| Author |
Topic  |
|
|
bonkedproducer
3 Posts |
Posted - 02/06/2004 : 1:48:15 PM
|
EDIT AS NEEDED for a good start:
Senator Crutchfield:
As an avid computer user, and support of fair use rights, I am greatly concerned with the so called "Super DMCA" bill that is currently circulating in the Senate under the name SB3101. This is an identical bill to HB3391 circulating in the House.
Like most attempts to pass "bad" legislation, on the face, this bill looks very valuable in preventing theft of service for cable companies, but the wording of the bill brings along some very dangerous side effects that I feel will limit my right to operate a computer system in a safe and secure manner within the state of Tennessee. I am so concerned with this prospect that should it pass, I will be considering moving to another more technologically friendly state, even though I gladly call Chattanooga, Tennessee home.
The text of the bill is far to broad, and is centered around and lobbied for by Time Warner cable (luckily I have a more friendly cable company - Comcast here in Chattanooga) in an attempt to cash in on the fact that the average home will soon have more than one Internet capable appliance, and they wish to be able to charge a service fee for each one that accesses their high speed Internet service. This is as ridiculous as the telephone company being able to charge me twice because I have a telephone in my living room and also in my bedroom.
Currently, most users of high speed Internet service are able to purchase a router at any major electronics chain for less than $100 and be able to share their connection to the Internet within their home using this technology. For example, I own a PC and a Laptop. If I choose to surf the web late at night, I may choose to use my laptop, sit on my porch and enjoy the beautiful Tennessee climate as I do so thanks to the wireless router in my home. Please realize that millions of these products are sold annually in the US. I pay close to $50 a month for the convenience of an always on connection from my cable company. They have no problem with me sharing the data coming into my home via my router. My router further provides a hardware firewall to prevent outside intruders from being able to access my computer fraudulently, something that is already illegal.
Should this bill pass and become law in TN, without written approval from my cable company, my router will become illegal. It will become illegal for me to share information regarding routers, which considering I do quite a bit of consulting on network security would make it impossible for me continue to do so in an effective manner. It would also limit all Tennesseans from being protected from computer crime in a way that the rest of the country is capable of without begging the cable/telco for the right to place these "electronic locks" in place.
For the right for me, an individual, to use more than one device in my home to access the Internet, I would be forced to either break the law, and continue using industry standard tools to prevent outside access into my system, or give up, and run naked to the world without the protection companies like Intel, Cisco, Netgear, Linksys, and hundreds of others provide.
You see one of the dangers with this bill, is it paints with a extremely broad brush, and ignores the fact that the laws currently on the books protect companies like Time Warner Cable from actual fraud, misuse and theft. But they want to be able to put a strangle hold on their customers beyond the monopoly they currently hold and generate revenue from existing customers for purchases of items like Microsoft X-Box's, Internet Capable Home Security Systems, and thousands of other products that would become impossible to use, if not excessively expensive should this bill become law.
Please stop this bill where it stands, Please leave me the right to say I live in a free country, and have a right to own the same devices that the rest of the country is able to legally enjoy. Please provide me the right to my privacy and protection provided by NAT enabled routers. Please let me continue to enjoy my livelihood and be a productive member of society. Cablecos already have enough government protection and consumers lose more rights everyday. Do not contribute to that steady decline.
I implore you to vote down this unjust and frightening bill, and to take the time to educate those you influence as to why this bill is bad, and prevent the countless ones that will follow it.
Please view / for more reasons I do not support this bill, and I fear for the enormous costs that it will bring in enforcing this should it become law and the cost of businesses that decide to move to other states without such broad draconian laws to save money on their communications bills.
Thank You, Paul Couture CONTACT INFO REMOVED
"The consequences of the action are included in the action itself" - Orwell |
|
|
utman
244 Posts |
Posted - 02/06/2004 : 2:43:27 PM
|
Bonkedproducer:
Looks like a very sincere and detailed letter, but some of your points are out of date (this may be because we need to update our reference part of the site).
I'm in a hurry right now but i'll come back and give a more detailed answer soon.
Thanks Jeremy Tunnell |
 |
|
|
Tony
401 Posts |
Posted - 02/06/2004 : 4:16:56 PM
|
The reference parts of the site are updated. I've been checking news items and legislative updates, and adding or updating links, twice or more every day for a while now. We still have references to last year's bill of course, but they are clearly to last year's bill.
