Tennessee Digital Freedom Forum
Tennessee Digital Freedom Forum
Home | Profile | Register | Active Topics | Members | Search | FAQ
Username:
Password:
Save Password
Forgot your Password?

 All Forums
 Tennessee Technology Legislation
 Message
 Wal-Mart / Industry Council Contact info?
 New Topic  Reply to Topic
 Printer Friendly
Author Previous Topic Topic Next Topic  

Dubber

441 Posts

Posted - 04/25/2003 :  5:21:53 PM  Show Profile  Visit Dubber's Homepage  Send Dubber a Yahoo! Message  Reply with Quote
Who got the Wal-Mart guy's contact info on Tuesday?
Need it ASAP!

Tony

401 Posts

Posted - 04/25/2003 :  6:17:21 PM  Show Profile  Visit Tony's Homepage  Send Tony an AOL message  Send Tony a Yahoo! Message  Reply with Quote
Russell L. Palk
Tennessee Council of Retail Merchants
President
_____________________________

Work: (615) 256-4771
Fax: (615) 256-4773
Mobile: (615) 210-2737
E-Mail: spalk©tnretail·com

Address:
530 Church St
Nashville, TN 37219
Go to Top of Page

Dubber

441 Posts

Posted - 04/29/2003 :  09:23:57 AM  Show Profile  Visit Dubber's Homepage  Send Dubber a Yahoo! Message  Reply with Quote
Here's the result of sharing Mr. Palk's info:
(They have a well thought out letter, imo)
-Aaron
:-)'
(PS the files she references as attachments are also linked)
quote:

Accessable links to Texas created documents (M$ Word):
http://dubber.org/tndf/HB2121-bad-bill.doc
http://dubber.org/tndf/HB2121-Good-Bill.doc
http://dubber.org/tndf/SRAsOnePager.doc
http://dubber.org/tndf/HB2121-AltBill.doc



--original email--
From: Adina Levin <[email protected]>
Subject: Referral request, Walmart representative in Texas, regarding TX version of TN SB213/HB457
Date: Tue, 29 Apr 2003 00:08:56 -0500
To: tndigitalfreedom at dubber dot org

Aaron, here's a copy of what I sent to the Walmart rep.

- Adina

Dear Mr. Palk--

I received your name from a group of technology activists in Tennessee who are working to oppose Senate Bill 213 / House Bill 457.

My colleague Douglas Barnes and I have been working against the Texas versions of these bills, HB2121/SB1116. As you may know from your work in Tennessee, this bill creates sweeping new areas of criminal and civil liability for possession, use or manufacturing of a very
broadly-defined range of communication devices (anything from a telephone to a router to software installed on a computer).

This bill is one of a series of bills being introduced in each state across the country by the Motion Picture Association of America (MPAA). The MPAA is driving this bill, motivated by fears of content piracy. Unfortunately, as it is written, the bill is extremely broad, and is harmful to electronics resellers and manufacturers of computer and consumer electronics products, consumer and business customers.

In Texas, the bill is actively opposed by the Consumer Electronics Resale Association, a consortium of telecom companies and internet service providers, along with consumer and civil liberties groups. In other states, the bill has been actively opposed by the American Electronics Association and the Consumer Electronics Association. We are seeking their support to oppose this bill in Texas as well.

I'll give you a call tomorrow regarding Walmart's position on the bill, and to request for your assistance in locating the Walmart representative who would be working on this issue in Texas.

There is a hearing on the Senate bill next week on Tuesday, May 6th, so the issue is time-sensitive. Following is a summary of the issues with the bill. I've also attached:
* a copy of the most recent version of the MPAA's bill, attached as "CSHB2121 MPAA 42203.doc"
* a fact sheet about the bill, attached as "HB2121 Fact Sheet- Bad Bill"
* a proposed substitute that achieves the bill's goals without harmful side effects, "CSHB2121 0425_03.doc"
* a fact sheet about the substitute, attached as "HB2121 Fact Sheet-Good Bill"

What is wrong with the bill

The bill is incredibly broad. One example is that, if with "intent to defraud a communication service provider" someone "possesses a communication device", they're committing a crime. "Communication service" includes pretty much anything you can think of, plus any service for distributing information over the Internet. "Communication device" includes anything from a telephone to a VCR to software that can connect to a communication service (like RealPlayer).

This has serious implications for industry. Most directly, the bill criminalizes two kinds of device: "unauthorized access devices" (which are simply illegal to possess, ever) and "communication devices" (with some provisions for "intent"). The langauge they use in defining "unauthorized access device" is far less favorable to manufacturers and consumers than the Sony v. Universal language. As I read the bill right now, it arguably outlaws VCRs.

We also believe that this bill would give enormous anti-competitive power to those who provide communication services and the content that's sent over those services. It could arguably allow such providers to dictate the hardware and software that consumers use. This argument has several steps:

1) These new provisions will be primarily enforced through civil litigation, not criminal prosecution. Even if we're successful in removing the special civil provisions, it can still be litigated under the Texas Theft Liability Act.
2) These provisions will then be held to the standards of civil law, not criminal law.
3) Therefore, in a civil case, "intent to defraud" would have to be shown by a preponderance of the evidence, not beyond a reasonable doubt.
4) Under Texas law, "intent to defraud" can be inferred from any of the surrounding circumstances. This can be hard to prove to a criminal jury, but would be much easier to prove to a civil jury.
5) "Surrounding circumstances" could include failure to abide by the Terms of Service of a communication service provider. These terms can --and do -- change with almost every bill you receive. The terms could dictate what kinds of hardware and software you are allowed to connect to the Internet.

The problem for industry then, is this -- those that operate communication services will be able to leverage the fear of litigation or prosecution under these new provisions to engage in a wide range of anti-competitive behavior, such as tying their service to particular hardware and software products.

Please feel free to call me at (512) 632-6829 (cell) or (512) 447-4685 if you have any questions.

Thanks and best regards,

Adina
Go to Top of Page
  Previous Topic Topic Next Topic  
 New Topic  Reply to Topic
 Printer Friendly
Jump To:
Tennessee Digital Freedom Forum © 2003 TNDF.net Go To Top Of Page
Snitz Forums 2000