Tennessee Digital Freedom Forum
Tennessee Digital Freedom Forum
Home | Profile | Register | Active Topics | Members | Search | FAQ
Username:
Password:
Save Password
Forgot your Password?

 All Forums
 Tennessee Technology Legislation
 Legislation
 HB3391 amendment lineup
 New Topic  Reply to Topic
 Printer Friendly
Author Previous Topic Topic Next Topic  

Dubber

441 Posts

Posted - 03/31/2004 :  1:36:14 PM  Show Profile  Visit Dubber's Homepage  Send Dubber a Yahoo! Message  Reply with Quote
Here goes:

BMI proposed amendment (slightly different than the SB3101 adopted amendment ***Which has TN Constitutional Issues! TCA 2.8 specifically addressing no exemptions of companies allowable, period.***)
http://dubber.org/tndf/BMIamendment.rtf
(ACLU-TN would like to see a definition of monitoring included in this to be sure their privacy concerns are addressed)

Intent to Defraud Definition amendment (tightens the definition and really makes the MPAA & Cable guys unhappy - I mean really unhappy)
http://dubber.org/tndf/Intent2DefraudDefinitionAmendment.rtf
(all the examples I came up with (and I thought they were good ones)that I thought I might do inadvertently were explained as legal to my satisfaction)

Vanderbilt/Library/Researchers'(?) amendment (essentially clarifies how copyright law & fair use protects library usage)
http://dubber.org/tndf/V-L-Ramendment.rtf
[link here in a little bit with my comment]

The Hammer Amendment (Rep Briley will introduce this amendment if all the disagreeing parties continue to disagree - if most of the disagreeing parties don't make compromises (most already have an understanding that they *will* compromise further with each other) this will be Rep Briley's fall back position - probably tounge-in-cheek)
http://dubber.org/tndf/TheHammerAmendment.rtf

-Aaron
:-)'

critch

83 Posts

Posted - 03/31/2004 :  2:15:19 PM  Show Profile  Visit critch's Homepage  Reply with Quote
The Intent to defraud language still doesn't bode well for VoIP users.

The intention of most users who use VoIP is to avoid paying some form of bill to Ma'bell. VoIP could be concidered subterfuge depriving Ma'bell of it's lawful compensation for long distance service, or service period.

As an example of this, I used to run a phone system at home that had no connection directly to the PSTN. I used my cable modem to connect to the pbx in my office where it was connected to the PSTN. I then could call anywhere I needed using the corporate phone lines. IT could be said that my company was involved with the retransmital of a communications service and it could be said my actions included subterfuge to keep from paying for home phone service.

Another example, If TNDF where to create a network of users outside of the calling area, and we where to construct a method by which we shared our local phone lines with those who wished to call their representatives in Nashville, We again would be retransmitting our service to someone else to avoid paying the long distance charge.

I still think the wording of the intent to defraud section potentially allows a device the mirrors functionality of a service provider to become illegal if the service provider charges to provide that function.
Go to Top of Page

Scott Lyon

298 Posts

Posted - 03/31/2004 :  2:36:03 PM  Show Profile  Reply with Quote
quote:
Originally posted by Dubber

Here goes:

BMI proposed amendment (slightly different than the SB3101 adopted amendment ***Which has TN Constitutional Issues! TCA 2.8 specifically addressing no exemptions of companies allowable, period.***
http://dubber.org/tndf/BMIamendment.rtf
(ACLU-TN would like to see a definitionn of monitoring included in this to be sure their privacy concerns are addressed)


My view: this is just a BMI CYA amendment and doesn't actually help the situation of the federal pre-emption issue. As far as BMI is concerned, they won't ever be in violation if they engage in conduct permitted by federal copyright law, but the statute is still in conflict, still pre-empted, and no one knows where the line is exactly between federal copyright and state "content protection". If this passes, that means that a judge is going to have to sort all of this out (and maybe rule the statute pre-empted and invalid, in which case we'd have to start all over again). To avoid wasting any more time than necessary, I'd like to avoid this problem.

