| Author |
Topic  |
|
|
Tony
401 Posts |
|
|
Dubber
441 Posts |
Posted - 02/24/2004 : 11:50:02 AM
|
I was at the House Criminal Procedures Subcommittee (of the House Judicial Committee) hearing this morning. 
To sum up, we heard from the Nashville Songwriters Association (forgot name of speaker, he's the President or whatever of the Assn) who pushed for either a Carve Out for Songwriters or a delay in the legislative process while BMI, et al. negotiated with MPAA, &c about their right to access the information being carried in a channel or stream. BMI was asked for several clarifications on *how* they currently do what they do. From the description I (and Briley and several others on the committee) felt it sounded like BMI was breaking the current statutes (and would still be breaking the proposed statute).
Nashville Songwriters dude also brought up Copyright issues & Intellectual Property issues which (I thought to myself) :: were covered in federal statutes which would trump anything the legislature does here.
Duff (BMI) brought up the problem of accessing the content in a digital channel (and again I thought to myself) :: DMCA trumps whatever they want TN to do. Also, BMI has issues with injunctive and locality provisions in the SB3101/HB3391 bill.
During the course of the discussion Briley pointed out our problem with SB213/HB457 where it (and current statute) made NAT routers illegal. He also acknowledged that these are now widely used and shouldn't be illegal. Also Briley brought up subsection (h) on "bottom of page 9" as the defining measure of intent to defraud.
Interestingly, Briley "would encourage everyone to go to Google and search for "Cable Descrambler" to see how easy it is to do" (which makes him guilty of a Class D Misdemeanor under current statute, right? I may have that wrong)
Duff also mentioned that he was at the Study Committee meeting and he did not speak there, as he only received a copy of the proposed bill at the meeting. He said he had not seen any copy on the legislative site prior to that last meeting and therefore felt unable to comment on the bill at that time.
Vice Chairwoman, Brooks, upon seeing BMI's proposed amendatory language, said she would like more time to ask constituents in Memphis for their opinions. Briley then stated that he wanted everyone to be heard *in the House Criminal Procedures Subcommittee* before it was moved on to the Full House Judiciary Committee but that time was getting tight & he wants to get moving on it. He wants to "iron out the details" in the Subcommittee quickly. "This bill has been through the grinder more than any other bill he's been involved with, almost as much a grinder as the budget."
We only heard from BMI & Nashville Songwriter guy today (to the MPAA dude's frustration; Flournoy was in attendance, as was someone else I've forgotten who from Time Warner Cable)
Ran right up against the time limit (relinquished the room, ~3 minutes late) and 3391 was rolled to next week's calendar.
-Aaron W. Dobbs :-)'
PS Briley saw and recognized me (I was in my big flannel overshirt, so I wasn't very subtle) and mentioned me as being part of "Tennessee Digital Freedom Forum." I was acknowledged & was put on the roster of speakers. He said just give him "a nod" at the next committee hearing when I wanted to speak and he'd make sure I was recognized then.
|
 |
|
|
utman
244 Posts |
Posted - 02/24/2004 : 12:12:02 PM
|
| Hmm, are we looking at a change of heart from briley? |
 |
|
|
critch
83 Posts |
Posted - 02/24/2004 : 12:19:05 PM
|
| Well remember Rep. Briley is from the Donelson area. If we can mount such a show of force continually, think we could ruin his and his brother's(?) metro council election runs? |
 |
|
|
Tony
401 Posts |
Posted - 03/02/2004 : 09:27:42 AM
|
| I got an update from Aaron at HHR 30; Anne Carr said that she believes Rep. Briley will defer HB3391 until next week. Further updates as events warrant... |
 |
|
|
Tony
401 Posts |
Posted - 03/02/2004 : 10:17:21 AM
|
| This just in from Aaron: HB3391 has indeed been rolled to next week. Aaron's got other news too, which I'm sure he'll share as soon as he gets to a terminal. We all owe him a big thanks for being there this morning to represent us. |
 |
|
|
Dubber
441 Posts |
Posted - 03/02/2004 : 10:25:45 AM
|
3391 Rolled to next week. Briley & Netwon would like to see our amendment/rewrite asap this week. Nashville folks, who can bring it by and speak briefly with them?! I will if no one else does, but it's a minimum 2 hour round trip for me.
