| Author |
Topic  |
|
|
Tony
401 Posts |
Posted - 10/30/2003 : 11:44:59 PM
|
[Originally posted by kelargo:] How can the cable industry be irate about cable theft when I have lived in two different places (in MD and VA..) where the cable company left the signal on from the previous tenants?
When I moved in, I cabled up my TV and I had basic cable. The cable companies need to clean up their own act first. Was I stealing the service or was the cable company negligent?
Not only are they sloppy in this regard, but the law does not provide any penalty for loss of service. The providers are not liable for poor performance and loss of signal.
It's a two way street, but they are trying to make it a one way street.
Ken
|
|
|
Tony
401 Posts |
Posted - 10/31/2003 : 12:14:09 AM
|
First, Ken, I hope you don't mind that I moved your message to a more appropriate forum and made it a separate topic; it really deserves to stand on its own, because I'm sure a lot of people ask the same question.
The cable companies are generally not irate about your service being on when you moved in. It's part of their business model. In such cases, SOP is to disconnect the old service the next time a cable technician can get around to it. If they find that someone is using the service, they generally leave a polite note explaining that they'd turned off the old service and that if you want new service you can call the cable company.
If you reconnect the service again without paying for it, that's when things can get ugly. If they find it, the next note will not be an apology, but a notice that if you want cable service, you'd better pay for it. If you reconnect it a third time without paying, expect legal action when they find out.
Seems reasonable, fitting and proper that they should handle it that way; it's not negligence, but sound business management. After all, if they rolled a truck every time someone cancelled their service, their costs (and rates) would rise considerably. It's better and cheaper for them to assume honesty on the part of the next tenant, that he'll pay for what he's getting. I don't think most folks here have a problem with that policy.
We do, however, have a problem with mandated civil penalties for service agreement violations that are far in excess of any reasonable damages, real or imagined. Under the original version of this bill (still being bandied about along with the amendment which may or may not pass with it), you could be charged as much as $10,000 per day you're in violation, per device involved. If you've got a router, laptop and PDA running off your cable modem and they aren't supposed to be, you could be subject to $210,000 a week in civil penalties. Call us crazy, but we consider that excessive.
We don't expect something for nothing. We don't expect the cable companies to provide services for free. We just don't want to give these companies dictatorial control over how their customers use those services. Capisce? |
 |
|
|
nathan
49 Posts |
Posted - 10/31/2003 : 07:59:58 AM
|
O.K. I can see your argument for not disconnecting every time a tennant leaves. But how about this:
At two separate residences, when I moved in, I ordered Extended Basic service (~70 channels, no digital) with the free promotional HBO/Showtime for 3 months. After my 3rd month of free movies, I called and requested my service be cut to Limited Basic (around 20 channels). My next bill reflected my request (~$12) but, they only cut out my movies. I still had ~70 channels. I kept wondering if they would fix this, but they never did.
Someone once told me that they have to put a filter on to limit you to Limited Basic, and that that they often do not keep many of those filters with them.
Perhaps this would be a better example of them needing to police themselves. But it is probably a weak argument for our cause.
I suppose I'll be receiving a big retroactive bill now. I hope they accept monthly payments.  |
 |
|
|
Tony
401 Posts |
Posted - 10/31/2003 : 4:47:47 PM
|
It seems that both of these cases involve getting more from the cable company than what was paid for. So Nathan, I think you're right that this isn't one of our strongest arguments.
There was a fellow who spoke at the first hearing back in April (has it only been six months?) who compared his freedom to tinker with his cable & Internet service with his reasonable (to him) attempt to break into someone's house to test their security system. That got my vote for Worst Analogy Ever Used in a Judiciary Committee Hearing.
That's one thing I really like about having these forums: they offer all of us opportunities to analyze the issues, focus our arguments, troubleshoot our logic, whether we live in Nashville or Beech Bluff. The more we use those opportunities, the clearer our message becomes, and the more successful we'll be in getting that message across. |
 |
|
|
kelargo
21 Posts |
Posted - 11/01/2003 : 03:38:27 AM
|
Hi,
I guess this is its own topic. :-)
Tony, I understand the thought that you are saying... in that the cable companies can not afford to manually turn off everyone, but I had free basic cable service for several YEARS! Who is negligent?
