| Author |
Topic  |
|
|
Dubber
441 Posts |
Posted - 04/25/2003 : 8:59:55 PM
|
From: Adina Levin Subject: Potential industry trouble from TX HB2121 Date: Fri, 25 Apr 2003 18:15:41 -0500 To: standup at peoplesright dot org Cc: tndigitalfreedom at dubber dot org Zack and Jeremy[Aaron, actually], here is:
* a copy of the note we've been using with industry groups * a copy of the substitute bill we've developed, which has Verizon's support * a copy of the Fact Sheet's we've been using to explain why the current bill is bad and why the alternative achieves the goals without the bad side effects.
quote:
Accessable links to Texas created documents (M$ Word): http://dubber.org/tndf/HB2121-bad-bill.doc Fact sheet on Current bill http://dubber.org/tndf/HB2121-Good-Bill.doc Fact sheet on bill Verizon supports http://dubber.org/tndf/SRAsOnePager.doc One Page Summary http://dubber.org/tndf/HB2121-AltBill.doc Possible compromise bill They sent, I posted (and anonymized the letter a little) --Aaron :-)'
--Copy of letter--
Dear [Target association representative]--
[Someone] gave us your contact information.
My colleague Adina Levin and I have been working with ACLU Texas and EFF-Austin against Texas HB2121, a bill that creates sweeping new areas of criminal and civil liability for possession, use or manufacturing of a very broadly-defined range of communication devices (anything from a telephone to a router to software installed on a computer). I've attached the bill as introduced, our fact sheet on the "bad" versions and our "good" version, as well as our proposed "good" version. I've also attached an information sheet that Mr. Schwartz gave us, from the Consumer Electronics Retailers Association.
Please let us know if you have already taken a position on this bill or the MPAA's model legislation, or plan to. We'd like to work with you against this bill, if you decide it's of concern to your membership.
The bill is incredibly broad. One example is that, if with "intent to defraud a communication service provider" someone "possesses a communication device", they're committing a crime. "Communication service" includes pretty much anything you can think of, plus any service for distributing information over the Internet. "Communication device" includes anything from a telephone to a VCR to software that can connect to a communication service (like RealPlayer).
This has serious implications for industry. Most directly, the bill criminalizes two kinds of device: "unauthorized access devices" (which are simply illegal to possess, ever) and "communication devices" (with some provisions for "intent"). The langauge they use in defining "unauthorized access device" is far less favorable to manufacturers and consumers than the Sony v. Universal language. As I read the bill right now, it arguably outlaws VCRs.
We also believe that this bill would give enormous anti-competitive power to those who provide communication services and the content that's sent over those services. It could arguably allow such providers to dictate the hardware and software that consumers use. This argument has several steps:
1) These new provisions will be primarily enforced through civil litigation, not criminal prosecution. Even if we're successful in removing the special civil provisions, it can still be litigated under the Texas Theft Liability Act. 2) These provisions will then be held to the standards of civil law, not criminal law. 3) Therefore, in a civil case, "intent to defraud" would have to be shown by a preponderance of the evidence, not beyond a reasonable doubt. 4) Under Texas law, "intent to defraud" can be inferred from any of the surrounding circumstances. This can be hard to prove to a criminal jury, but would be much easier to prove to a civil jury. 5) "Surrounding circumstances" could include failure to abide by the Terms of Service of a communication service provider. These terms can -- and do -- change with almost every bill you receive. The terms could dictate what kinds of hardware and software you are allowed to connect to the Internet.
The problem for the electronics industry then, is this -- those that operate communication services will be able to leverage the fear of litigation or prosecution under these new provisions to engage in a wide range of anti-competitive behavior, such as tying their service to particular hardware and software platforms.
Please feel free to call me at [phone#] or [phone#] (cell) if you have any questions.
Cheers,
[You]
|
|
|
Dubber
441 Posts |
Posted - 04/29/2003 : 09:13:11 AM
|
More industry groups coming on board elsewhere, whe should contact this one, also...
Consumer Electronics Association contact:
Veronica A. O'Connell Director, Government Affairs Consumer Electronics Association 2500 Wilson Blvd. Arlington, VA 22201 (703) 907-7577 (703) 907-7693 fax <voconnell at CE dot org>
--And the email source - content related specifically to TX bills but transferrable to ours and I believe the last email content is directly usable by us--
From: Adina Levin <alevin at alevin dot com> Subject: [Fwd: Re: Potential industry trouble from TX HB2121] Date: Tue, 29 Apr 2003 08:35:21 -0500 To: "Aaron W. Dobbs" <tndigitalfreedom at dubber dot org>, Zack <standup at peoplesright dot org> Here is a note from the Consumer Electronics Association stating their opposition to the bill, and our reply.
You may want to contact them if you are not working with them already.
- Adina
-------- Original Message -------- Subject: Re: Potential industry trouble from TX HB2121 Date: Tue, 29 Apr 2003 08:33:18 -0500 From: Adina Levin <alevin at alevin dot com> Reply-To: [email protected] To: Veronica Oconnell <voconnell at CE dot org> CC: douglas at salguod dot com
Thanks, Veronica.
This is Adina Levin, working with Doug on TX HB2121/SB1116, with an update on bill status.
There has been a hearing scheduled in the Senate on Tuesday, May 6. Is there a regional representative who might be able to testify at that hearing? A number of the senators are pro-business and CEA's testimony would be persuasive. Otherwise, a fax to the committee members office would be useful.
In the House, a substitute bill has been drafted which does not resolve any of the concerns of consumers, manufacturers or retailers. This bill will likely be voted on in a special committee session. There are a number of members opposed to the bill. A letter faxed to those committee members' offices would help their decision to vote against it. A list of committee members' fax numbers is listed below.
In addition, there are active bills in Florida and Tennessee, with a coalition of groups opposing those bills. Is CEA opposing this bill in those states yet? Tennessee has hearings this week, and Florida has a floor vote, I believe this week.
Thanks for your reply. We look forward to working with you on this issue.
- Adina
Texas Committee Member Fax Numbers <TX phone numbers snipped>
Veronica Oconnell wrote:
Dear Doug,
Thank you for your message. CEA is opposed to the MPAA model legislation and TX HB 2121. We are also concerned about the impact it would have on consumers, manufacturers and retailers. Our concerns are very similar to the concerns you outlined. We also believe that MPAA must provide evidence demonstrating that existing "theft of service" laws are inadequate.
I read some of the reports from the Texas hearing...appeared to be pretty heated. We plan to send opposition letters to Texas. We are also issuing a press release and sending letters to the AR & CO governors requesting a veto.
Thanks again for your message. I look forward to working with you and Adina.
Veronica
Veronica A. O'Connell Director, Government Affairs Consumer Electronics Association 2500 Wilson Blvd. Arlington, VA 22201
|
 |
|
| |
Topic  |
|
|
|