quote:
Intent to Defraud Definition amendment (tightens the definition and really makes the MPAA & Cable guys unhappy - I mean really unhappy)
http://dubber.org/tndf/Intent2DefraudDefinitionAmendment.rtf
(all the examples I came up with (and I thought they were good ones)that I thought I might do inadvertently were explained as legal to my satisfaction)


My view: The amendment only took out the "accomplice" mens rae, which I'm not really sure about. Under Tennessee law on accomplice liability, I don't think they can get to retailers of devices necessarily (because that requires some action by the accomplice in furtherance of the crime). There is a statute on criminal facilitation (TCA 39-11-403), which provides (summary from my bar review notes) "crime of criminal facilitation occurs when a person, knowing that another intends to commit a specific felony but without the intent needed to be a party, KNOWINGLY furnishes substantial assistance in the commission of a felony (i.e. supplies important items to someone with knowledge that the person will use the items to commit a certain crime." I guess I'm not against the amendment. As for the fraud, deceit, misrepresentation, subterfuge, etc., all of these seem to indicate the sending of false information to a CSP. The question I suppose will be: what kind of behavior constitutes fraud, etc. when you're stealing communications services ("the check's in the mail"?)

quote:
Vanderbilt/Library/Researchers'(?) amendment (essentially clarifies how copyright law & fair use protects library usage)
http://dubber.org/tndf/V-L-Ramendment.rtf
[link here in a little bit with my comment]

This manages to get libraries protected, but doesn't fix any of our free speech/"publish plans or instructions" problems. In a sense, the statute is kind of backwards (if you act with "intent to defraud", you're misrepresenting, etc. (giving false information) to publish plans or instructions, would the plans or instructions have to be false? If they were true and accurate, where is the fraud or misrepresentation?) This is part of the larger issue I have with criminalizing "thiefs" with "suppliers or facilitators of theft", because they're really two separate subjects. But as far as the librarians' amendment is concerned, I don't think it solves any of our real problems (unless, if you want to publish plans or instructions, post them in a non-profit library, I guess).

quote:
The Hammer Amendment (Rep Briley will introduce this amendment if all the disagreeing parties continue to disagree - if most of the disagreeing parties don't make compromises (most already have an understanding that they *will* compromise further with each other) this will be Rep Briley's fall back position - probably tounge-in-cheek)
http://dubber.org/tndf/TheHammerAmendment.rtf


This amendment, though tongue-in-cheek, is actually something to talk about for what it signifies (i.e. wipe the slate clean, start over). Our amendment has been about taking a new look at the problems facing communications and content laws and drafting something which is both fair to providers and consumers. Maybe it is time to wipe the slate clean and start from a different point of view (though obviously, no one wants the subject to go unregulated until we fix it; we need to protect CSP's somehow, but we need that protection to be balanced).

Edited by - Scott Lyon on 03/31/2004 2:37:57 PM
Go to Top of Page

critch

83 Posts

Posted - 03/31/2004 :  2:48:35 PM  Show Profile  Visit critch's Homepage  Reply with Quote
I wonder if that hammer amendment is also a response to the comment I went to Ben West Jr. about. Specifically asking why we needed a state law when the federal government already covered it well. I also bugged him about the DirectTV lawsuits and how close this bill would put us to being in the same boat here.

I need to ping his office again as I haven't received a response yet.
Go to Top of Page

Dubber

441 Posts

Posted - 03/31/2004 :  4:34:44 PM  Show Profile  Visit Dubber's Homepage  Send Dubber a Yahoo! Message  Reply with Quote
btw, the way I wrote up the Hammer Amendment may read too optimistically. I doubt this amendment would get adopted by the committee & it certainly wouldn't pass on the floor.

I also suspect the SB will be replaced outright with the HB at the end of all this, seeing as the SB has Constitutional Questions in it's formulation as noted previously.

-Aaron W. Dobbs
:-)'
Go to Top of Page

Scott Lyon

298 Posts

Posted - 03/31/2004 :  4:35:30 PM  Show Profile  Reply with Quote
To be honest, I'm having trouble thinking of a way to write a communications theft bill which VoIP doesn't run afoul of. The biggest problem is that the phone company charges different rates for long-distance, but you're using local telecomm lines to make long-distance calls.