What defines neglient? Who says, "the subscriber willfully turned services on" versus "the cable company left service on" first? Should one just safely assumes the cable company ALWAYS turns service off? and anyone who has free basic service is automatically stealing it? What happens if you dont report it being left on within 24 hours, is it your fault and you are liable? How about 30 days? or a year?
Where is the due process? This was an analog cable service... so I understand the issue regarding man power to send out truck rolls to police the system...
But as the service providers move to an all digital system, they can incorporate a digital switching system. (even something out of band, perhaps tunneled IP providing switching something like SS7 is to the PSTN)
Their argument that they are losing so much revenue and tax base from cable theft is moot.
The real issue is THEIR business problem, that they need to solve with their technology, infrastructure, and business systems.
This is the point I'm getting at. They need to take ownership of it.
And with regard to the thing about being penalized for having routers and PDAs networked in your home...
This is very similar to the crucial moment in the breakup of AT&T. The argument ended when a person was finally allowed to have their own answering machine, not provided by AT&T. (did it end in the Carter Act? sorry, I can't remember the name of it ... circa 1974? anyone remember what I'm talking about?)
Answering machine or router... its a subscriber provided CPE device and should not be policed by the service provider. Currently, a subscriber of DSL can bring their own modem and use their own router in their home. It needs to stay that way, just like a person can buy their own answering machine. Same goes for the cable industry.
>>Side note: Technology to solve the REAL problem and some history...
They way I understand it, SS7 signalling was invented to support the creation of the RBOCs. So each RBOC could separate their busines process and networks. SS7 provided a formal boundry to interface with each RBOC. The resulting system became more secure, extendable and manageable. (over older CAS signalling...)
The cable industry is at s similar crux. They need to manage their systems better. If service is being stolen, then again, THEY need to take ownership of their neglience and poor business systems and solve the REAL problem.
Enjoy, Ken
|
 |
|
|
kelargo
21 Posts |
Posted - 11/01/2003 : 05:39:23 AM
|
To Clarify:
In the previous post, I described a new Invention.
The invention is a method of managing cable subscribers using an out of band signal to manage customer port status. The out of band signal will manage subscriber port status states and services. Some subscriber port states includes but are not limited to On, Off, Account Suspend, Channel Selection, Parental Control, Pay Per View. This invention has never been described in a public forum before. The problem solved by this invention has been described in a public form, i.e. this web site. The need was described on 10/28/2003 by cable industry experts who need to solve the problem of cable television subscription theft as described in Tennessee legislative hearing.
The cable industry experts described how they are powerless to stop cable subscription theft. The cable industry experts described how they can audit their cable system to identify theft. The industry experts describe how they are not able to stop cable theft. The current method utilized by the cable industry, described by cable industry experts, is expensive to maintain and unmanagable. The cable industry experts seek a solution to their business problem through legislation. This Invention solves that business problem by implementing a cost effective mechanism to the cable network. The Invention enables the cable industry to manage their network system in a cost effective manner and eleminate cable subscription theft.
This Invention solves the problem by utilizing an out of band signalling protocol that manages subscriber services. The out of band signalling protocol is immune to subscriber unlawful activity, as the subscriber does not have network access to that system, being out of band. The subscriber can connect their television or network device to the cable network interface, but since port subscription services are managed out of band, the subscriber is not able to unlawfully receive any electronic or optical communication transmission signal. And further since the system is managed out of band, the subscriber is not able to unlawfully manipulate the system to receive unlawful signal services.
The out of band signalling protocol can be created but not limited to using an IP Tunnel or separate physical signalling method. The signal message for this protocol are similar in functionality and derived from other similar protocols. Other similar protocols are as follows, but not limitied to: SS7, ISDN, MGCP, SIP, H.323, and H.264 (Megacop) and their derivatives. The application of this kind of signalling protolcol to the management of cable subscriber port status is unique and is not practiced in prior art.