Other "neat" items: 4403 Identity theft -- I think TNDF should look at it (too rushed to see if it's linked already, sorry) and evaluate. Mostly sounded harmless, but that is a flag for me, these days 
forgot number Excize tax on illegal items -- I think this is funny as all get out. If you are naughty, but you get off in court, you can be taxed for the street value of the contraband you possessed at the time of the arrest. rotflmao! Prior art includes reference to the "revinooers" of alcohol enforcement. I worked hard to not laugh out loud. 
Marc Pearl was present from DC for CERC (Consumer Electronics Retailers Coalition) they shared a few comments or suggestions, I don't have a copy but requested a copy from Mike when he gets back to the office later today. Will post & link later.
Duff & NSAI guy (whose name I still need to look up) were present as were our favorite lobbyists for the Cable cos & MPAA. (no, Todd was not present, today)
And that's the way it is... -Aaron W. Dobbs :-)' PS with apologies to Mr. Cronkite  PPS Rick & mdchaney were also there, as was a reporter from the MTSU paper that scooped us all about 3101 this year. Jason was there to cover the taxation of illegal substances, afaik. |
 |
|
|
Scott Lyon
298 Posts |
Posted - 03/02/2004 : 11:45:03 AM
|
| I'd be happy to speak with Briley and Newton this week. I'll try calling their offices this afternoon and setting up an appointment, then posting the details online. |
 |
|
|
Scott Lyon
298 Posts |
Posted - 03/02/2004 : 2:52:38 PM
|
I've got an appointment with Representative Briley tomorrow (3/3/04) at 10:00am at his office (he didn't have any openings on Thursday or Friday). Anyone else who is available is more than welcome to attend (and I'd really appreciate someone more familiar with technical details of cable service delivery to sit in with me, so I have someone to consult if Briley asks any technical questions over my head).
I'll also try to send our draft bill off to CEA and CERC for their responses and just hope they can get back to us with something before the meeting (though it's admittedly short notice). |
 |
|
|
utman
244 Posts |
Posted - 03/02/2004 : 5:18:43 PM
|
| Hey, you might try to give Scott Kozicki a call. He has kinda been MIA but he is very well versed on the technical issues. |
 |
|
|
Tony
401 Posts |
Posted - 03/09/2004 : 11:04:19 AM
|
| HB3391 was rolled to next week again. More details later... |
 |
|
|
Dubber
441 Posts |
Posted - 03/09/2004 : 11:33:50 AM
|
quote: Originally posted by Tony HB3391 was rolled to next week again. More details later...
Long story short is, they pulled most everything after 3391 on the calendar to the front & when Rep Briley didn't show Rep Windle said it rolls to the next meeting. 3391 was the last bill covered today. -Aaron :-)' |
 |
|
|
critch
83 Posts |
Posted - 03/09/2004 : 1:58:08 PM
|
| After the meeting, I went to talk to Rep. Ben West Jr.. He is the Rep for my district. While Rick and I sat there we noticed his sign outside his office was for "Consumer and Employee Affairs". He is listed as chairman. So we played up the arguement about DirectTV and them sueing people but letting them settle for lower costs. We also brought up concerns over the cable cos. shooting down the paying of successful defendants legal bills. He seemed very interested in those arguements. Of course I could have mistook some of his excitement as him being ansy to get to his committee meeting starting right after he saw us. |
 |
|
|
Tony
401 Posts |
Posted - 03/24/2004 : 10:29:46 AM
|
Aaron Dobbs reports that the House Judiciary Committee did not get to HB3391 today. Representative Coleman is sponsoring Vandy's amendment (Tracking# 01329129); Aaron says that the amendment benefits schools and libraries, but "as a consumer, it doesn't do anything for me."
Vanderbilt University Librarian Paul Gherman was present and slated to speak, but did not have the opportunity. Betty Nixon was also there, as was someone from National Public Radio. Further updates and details later. |
 |
|
|
Dubber
441 Posts |
Posted - 03/24/2004 : 11:55:56 AM
|
Thanks for posting that earlier, Tony. I forgot to mention Joe Sweat, ACLU-TN, also had an addition to the BMI/ASCAP amendment basically tightening up the wording: "monitoring activity will be limited to the negotiated agreement between the service providers and the monoitoring agencies." or something really close to that.
I think this is to be sure BMI/ASCAP/etc are not given carte blanche immunity to suits where they overstep themselves. (not that they necesarily would, but just in case -- which, to me, mirrors the MPAA/TN Cable Assn reasoning almost exactly, making it funny)  |
 |
|
| |
Topic  |
|