not the State level.
    quote:
    quote:
    What can the owner of this unlawful device do regarding the depreciation of their unlawful device, if it was used for commercial reasons, such as Network Management and Troublshooting services.
    - Not sure how this fits into the bill. Could you clarify the question please?
    A person owns a device lawfully. All of a sudden, the device is unlawful. The person who owned the device is now breaking the law and must dispose of the property.

    How is the owner going to get reimbursed for the lost value of the property?

    The owner was able to depreciate the property on their Federal income tax as a business expense. That is not longer possible.

    quote:
    - This gets tricky, because it's mixing state and federal issues. The federal government (a la Congress) has power over "interstate commerce", which they don't share readily with states. Basically, states can't pass laws which would unduly hinder interstate commerce. In order to avoid coming into federal conflict, the bill would have to be read as evaluating the device at point of origin and point of destination, and purely transporting the device across the state as freight would be excluded (Courts try to construe laws in a way to keep them constitutional, so I think this is how a Tennessee court would read the law, but it's anyone's guess if this is what actually happened).
    Creating a law as nebulous as this reads, without any certifying process to guarantee indiviudal freedoms, is wrought with conflicts of Interstate Conflicts.
    Go to Top of Page

    SKozicki

    242 Posts

    Posted - 11/10/2003 :  10:03:38 AM  Show Profile  Send SKozicki an AOL message  Reply with Quote
    Of interest:

    http://www.efga.org/archives/00000019.html

    This is a link to the CEA and CERC proposed legislation.
    Go to Top of Page
    Page: of 2 Previous Topic Topic Next Topic  
    Previous Page
     New Topic  Reply to Topic
     Printer Friendly
    Jump To:
    Tennessee Digital Freedom Forum © 2003 TNDF.net Go To Top Of Page
    Snitz Forums 2000