The Latest News section on the home page says, "TNDF members are analyzing the bill's language and discussing it in our online forums. Read the bill and join the discussion!" Read the bill. Join the discussion. In that order. I believe it is clear that Paul has done exactly that.
(I have also included references to home networking, encryption, VPN, firewalls, etc. as being threatened by SDMCA-based legislation, not by any particular bill, version or amendment. This comes long after the "Read the bill and join the discussion" line.)
Paul wrote an excellent letter, and I hope his legislators read it entire. It makes several great points, and if it contains some hyperbole, it doesn't contain much. The current bill doesn't make routers, etc. illegal unless they are used to defraud the provider of lawful compensation. If the company has a more expensive level of service for home networks, how will they interpret your Linksys router? And if many customers use routers that can't be controlled and managed by the ISP, might not the ISP interpret that as "substantial electronic harm" to their network under Section (f)? These are real dangers under the vague, overbroad, overreaching language still present even in the current bill.
Regarding website updates and changes: As always, please direct your comments and suggestions for the website to the Technical forum, or to me via email. Thanks!
[ Note: One much-appreciated fellow member has already responded with a suggestion which distills to this: "Chill out! " I apologize if I've been overly defensive about the state of the website, and promise to respond appreciatively to any constructive input that's offered.
I won't edit this post though, since my tirades will gain historical value when I finally lose it and tear the webserver apart with my teeth. ] |
 |
|
|
jody
395 Posts |
Posted - 02/06/2004 : 4:35:31 PM
|
I have no problems with the letter. Personally, I would choose to express myself differently, but this was a freebie to anyone who might otherwise be challenged to come up with something. And he did offer the caveat to "EDIT AS NEEDED".
However, unless and until we get our collective butts together and decide on an official position I think such letters had best be personal and not written on behalf of TNDF or Tennessee Digital Freedom. Which is all the more reason for us to meet soon and make a decision about such things. |
 |
|
|
bonkedproducer
3 Posts |
Posted - 02/06/2004 : 5:00:27 PM
|
Thank you for the comments, and hopefully those out there that need a spring board to get SOMETHING out to your representatives in the TN government, this will be helpful.
I was careful not to state that I represented the TNDF stance on this issue, as my fears come from reading the bill, and the broad brush it paints with. I was stating my personal objections to the bill(s) and my reasons for holding those close to my heart.
I was an Arizona resident when routers cost $500 and @HOME was our only choice, and we were forced to use static IPs and pay $40 for basic high-speed net service and then $15 per additional computer.
In my home that totalled nearly $100 a month even though the majority of the time, there was only one system in use. I see that occurring again once this passes, and I hope I am wrong, but I have little doubt that the cable cos money will buy enough votes to make it happen.
I did my best to explain my viewpoints on the bill, and direct my reps. to this voice to hear YOUR concerns. I support TNDF fully, as you can see at http://paulcouture.com. But when it comes to contacting my government reps, I am going to speak from my heart and mind, not a collective's. I hope we win this one. GET THOSE LETTERS OUT!
Also, whoever is the webmaster here, please contact me via my site, or e-mail, I have some suggestions to make the hot linked banners more useful, I have helped the eff with similar ideas and want to get some thoughts on my ideas. I haven't been in TN that long and only through passing have I seen your site - I want to help!
Now, I'm off to write and article about SCO and myDoom for Groklaw, dang this (TOUNG IN CHEEK FIRMLY)"hacktivism."
"The consequences of the action are included in the action itself" - Orwell |
 |
|
|
utman
244 Posts |
Posted - 02/06/2004 : 6:57:09 PM
|
My point revolved around the fact that we have a brand new bill, that, in my opinion, does not have many of the drawbacks of the previous bill.
For example, only routers used for theft are illegal in this bill, and I frankly have no problem with that.
However, we do appreciate any help we can get. Here's hoping that many more people write letters. |
 |
|
|
bonkedproducer
3 Posts |
Posted - 02/06/2004 : 10:08:45 PM
|
But, say my neighbor figures out how to break my WEP, the burden of proof goes to me to show that I didn't give him the key and let him use my broadband connection. The whole concept of innocent until proven guilty went away a long time ago in this country. So basically wireless routers will beg to be punished.
"The consequences of the action are included in the action itself" - Orwell |
 |
|
| |
Topic  |
|
|
|