I demand a royalty for use of this Invention. The amount of the royalty is to be determine in the future. The Royalty is based upon equipment subscriber ports both within the United States of America and Internationally. The Royalty payment is to be paid by hardware equipment manufactures upon creation of a device and ports. The hardware equipment manufactures will make a one time payment upon manufacture of said equipment for each port of equipment that can be managed with this Invention. The cable service provider will make a continously reoccuring Royalty payment per subscriber per port per month for each subscriber port within the cable service provider port inventory that can be managed by this Invention. The duration of this payment is forever.
I direct the Royalty payment for this Invention to go towards the support of the Electronic Frontier Foundation or similar appropriate 501(c)3 charity, as directed by the Electronic Frontier Foundation, whose corporate charter is to support digital freedoms both within the United States of America and Internationally.
Sincerely, Kenneth James Long II <signed>
|
 |
|
|
SKozicki
243 Posts |
Posted - 11/01/2003 : 07:51:20 AM
|
Your idea is a great one. Already partially implemented in digital cable, but not fully engineered. Even if it was OOB, there would still be ways of 'hacking' it. There's *always* a way. The point is to increase the time-cost to make it unattractive. This is the tenent of any security application. This goes back to the issue that if the industry wants to thwart piracy, then they need to engineer their services better to reduce it. Not rely on legislation to reduce their investment in R&D.
As a side note, you bring up a good analogy with the telephony system. The change to OOB signalling came for two distinct reasons. One was sheer horsepower. It was difficult to scale switching equipment in an analog world with inband signalling. Call setup times were long and central offices could not keep up with demand for new lines using analog switches. Add to that the cost/performance of digital switching components. But the second catalyst was theft. For cryin out loud, we memorialize this moment by naming the Hacker's Quarterly 2600! Ma Bell was losing a lot of money from 'signal theft' because it was ridiculously easy to hack the signalling. So they moved it out of band and the rest is history. This was in the 60's and 70's, well before divestiture (1984). Of course, deployment was glacial. Even in 1994, I could still find lines in rural areas that could be dropped to the trunk with the proper tones.
But back to the core issue of who is more negligent. I've heard many stories of people who've actually called the SP to tell them that cable was left on by a previous tenant, only to find it still on months later. It's a great point because it demonstrates the folly of this entire issue. The SP industry wants their cake and to eat it too. They don't care about signal theft in the true sense of the word. Existing law is adequate. When you have 60K people who are stealing cable, but you only prosecute .001% of them, you're not interested in solving the problem. They want the ability to 'fight criminal behavior', but they want every consumer out there nursing on the cable TV teat. They are like drug dealers. Sure, some of your customers try and scam you, steal from you, and even try to kill you. But no matter what, you'll still sell to them in the end.
I find it amusing and ironic that if someone shops at WalMart, is thrifty, shops around, uses coupons, and otherwise tries to save money, we admire them and our culture promotes this behavior insidiously through advertising. But if I go out and assemble some parts or technology that enables me to save a few bucks in the services I purchase, suddenly I'm a felon. I've robbed some poor monopoly of the ability to collect an extra $10/month from me and for that I should be drawn and quartered in the town square. |
Edited by - SKozicki on 11/01/2003 08:07:17 AM |
 |
|
|
kelargo
21 Posts |
Posted - 11/03/2003 : 1:27:15 PM
|
>But back to the core issue of who is more negligent. I've heard many >stories of people who've actually called the SP to tell them that >cable was left on by a previous tenant, only to find it still on >months later. It's a great point because it demonstrates the folly of >this entire issue.
Would it be worth gathering emperical data to make the point? |
 |
|
|
SKozicki
243 Posts |
Posted - 11/03/2003 : 2:20:27 PM
|
| It's a great point, but it all boils down to resources and what's worth investing our time in. Since the proponents of the bill have been unable to produce any real data supporting their 'losses' or why they only prosecute .001% of known offenders for stealing cable, it's probably not worth our time and effort to compile the data that you suggest. The burden is on them to prove that they have a problem, and that the current laws are unsatisfactory in solving that problem. |
 |
|
| |
Topic  |
|
|
|