Now, aside from not paying the phone company long-distance charges, VoIP doesn't actually cause any "harm" per se, but it's still using one kind of system in a different way to achieve a desired result for lower cost to the user by circumventing another system. I'm having trouble figuring out a way to prevent someone from avoiding compensation to a long-distance teleco without making the action an offense for avoiding payment to a cable provider, etc.

Anybody have any suggestions?

Edited by - Scott Lyon on 03/31/2004 4:39:44 PM
Go to Top of Page

critch

83 Posts

Posted - 03/31/2004 :  4:47:21 PM  Show Profile  Visit critch's Homepage  Reply with Quote
I think you hit it right on the head on why this bill needs to be split up into many different paragraphs. Being too generic is what causes unintended consequences.

If you read through the federal law, it has one section for cable theft, it has a different one entirely for telephone service theft, and another one for satelite signal theft. They knew you couldn't write a one size fits all bill. They spent some time drafting up what actions where wrong for each service. Maybe it is time to go in with that problem and say the only way to fix this is to go to summer session again and see if we can write a much more verbose and explicit bill that can treat each and every form of current theft on it's own, then look forward in another section that can aim at technologies that havent been invented yet. This going forward section is the own the MPAA is really interested in anyway, and we can try and look at how a online service could be stolen from.
Go to Top of Page

Dubber

441 Posts

Posted - 03/31/2004 :  8:22:54 PM  Show Profile  Visit Dubber's Homepage  Send Dubber a Yahoo! Message  Reply with Quote
quote:
Originally posted by Scott Lyon
To be honest, I'm having trouble thinking of a way to write a communications theft bill which VoIP doesn't run afoul of. The biggest problem is that the phone company charges different rates for long-distance, but you're using local telecomm lines to make long-distance calls.
Well, technically, you're actually not using local lines to "make long-distance calls" you're using local lines to connect to a service that provides the ability to contact people over an interconnected network of networks ("the internet").
True, the long-distance folks offer a similar service that has been around 70 or so years for a certain price that happens to be higher than this new service. However, that is no reason to say you're "defrauding" the long-distance carrier. That would be like syaing I'm defrauding AT&T of compensation by using Sprint for my long-distance company.
Go to Top of Page

critch

83 Posts

Posted - 03/31/2004 :  9:01:17 PM  Show Profile  Visit critch's Homepage  Reply with Quote
For instate calls that wouldn't leave the Bellsouth network, you are potentially defrauding them of their otherwise lawful compensation. If a call leaves or enters BellSouths network, they normaly get paid a certain amount. So VoIP with PSTN connections run by non phone companies could be also defruading them of their termination fees. There are several possible areas where we could be getting away from paying Bellsouth.
Go to Top of Page

Scott Lyon

298 Posts

Posted - 04/01/2004 :  12:05:45 AM  Show Profile  Reply with Quote
I don't know about VoIP as not fraud under the bill. If you set up a wireless network to share your high-speed connection with other people who hadn't subscribed (and for the sake of argument, let's say you're selling the service at a percentage of what you're paying), the cable companies are arguing that you're "stealing" their service. According to the cable co, they charge each customer a different flat rate.

If you use the local telephone system plus an online service to pass signals across a network, while avoiding the long-distance tolls that normal telephony would incur, I think there's an argument there that one is like the other. We all know that it's not, but where do you draw the generic principles to allow one, disallow the other, and make it clear which is which? Specifically opt out VoIP?
Go to Top of Page

Dubber

441 Posts

Posted - 04/07/2004 :  11:46:14 AM  Show Profile  Visit Dubber's Homepage  Send Dubber a Yahoo! Message  Reply with Quote
The 3 amendments were attached to the bill & it was approved to go to Finance, Ways & Means Committee. I'm out of time on the Public Library computer I'm on, or I would write more.
-Aaron W. Dobbs
:-)'
Go to Top of Page
  Previous Topic Topic Next Topic  
 New Topic  Reply to Topic
 Printer Friendly
Jump To:
Tennessee Digital Freedom Forum © 2003 TNDF.net Go To Top Of Page
Snitz Forums 2000